Wednesday, November 25, 2015

An Epistle of Francis to the English

We interrupt our currently scheduled radio silence with a wonderful sermon preached before the General Synod of the Church of England by the Preacher to the Papal Household, Fr. Raniero Cantalamessa, O.F.M. Cap.


The situation has dramatically changed since then. We need to start again with the person of Jesus, humbly helping our contemporaries to experience a personal encounter with Him. “All things were created through him and for him”; Christ is the light of the world, the one who gives meaning and hope to every human life – and the majority of people around us live and die as if He had never existed! How can we be unconcerned, and each remain “in the comfort of our own panelled houses”? We should never allow a moral issue like that of sexuality divide us more than love for Jesus Christ unites us.
or…
Justification by faith, for example, ought to be preached by the whole Church—and with more vigour than ever. Not in opposition to good works – the issue is already settled - but rather in opposition to the claim of people today that they can save themselves thanks to their science, technology or their man-made spirituality, without the need for a redeemer coming from outside humanity. Self-justification! I am convinced that if they were alive today this is the way Martin Luther and Thomas Cranmer would preach justification through faith!
and… let's not forget:
I believe that the Lord wanted me to be among you today, above all to tell you that He is addressing this same message to you, at the inauguration of your Synod and also in view of the meeting planned for next January between the leaders of the entire Anglican communion: “Take courage, Your Majesty, Sovereign of this nation, courage, Justin, Archbishop of Canterbury, courage Sentamu, Archbishop of York, courage, you bishops, clergy and laity of the Church of England! To work, because I am with you. Says the Lord!”

Wednesday, January 21, 2015

Book I, Homily 10 Remixed: You Will Respect The Authorities (Author Unknown)

(1)
Almighty God has created and organized everything in the heavens, on land, and in the ocean most excellently and perfectly. In heaven, he has appointed different kinds and ranks of angels and archangels. On earth, he has assigned and appointed heads of state and government as well as the governors under them in a good and necessary order. Water vapor is dissolved within the atmosphere and condenses into rain and snow at the appropriate time and season. The sun, moon, stars, rainbows, thunder, lightning, clouds, and all birds of the air come into being and behave according to a fixed order, as do plants and animals on land; the divisions of time into years, months, nights, and days; the fish of the sea, as well as the sea itself. All are bound by physical laws and physical limits in a most harmonious order. And each human being has inner and outer parts of his or her body such as the soul, heart, mind, memory, understanding, reason, speech, nose, mouth, limbs etc. in a profitable, necessary, and pleasant order.
            Everyone in their job, calling, and office has a duty and rank. Some rank highly. Some rank lowly. Some are queens, presidents, and prime ministers. Some are trainee associates at big box stores. Clergy and laity; supervisors and subordinates; parents and children; husbands and wives; rich and poor; ranks and callings may differ, but each rank and calling has a need for everyone else. And so the good order of God is worthy of thanks and praise under all circumstances, for no house, city, or commonwealth can survive without it. Where right order does not reign, every abuse, liberty of the flesh, atrocious crime, sin, and Babylonian confusion reigns instead. If you were to take away queens, presidents, prime ministers, legislators, judges, and similar offices in God’s order, no one would be able to travel without being robbed; no one would be able to sleep in their own house or bed without being murdered; and no one would be able to have property or a family life unmolested. Instead, everything would belong to whomever would take it, and from this involuntary sharing would follow every mischief until there was utter destruction of souls, bodies, property, and commonwealths.
             Blessed be God that we in the United Kingdom do not experience the horrible calamities, miseries, and wretchedness that all who lack this godly order of government experience. And praise God that we know how richly God has blessed us in placing us here. God has sent us His high gift, our most dear Sovereign Lady Queen Elizabeth who has the godly, wise, and honorable counsel of her own mind as well as that of the superior and inferior officials of Her Majesty’s Government and Loyal Opposition in a beautiful and good order. And therefore, let us her subjects do our duties, thanking God and praying for the preservation of this godly order. Let us all obey from the bottom of our hearts all of their godly proceedings, laws, statutes, proclamations, and injunctions as well as all their other godly orders. Let us  consider the Scriptures of the Holy Spirit, which persuade and command us to obey, first and principally to Her Majesty the Queen, Supreme Governor over all, and next to her Privy Council, and to all other officials of government, who God’s goodness has placed over us.
            For Almighty God is the only creator and provider of the state and order of government, as it is written of God in Proverbs, “Through Me kings reign, through Me counselors make just laws, through Me princes wield authority, and all of the judges of the earth execute judgment. I love those who love me.” (Prov. 8:15-17). Here let us pay close attention and remember that the high power and authority of governments and their making of laws, judgments, and official appointments are the ordinances, not of human beings, but of God; and therefore this phrase, “Through me” is so often repeated. Here we also should consider and remember carefully that this good order was organized by God’s wisdom, favor, and special love for those who love God: and therefore He says, “I love those who love me.”
            Also in the Book of Wisdom, we learn that the power, authority, and strength of a king is a great benefit of God: a great mercy intended to comfort our great misery, “Hear, O you kings and understand; learn, you that are judges in the remotest places of the earth; listen carefully, you that rule great nations; the power you have was given to you by the Lord and your strength comes from the Highest” (Wisd. 6:1-3). Let the infallible word of God teach us here that kings and other supreme and higher officials are appointed by God, who is the Most High; and therefore, they are commanded by these words to seek knowledge and wisdom about how they can best govern those whom God has committed to their care. And they are additionally taught that their power and strength does not come from any authority on Earth but directly from God Most High.
            The Book of Deuteronomy tells us that all punishment is the prerogative of God, saying “Vengeance is mine, and I will repay” (Deut. 32:35). But we should interpret this sentence to pertain also to judges and all who enforce the law, who judge and punish in place of God according to good and godly laws. And the examples in Scripture which appear to forbid judgment, punishment, or killing to Christians should be interpreted to mean that no one of their own private authority should judge, punish, or kill another person. Instead, we should leave judgment to God, governments, and the law courts, to which God has delegated the execution of justice. Scripture clearly says that God has given to governments their authority and monopoly upon violence, as we are taught by St. Paul, the dear and chosen Apostle of our Savior Christ, whom we should obey as we would our Savior Christ, if He were present.
St. Paul writes to the Romans, “Every person must submit to the authorities in power, for all authority comes from God, and the existing authorities are instituted by Him. It follows that anyone who rebels against authority is resisting a divine institution, and those who resist have themselves to thank for the punishment they will receive. Governments hold no terrors for the law-abiding but only for the criminal. You wish to have no fear of the authorities? Then continue to do right and you will have their approval, for they are God’s agents working for your good. But if you are doing wrong, then you will have cause to fear them; it is not for nothing that they hold the sword, for they are God’s agents of punishment bringing retribution on the offender. That is why you are obliged to submit. It is an obligation imposed not merely by fear of retribution but by conscience. That is also why you pay taxes. The authorities are in God’s service and it is to this that they devote their energies” (Rom. 13:1-6).
Here let us all learn from St. Paul, the chosen vessel of God (Acts 9:15), that every person with a soul (he excuses none, nor exempts none, neither priest, apostle, nor prophets says St. John Chrysostom) are morally obligated to obey, submit, and be subject to the high powers set in authority by God, for they are God’s deputies, God’s presidents, God’s officials, God’s commissioners, and God’s judges, ordained by God Himself, from whom they derive all of their power and authority. And the same St. Paul threatens the extreme penalty of eternal damnation to all disobedient people, to all who resist this general and common authority, for these people do not resist human beings; they resist God. They do not resist something of human creation and ingenuity; they resist something created by God’s wisdom, God’s order, power, and authority.

(2)

We taught in the first part of this Homily concerning good order and obedience that God has created and arranged all things in a beautiful order, so we should maintain all commonwealths in a similarly good and beautiful order by obeying those in power, their ordinances and laws; and that all rulers have been appointed by God to keep the world in godly order; and also how government officials should learn how to rule and govern according to God’s laws; and that all subjects are bound to obey the authorities as the delegates of God; yes, even if they are evil, not only out of fear, but as a moral duty.
            And here, my friends, let us be very clear that it is not lawful for inferiors or subjects to ever resist those in authority, for St. Paul’s words are plain, “that whoever rebels against authority is resisting a divine institution” (Rom. 13:2). Our Savior Christ himself and his Apostles were wronged and injured by the unfaithful and wicked men in authority in their day, yet we never read that any of them caused any sedition or rebellion against authority. We often read that they patiently suffered all troubles, nuisances, slander, pain, suffering, and death itself obediently, without inciting others or breaching the peace themselves. They “delivered [themselves] to Him who judges justly” and prayed for their enemies deeply and authentically (1 Pet. 2:23). [Ed.: The passage refers specifically to Christ, but the Homilist cites it as the conduct of the Apostles generally.] They knew that God ordained the authority of the government; and therefore, both in their words and actions, they always taught people to obey it and never taught the opposite.
            The wicked judge Pilate said to Christ, “’Do you not know that I have the power to put you to death and the power to acquit you?’ Jesus answered, “You could have no authority over me if it had not been given to you from above” (Jn. 19:10-11). With these words, Christ clearly taught us that even wicked rulers have power and authority given to them by God. And therefore it is not lawful for their subjects to resist them by force, even if they abuse their power, even less so is it lawful for subjects to resist their godly and Christian rulers, who do not abuse their authority, but use their power to glorify God and promote the welfare of God’s people.
            The holy Apostle St. Peter commands servants to obey their masters, “not only those who are kind and forbearing, but even to those who are unjust,” (1 Pet. 2:18-19) affirming that God’s people are called to be patient and suffering. And St. Peter even invokes the patience of our Savior Christ to argue for obedience to governors, yes, even if they are wicked criminals. But let us now hear St. Peter himself speak in his first Letter, for his own words should give us confidence in our doubts, “Servants, obey your masters with all due respect, not only if they are kind and forbearing, but even those who are unjust. It is a sign of grace in the sight of God when you have endured suffering for behaving well. And indeed what praise do you deserve for enduring punishment patiently when you have deserved it? But when you do well and suffer wrong but endure it patiently, you will have God’s grace. This indeed is your vocation, because Christ suffered on your behalf and left an example for you to follow” (1 Pet. 2:18-21).
            David also teaches us a good lesson about obeying rulers who wrong you. King Saul very often cruelly and wrongly persecuted him, and indeed King Saul and his deputies tried to kill David on many occasions. Yet David never disobeyed King Saul, nor did he use any force or violence against his mortal enemy but truly, diligently, and faithfully served King Saul as his ruler and master (1 Sam. 18-20). In fact, when the Lord handed Saul into David’s power in David’s own cave, David would not hurt Saul, even though he could have killed Saul easily without any danger to himself (1 Sam 24). No, indeed, he would not even allow any of his servants to capture King Saul but prayed to God in this way, “God forbid that I should harm my master, the Lord’s anointed, or lift a hand against him. He is after all the Lord’s anointed…As the Lord lives, the Lord will strike him down, either his time will come and he will die, or he will go down to battle and meet his end. God forbid that I should lift my hand against the Lord’s anointed” (1 Sam. 24:4-7, 26:10-11). [Ed.: The Vulgate puts the verses from Chapter 26 in Chapter 24 in some manuscripts.] And that David had the opportunity to kill Saul is clearly proved here by David’s ability to cut off a piece of Saul’s clothing as well as Saul’s own admission.
            In another incident in the First Book of the Prophet Samuel, King Saul unmercifully and unkindly persecuted David and God again gave King Saul into David’s hands by putting King Saul and his whole army into a deep sleep, so that David and his soldier Abishai went in the midst of Saul’s army, where Saul was sleeping, and “his spear was thrust into the ground beside his head. Then Abishai said to David, ‘God has put your enemy into your power today. Let me strike him and pin him to the ground with one thrust of the spear. I shall not have to strike twice,” intending to kill Saul with one stroke and do away with him forever. And David then repeated much of the speech he had in the cave and said, “But now let us take the spear by his head and the water-jar and go” (1 Sam. 26:11), and so he did. These incidents clearly demonstrate that we may not resist or in any way hurt an anointed king, who is God’s deputy, vice-regent, and highest minister in the country where he is king.
            But some might object that David might have justifiably killed Saul in self-defense. But holy David did know that he should not in any way resist, hurt, or kill his sovereign lord and king: he did know that he only King Saul’s subject, even though he was a great favorite of God and King Saul was an object of divine displeasure. Therefore, even though David was greatly provoked, he utterly refused to hurt the Lord’s anointed. He did not dare offend God and his own conscience (although he had at least two opportunities) to lay his hands upon God’s high officer, the king, because he knew that the king was a person accountable only to God for punishment and judgment. Therefore, he prayed so often and earnestly that he should never lay his hands upon the Lord’s anointed. And by these two examples, David, being named in Scripture, “a man after God’s own heart” (e.g., 1 Sam. 13:14) hands down a general rule and lesson to all subjects in the world not to resist their lord the king (or equivalent head of state), not to take up arms by their private authority against their king, God’s anointed; who holds the monopoly upon violence by God’s authority, for the maintenance of the good and punishment of the evil; whose ability to exercise that monopoly is according to God’s law; and also possesses all power, jurisdiction, rule, coercion, and punishment as supreme governor of all his realms and dominions by the authority of God and God’s ordinances.
            Yet another notable story and teaching relevant to obedience to the government is in Second Samuel. An Amalekite killed King Saul after King Saul commanded him to do so. This Amalekite then went to David, expecting David ‘s gratitude and reward for having killed his deadly enemy. And so this Amalekite rushed to tell David the news and brought Saul’s crown and bracelet to prove the kill. But godly David did anything but rejoice at the news. He tore off his clothes, mourned, and wept, saying to the Amalekite, “How is it that you were not afraid to raise your hand to kill the Lord’s anointed?” (2 Sam. 1:14). He then commanded one of his servants to kill the Amalekite, saying, “Your blood be on your own head; for out of your mouth you condemned yourself by saying, ‘I killed the Lord’s anointed.’”
            These examples are so obvious that it is unbearably ignorant, mad, and wicked for subjects to make any murmuring, rebellion, resistance, commotion, or insurrection against their most dear and honorable Sovereign Lord and King, ordained and appointed by the goodness of God for their benefit, peace, and quietness.
            Yet let us believe without any doubts, my friends, that we may not obey kings, presidents, or any other official, though they are our own fathers, if they command us to do any thing contrary to God’s commandments. In such a case, we ought to say with the Apostles, “We must obey God rather than men” (Acts. 5:29). But nevertheless in that case, we may not in any way violently resist or rebel against rulers or make any insurrection, sedition, or breach of the peace, either by force of arms or other ways against the anointed of the Lord or any of his appointed officers; but we must in that case patiently suffer all wrongs and injuries, referring the judgment of our cause only to God. Let us fear the terrible ways that Almighty God has punished traitors or rebels such as Korah, Dathan, and Abiram, who showed contempt for and complained against God’s magistrates and officers, and therefore the earth opened and swallowed them up alive (Num. 16:1-33). Others were punished by a fire from God because of their complaining (Num 11:1). Miriam tried to undermine Moses’s authority and was suddenly struck with foul leprosy for her rebellion against God’s minister (Num. 12). Others were bitten by venomous snakes (Num. 21:6). Others were struck by plague so that 14,700 were killed in a day for their rebellion against Moses and Aaron, whom God had put in charge (Num. 16:41-29). Absalom, also, in rebellion against his father King David was punished with a strange and notable death (2 Sam. 18:9).

(3)

You have heard in the previous parts of this Homily about good order and obedience, for I have clearly demonstrated from the Scriptures and examples that all are bound to obey the political authorities in the countries in which they live and have no good reason to resist, rebel, or call for rebellion against them. Yes, even if they are wicked people. And let no one think that they can escape unpunished if they commit treason against their nation and its rulers, even if they commit treason in the utmost secrecy in thought, word, or deed. Even if they do so in the most secret recesses of their bedrooms by themselves or else openly communicating and conspiring with others, they will not escape punishment. For treason cannot remain hidden; treason will be revealed in full. God will ensure that that most detestable vice will come to light and be punished; for it is so directly aimed against His ordinance and his chief judges and anointed governors upon the earth. The violence and injury that is committed against authority is committed against God, the common good, and the entire nation; which God will ensure is detected and punished appropriately in one way or another. For the Wise Man of the Scriptures writes in Ecclesiastes, “Do not revile the king in your thoughts nor speak ill of him in your bedroom, for a bird in the sky may carry your words and a bird on the wing may report what you say” (Eccles. 10:20).
            These lessons and examples were written to instruct us. Let us all therefore fear the most detestable vice of rebellion, ever knowing and recalling that whoever resists the authority of the community resists God and his ordinance, as it may be demonstrated in many other parts of Holy Scripture.
            And here let us make sure that we do not confuse Scriptural injunctions about lawful obedience to superiors and punishment for rebellion and disobedience to suggest anything relevant to the pretended authority of the bishop of Rome. For truly the Scripture of God does not allow the abusive usurpation of power, but extols and proclaims God’s true will that anointed kings and the officers under them should be the authorities. And concerning the assumed power of the bishop of Rome, which he most wrongfully claims as the successor of Christ and Peter, we may easily determine how false, pretended, and forged it is. It lacks any ground in Holy Scripture and results in bad fruit and doctrine as well. For Our Savior Christ and St. Peter earnestly and consistently teach that kings should be obeyed as the chief and supreme rulers in this world under God, but the bishop of Rome teaches that those under him are free from all obligations and responsibilities to the commonwealth as well as obedience to the authorities, which is most clearly against Christ’s teaching and St. Peter’s. [Ed.: The Pope certainly does not teach anything quite this bold anymore.] He should therefore be called Antichrist and the successor of the Scribes and Pharisees rather than Christ’s vicar or St. Peter’s successor; because on this point and on other important matters of Christian religion such as the remission and forgiveness of sins and salvation itself, he teaches so directly against both St. Peter and our Savior Christ: who not only taught obedience to kings, but also practiced obedience in their conversation and living; for we read that they both paid tribute to the king (Matt. 17:24-27). [Ed.: No, no, no, no. That’s not what that passage says, at all, especially in its plain meaning.]
And we also read that the holy Virgin Mary, mother of our Savior, and Joseph (his reputed father), went to Bethlehem, the city of David, in obedience to an Imperial decree. There, they were taxed and declared their obedience to the magistrates for the sake of God’s commandments (Lk. 2:7). [Ed. The Biblical text just says that they were registered or assessed.] And let us not forget the Virgin Mary’s obedience here. She was highly favored by God, the biological mother of the Christ, and so heavily pregnant that she went into labor on the journey. Yet she gladly and ungrudgingly took that cold and foul winter journey for the sake of conscience. Indeed, they were so poor that she lay in a stable, where Christ was born. [Or Jesus was born in the front room of the typical Palestinian home, where there were feeding troughs for animals. That fits the Greek, too.]
            And St. Peter supports this obedience, writing explicitly in his first Letter, “Submit yourselves to every human authority; whether to the emperor, as the supreme authority, or to governors, who are sent by him to punish those who do wrong and praise those who do right, for it is God’s will…” (1 Pet. 2:13-15). St. Peter did not say, “Submit yourselves to me as supreme head of the Church,” nor did he say, “Submit yourselves from time to time to my successors in Rome,” but he says submit yourselves unto your emperor (or king) as the supreme authority and to those that he appoints to be exercise authority under him. For it is God’s will that you should show your obedience to your head and king. This is God’s ordinance, God’s commandment, and God’s holy will that the whole body of every nation, and all the members and parts of the same, should be subject to the supreme authority in that nation; and that, as St. Peter writes, “for the Lord’s sake” and as St. Paul writes, “for conscience’s sake” and not only out of fear of punishment.
            Thus God’s word teaches us to yield to our king (or head of state) what is due to our king, that is, honor; obedience; payments of due taxes, customs, tribute, and subsidies; love; and fear.

            Thus we know in part the duty we owe to the authorities that govern us: now let us learn to accomplish the same. And let us immediately and heartily pray to God the source of all authority for all of those that are in authority, as St. Paul commands in his First Letter to Timothy, “First of all, I urge you that prayers, supplications, intercessions, and thanksgiving may be made for all, for kings, and for all that are in authority, that we may live a quiet and peaceful life with all godliness and honesty, for that it is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Savior” (1 Tim. 2:1-3). Here, St. Paul makes an earnest and special exhortation concerning giving thanks for and praying for kings and rulers, saying, “first of all,” as he might say. Or at any rate, he means that the principal and chief prayers should be made for kings and other heads of state. Let us heartily thank God for the great and excellent gift and provision he has made to and for us by giving us kings and other heads of state. Let us pray that they may have God’s favor and protection. Let us pray that they may have God before their eyes in all that they do. Let us pray that they may have wisdom, strength, justice, clemency, and zeal for God’s glory, God’s truth, Christian souls, and the common good. Let us pray that they correctly use their sword and authority for the maintenance and defense of the catholic faith contained in the Holy Scriptures, the protection of their good and honest subjects, and the frightening and punishment of their evil and vicious people. Let us pray that they may faithfully follow the example of the most faithful kings and captains in the Bible: David, Hezekiah, Josiah, Moses, and others like them. And let us pray that we may live godly lives in a holy and Christian walk, so that we will have God on our side. Then let us not fear what human beings can do to us. So shall we live in true obedience, both to our most merciful King in heaven, and to our most Christian Queen on Earth. So shall we please God and have great benefits, such as peace of conscience, rest, and quietness in this world; and shall enjoy a better life, rest, peace, and the everlasting bliss of heaven afterwards. For this we are granted by Him who was obedient for us all, even to death on a cross (Phil. 2:8), Jesus Christ; to whom with the Father and the Holy Ghost, be all honor and glory, both now and forever. Amen.      

Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Why the Next Homily is Delayed: A Brief Reflection on Obedience to Authority

The next Homily in the series is "An Exhortation Concerning Good Order and Obedience to Rulers and Magistrates." I am having a great deal of trouble with it on a variety of levels.

First, I am encountering unusual difficulties in translating the context of the 16th century to the 21st century. Oddly enough, the one anointed monarch left in the western world is also Queen Elizabeth and rules the same realm ruled by her predecessor in the original text. At the same time, the Homilist seems to assume the necessity of governance by an anointed king or somewhat equivalent monarchical ruler, which does not seem entirely justified by the Scriptures (see 1 Samuel 8) and is also not the situation for a vast majority of the world's Anglicans, particularly in the Global South. Somehow, I doubt the Homilist would have felt the same way about a Muslim President of Nigeria.

Second, I recognize this Homily as one that would have been severely edited in any edition of the Homilies made by Americans in the early days of the Episcopal Church, as the 1789 Articles of Religion promised. It seems almost unpatriotic to handle this text, since it condemns the very foundations of our commonwealth. (Also, it makes any denomination with historical connections to the execution of Charles I and a doctrine of Biblical inerrancy look hypocritical. The interactions between David and Saul are quite apropos to thinking through the English Civil War.)

Third, it accuses the Pope of a variety of things that was probably true of the Pope at the time but is not now and calls him nasty names that were probably as inappropriate then as they certainly are now.

Fourth, the exegesis in at least one place contradicts the Biblical text to such an extent as to be risible. I understand how to hold two contradictory interpretations of Mark 12:17. In no universe do I live in does Matthew 17:24-27 suggest that Peter and the Lord Jesus "paid tribute to the king." (Though it is a relevant passage to the subject, which I do not recall ever hearing preached upon.)

Fifth, it is hard to face a world that has seen the horrors of Nazi Germany, Stalin's Russia, Pol Pot's Cambodia, Showa-era Japan, and a variety of other state-sponsored atrocities with the good news of "submitting to every ordinance of man for the Lord's sake" (1 Peter 2:13). When the commonwealth is functional (for you at least), I understand the compulsion to defend its stability and the lives of friends and relations with the justification of Divine Providence. However, just as anointed kings are few and far between (the distance between Westminster and Samoa…), the commonwealth is not always functional and perform the great Petrine function of governors, "the punishment of evildoers and for the praise of them that do well."

Just as we cannot evaluate the respect due to the political authorities we have today in light of a theology that privileges anointed kings, we cannot give the political authorities the respect required by an absolutist theology of political authority partly justified by the difficult political conditions of Tudor England without raising the spectre of German evangelical quietism in the face of the Holocaust. We may lionize Bonhoeffer and the White Rose, but we rarely examine whether the Nazis co-opted German Protestants ideologically or simply cowed them theologically.

I, of course, will put out a remix of the Homily. In a perfect world, I'd completely rewrite it. But that defeats the point of the project. Instead, I'll outline here what a rewrite would look like.

The actual Homily begins with an assertion that the created world is in a perfect and hierarchical order. To paraphrase Frank Herbert, a place for every thing and everything in its place. It is difficult for me to maintain this view in light of the mechanisms of biological, geological, and astronomical evolution, particularly. I probably would say that creation is good, yet incomplete on account of the disobedience of our first parents and so the order we see in creation is a shadow of the perfect order that God intended and would seek that we imitate.

I then would say that just as we see the necessity of diversity in biological contexts, we see that God is open to diversity in political systems by citing 1 Samuel 8 (monarchy is not the one divinely ordained political system) and Exodus 18:13-27 and Deut. 1:12-18 (a primitive republic for Israel).

And then I'd discuss Christian duty regarding political authority by starting with 1 Timothy 2:1-4. The interpretation I'd give is that Christian respect for the idea of the commonwealth and temporal authority is founded on: (1) God's generosity to all in Christ and (2) the necessity of being able to proclaim and live out that proclamation in daily life. We seek the space from rulers to live quietly, peaceably, honestly, and according to the will of God as we understand it. And while we still can hold the position that others displease God in ways that do not harm us (or every activity of their heathen lives, if you prefer), the Lord enjoins us to love our neighbors as ourselves (Matt. 22:39) and do unto others as you would have them do unto you (Lk. 6:31). We therefore are obligated to pray for and seek the space to live quietly, peaceably, honestly, and according to their understanding of the right to all of our neighbors. And if you doubt the generosity to non-believers in this, you should re-read Luke 10:25-37 and call me in the morning. The ability to freely receive and hear the Gospel is necessary.

Next, I would perform the extraordinary task of placing Romans 13 and 1 Peter 2 into context by emphasizing that both passages describe functional commonwealths in which evildoers are punished and those who do right are rewarded (or at least left alone). This idea requires us to think a little differently about the Roman Empire than we are accustomed to doing. However, I will point out that Jesus shows very little animus to the Romans in his teaching. He heals the slave of a centurion (Lk. 7:1-10). His forerunner, John the Baptist, tells soldiers (possibly Roman or at least working for them) to avoid extortion and be satisfied with their compensation (Lk. 3:14). I could keep going with Paul's use of the privileges of Roman citizenship (Acts 22:23-28) to the revelation of the availability of salvation to the Gentiles through the household of a centurion (Acts 10).

Our current exegetical mindset poses Rome as the Evil Empire Jesus could not criticize for fear of being executed too early. Any favorable treatment is interpreted as later emendation to reduce political suspicion. I wonder if it is possible that Jesus considered the problems of Judea under Roman rule to be beneath His notice, much like the inheritance dispute He refused to judge in Luke 12:14. Maybe, we should take Him seriously when He says that "my Kingdom is not of this world. If it were, my servants would have fought to keep me from being handed over to you" (John 18:36). The disappointment of the Jerusalemites at the Passover was that Jesus had not come to liberate them from Roman occupation. There is nothing direct in the Biblical witness to suggest that Jesus preached strongly for or against the political authorities of his day. Satan had tempted Him with control of them, and He replied, "Worship the Lord your God and serve only Him" (Lk. 4:8).

The only points where Jesus might be making a critique of Roman power require deep context. Jesus casts out a demon named Legion in the country of the Gadarenes or Gerasenes (Matt. 8:28-34; Mark 5:1-17), where there might have been a Roman garrison (or not…we are unsure where this incident took place). In another case, Jesus takes a Roman coin and asks, "whose image is this and what is it labeled?" When they reply, "Caesar's," he says "Render to Caesar what is Caesar and to God what is God's." (Lk. 20:24-25). Yes, Tiberius Caesar is claiming to be the son of a god on the coin, but the incident can be read as a spiritual critique rather than one of political authority. Jesus seems more concerned with the greed of tax collectors rather than the collection of taxes.

Therefore, I'd emphasize that Christian teaching concerning how to respond to oppressive political authority begins with "don't sweat the small stuff." The best examples would be the incident in Luke 20 as well as Matthew 17:24-27. In the later example, Peter and Jesus are asked to pay the temple tax. Jesus makes the theological point that no one taxes their children, so the children of God are exempt from taxes to God, i.e., the temple tax. But he informs Peter that, "So we do not cause offense," our tax money can be found in a local fish, catch the fish and pay the man. On one hand, the idea that Christians are children of God (or that Jesus is the Son of God) is fundamental Christian theology. On the other hand, Jesus acts against this crucial theological principle so as not to cause offense.

So the summary of the first part of my homily would be: the teaching of Jesus, Paul, and Peter all suggest that there is such a thing as a functional political system, it has certain purposes ordained by God as common grace, it has certain purposes that support the church and its mission, and its imperfections should be tolerated to a point. In the latter case, functional political systems are entitled to a high level of respect, no matter their offense to our theological principles, as long as we still can believe them and proclaim them. Note that Jesus did not stop saying He was God's Son.

The second part would focus on evaluating dysfunctional political systems. Here I would make the extraordinary claim that our standard should focus particularly on how non-Christians, the sick, and the disabled are treated. Partially, this idea is based on the experience of Nazi Germany. Partially, this idea is founded on Luke 6, where Jesus "breaks the Sabbath" to heal and commands radical love for enemies in verses 27-36. I would argue that we should be concerned with systems where evildoers are rewarded and those who live peaceably, quietly, and honestly are punished, and I would rely mostly on the passages discussed in the first part.

The original Homily focuses on the relationship between David and Saul, particularly how David did take the opportunity to kill Saul after Saul tried to kill David. In the third part, I'd use these incidents as a way to discuss why non-violent and/or sacrificially forceful resistance should be the first response of Christians to dysfunctional political systems, again referring to Luke 6:27-36 and Romans 12:19-21.          In other words, Christians should resist dysfunctional political systems in ways that protect the lives of others even at the cost of their own.
       

Tuesday, December 02, 2014

Book I, Homily 9 Remixed: Fear God, Not the Reaper (Author Unknown)

(1)
It should be no surprise that we fear death in proportion to our interest in power, fame, and fortune. Death deprives us of our job titles, bank accounts, and every other possession from which we try to extract happiness. If we have these things in the proportions we desire, we consider ourselves to be happy. But if we lose some or all of what we possess and see no hope of retrieving them, we then easily become unhappy. “FML,” thinks the person focused entirely on ambition and acquisition, “will I now depart forever from my titles, treasures, beloved country, friends, bank accounts, investments, and all the good things I like that can money can buy, which are the joy and delight of my heart? FTS, that the day should come when I should say goodbye to all that and never enjoy it ever after!”
            Indeed, Ben Sirach is justified when he writes, “O how bitter and sour is it for a man lives in peace and prosperity in his own property, living in leisure as he chooses without trouble, pampered and well-fed, to recall that he must die” (Ecclus. 41:1).
            The world does not smile upon us all, of course. Some of us suffer because of poverty, illness, or other adversities. And these unfortunates fear death as well, because our bodies naturally dislike the prospect of inactivity, decay, and dissolution which death promises them. Or they fear death because of the horrible pain often precedes death, particularly during chronic and lingering illnesses.
            These two reasons to fear death seem big and important to us, yet we should fear death for a reason much more important than the ones I have given. Our interest in power, fame, and fortune and concern for the pleasure and integrity of our body without repenting for our sins and allowing our life to be changed by grace puts us at risk of a state and condition after death known as “the second death” (Rev. 21:8), which will come to all of the unrepentant after the first death of the body. And this is the death that should terrify us, for that death will bring the irretrievable loss of the grace and favor of God, eternal joy, pleasure, and happiness. And this is not all. Those who experience the second death not only lose these eternal pleasures but also are condemned without hope of redemption to the eternal punishment of hell.
Into this state death sent the unmerciful and ungodly rich man described in the Gospel of Luke (Lk. 16:19-31), who living in all wealth and pleasure, indulged himself with haute cuisine and haute couture and despised poor Lazarus, who lay at his gate seeking pity while sick, starving, and covered with sores. Both these men died. Angels took Lazarus, the poor sufferer, to Abraham’s bosom, a place of rest, pleasure, and healing. But the unmerciful rich man descended into hell; and cried out for comfort in the midst of his suffering, complaining of the intolerable pain that he suffered in the flames of fire. But it was too late. So it is to hell that the death of our bodies sends all those that have had joy and happiness in this world but have not been faithful to God or loving to their neighbors and so have died without repentance and hope of God’s mercy. Therefore, it should be no surprise that we fear death; many of us have much more cause to do so than we believe.
 I have described three reasons why we might fear death: (1) because death will cause us to lose what power, fame, and fortune we have gained in this life and the pleasures that come with it; (2) because horrible pain often precedes death; but the third and chief reason is fear of the eternal condemnation and punishment of body and soul, which we fear will follow our departure from the pleasures of this present life.
            The Scriptures tell us that our very fear of death has enslaved us to the pursuit of the pleasures of the world alone, so that we fall into sin (Heb. 2:15). But we should be forever grateful to God that neither one of these causes nor all of them put together should make Christians fear death, for Christians are the very limbs of Christ, the temple of the Holy Spirit, children of God, and heirs of the everlasting kingdom of heaven (1 Cor. 3:16; 6:19).
Instead, there are many significant reasons undoubtedly grounded upon the faultless and eternal truth of God’s word that should encourage Christians to have no fear of bodily death. And indeed because of the many benefits and opportunities created by death, Christians should wish, desire, and long enthusiastically for death. For death to a Christian is no death at all but indeed a rescue from death, from all of the pain, anxiety, sadness, and imperfection of this world, and the beginning of rest, eternal joy, and the tasting of heavenly pleasures so great that tongue is not able to express, eye is unable to see, ear cannot hear, nor anyone living in the created worlds can imagine them (1 Cor. 2:9). These are the exceedingly generous benefits that God our heavenly Father, out of his one way merciful love for the human species and out of His love for Son Jesus Chris Christ, has prepared for those who humbly submit to God’s will, and truly love Him from the bottom of their hearts each and every day.
            And we should believe that death, having been destroyed by Christ, cannot keep anyone that steadfastly trusts in Christ under its perpetual tyranny and subjection. Those who trust in Christ will rise from death again to glory at the Day of Judgment selected by Almighty God, just as Christ, our Head rose again, according to God’s design upon the third day. For St. Augustine says that where the Head goes, the rest of the Body can trust and be trusted to follow. And St. Paul says that if Christ has risen from the dead, we will as well (1 Cor. 15:20-25). And to comfort Christians about their deaths, the Holy Scriptures call the death of our bodies “a time of sleeping” (John 16: 11,13; Acts 7:60; 1 Thess. 4:13-18). Like in sleep, our senses will be taken away from us for a time, and we will awake with our senses refreshed to a higher state than when we fell asleep. So, although our souls and bodies will be separated for some time, yet at the general resurrection of the dead, we will be more fresh, beautiful, and perfect than we are now. For now we are mortal, then we will be immortal. Now we suffer from many weaknesses, but then we will be free of every weakness of body and mind; now we feel so many desires for power, fame, fortune, and pleasure, then we will become spiritual, desiring nothing but to glorify God and enjoy Him forever.
            Therefore, the death of our bodies is merely the door to eternal life and is not worthy of our fear and anxiety, if we think about it carefully. It is a comfort, not a burden, but the relief of every burden. It is not an enemy, but a friend; not a cruel tyrant, but a gentle guide, leading us, not to mortality, but to immortality, not to sorrow and pain, but to joy and pleasure that will last forever; if we receive it with thanksgiving, accept it as God’s messenger, and bear it patiently for the love of Christ, who died most painfully for us out of love for us and to redeem us from eternal death. And thus, St. Paul tells us, “Our life is hid with Christ in God, but when our Life will appear, then we will also will appear with Him in glory” (Col. 3:3-4).
            Why then are we afraid to die, when we consider the many comforting promises of the Gospel and the Holy Scriptures?  St. John tells us, “God the Father has given us eternal life and this life is in His Son. Whoever has the Son has life and whoever does not have the Son does not have life” (1 John 5:11-12). And he also writes, “I write to you that believe in the Name of the Son of God that you may know that you have eternal life and should continue to believe in the Name of the Son of God” (1 John 5:13). And Our Savior Christ says, “He who believes in me has eternal life, and I will raise him from death to life at the last day” (John 6:40, 47). St. Paul says, “Christ has been chosen and appointed by God to be our righteousness, holiness, and redemption, so that all who boast [of their merits] should boast instead about the Lord” (1 Cor. 1:30,31). St. Paul considered everything He had done before he found Jesus to be of very little value, “appraising what I considered nearly priceless to be worth as much as shit in comparison to being part of Christ” and having true holiness, righteousness, and redemption (Phil. 3:7-11). Finally, St. Paul makes a clear argument on this subject as follows, “If our heavenly Father would not spare his only Son but offered Him to death in exchange for us, how can He deny us anything?” (Rom. 8:32). Therefore, if we have Christ, then we possess by Him and through Him everything good, whatever we can wish or desire in our hearts, such as victory over death, sin, and hell. We have the favor of God, peace with Him, holiness, wisdom, justice, power, life, and redemption; we have through Him eternal health, wealth, joy, and bliss.

(2)

In the first part, I showed that there were three reasons why people commonly fear death; (1) because it separates them from their possessions and pleasures in life; (2) because of the pain and suffering that often comes with death; and most of all, (3) because they fear extreme misery and eternal damnation after death. And yet none of these three causes trouble good people; because they soothe their fears by true faith, perfect charity, and certain hope of endless joy and everlasting bliss.
            All of those that are united to Christ with true faith, steadfast hope, and perfect charity should be full of joy and fear neither death nor eternal damnation. For death cannot deprive them of Jesus Christ, nor can any sin condemn those grafted tightly onto Him, who is their only joy, treasure, and life. Let us repent of our sins, amend our lives, trust in His mercy and that He has paid for our sins, and then death can neither take Him from us, nor us from Him. For in that case, as St. Paul says, “whether we live or die, we belong to the Lord” (Rom. 8:1). And in another place he says, “Christ died and rose again, so that he would be Lord both of the living and the dead” (Rom. 14:8-9). Then, if we are the Lord’s own when we are dead, it follows in consequence that death of our body cannot harm us but benefits us greatly and puts us in closer relationship with God. And of the closer relationship to God that comes through death, St Paul writes, “God has prepared us for immortality and has given us a security deposit in the form of His Holy Spirit. Therefore, let us be free of anxiety, for we know that as long as we are in our bodies, we are as far from God,” as if we were traveling in lands far from home, at risk from many dangers and “walking without perfect sight” and knowledge of Almighty God, only seeing Him by faith in the Holy Scriptures, “but we are filled with courage and desire instead to be at home with God” (2 Cor. 5:5-8) and Our Savior Christ, far from the body, “where we may behold His Godhead as He really is, face to face” (1 John 3:2; 1 Cor. 13:12) to our eternal comfort.
            St. Paul is comparing life in this world to immigrating as an exile to a strange country far from God; and that death, delivering us from our bodies, honorably returns from exile into our native land and enables us to live with God forever in eternal rest and quietness. So dying is no loss but immensely profitable and victorious to all true Christians.
            What did the thief that hung on the cross next to Christ lose by his bodily death? Nothing. His death was only to his benefit. Did not our Savior say to him, “Today, you shall be with me in Paradise” (Lk. 23:43)? And consider Lazarus, an utterly destitute man camping out at a rich man’s gate while starving and covered with sores. Did not death do him good and greatly improve his condition? For death placed him into the ministering hands of angels, who brought him into Abraham’s bosom, a place of rest, joy, and heavenly consolation. Therefore, let us believe that Christ has prepared and made ready those same joyful and happy accommodations for us that he prepared for Lazarus and the thief. And so let us cling to His salvation and gracious redemption, believe His word, serve Him from our hearts, love and obey Him; and let us repent of whatever we have done contrary to His most holy will and eagerly amend our lives, being certain that we will find that He is as merciful to us as he was to Lazarus and the thief. The Holy Scriptures provide us these examples for the comfort of sinners and those who suffer sorrow, misery, or calamity in this world, so that that we do not think that God’s mercy is not meant for us but trust that our sins can be forgiven and life eternal be granted us, just as it was to Lazarus and the thief.
            Thus I trust that every Christian can see in the infallible word of God that bodily death cannot harm nor hinder true believers in Christ but indeed benefits and improves the condition of Christian souls who practice true repentance, charity, and faith in God’s mercy and forgiveness through the merits of Jesus Christ, his only Son.
            The second cause of the fear of death is the fear of pain that precedes or accompanies death. This fear is the fear of our weak flesh and a natural consequence of being mortal creatures. But true faith in God’s promises, regard for the extremity of Christ’s suffering on the cross for wretched sinners, and anticipation of joyful eternal life in heaven should calm and moderate this fear. Certainly, our fear does not need to get in the way of the healthy desire and happiness that the Christian soul has to be separated from its corrupt body and come into the gracious presence of Our Lord Jesus Christ. If we firmly believe the word of God, we shall view illness, the suffering of death, or whatever awful pain we suffer before or at the time of death to be the loving correction of our heavenly Father, which He administers to us: (1) either to demonstrate the power of his patient children and be made praiseworthy, glorious, and honorable in his sight when Jesus Christ shall be revealed as the Judge of all the world; or (2) else to discipline and fix whoever offends his fatherly and gracious goodness so that they do not suffer eternal death. And this rod of correction is common to all of those who truly are His children.
            Therefore, “let us throw off the burden of sin that weighs so heavily” on our necks and return to God by true repentance and amendment of our lives. “Let us with patience run the race” suffering all sorrows, the pain of death, and death itself (when God sends it to us) for the sake of Him who died for our salvation, “having our eyes fixed and firmly set upon the pioneer and perfecter of our faith, Jesus Christ; who considering the joy into which He would enter” disdained the shame and pain of death and willingly bent and fit his will to His Father’s will “patiently suffering the most shameful pain and death of the cross” being innocent and harmless. Now therefore He is exalted in heaven and sits eternally at the right hand of God the Father (Phil. 2:9). Let us recall therefore the life and joys of heaven that are kept for all those who patiently suffer here with Christ and consider that Christ was tortured painfully and put to death by sinners and yet these things were done for the good of sinners; and then with patience and greater ease, we will suffer such sorrows and pains when they come. Let us not despise the Lord’s correction, nor form a grudge against Him, nor turn away from Him, when He corrects us, for the Lord loves all those whom He corrects and chastises every child He acknowledges (Prov. 3:11-12). “Has anyone heard of a child”, St. Paul says, “who is loved but is not disciplined by his or her father. If you are without God’s correction, whom all his dearly loved and true children have, then you are illegitimate [lightly regarded by God] and not his true children. In this world, our earthly parents disciplined us and we came to fear them and respect their discipline. Should we not have greater respect for the discipline of our heavenly Father, through whom we have eternal life? And our earthly parents sometimes disciplined us unwisely and unfairly, but this Father justly disciplines us, so that we repent of our sins and amend our lives, but also to make us wealthy spiritually by participating in His holiness. Moreover, all discipline which God uses in this present time seems to lack all joy and comfort and only contain sorrow and pain; yet it brings with it a taste of God’s mercy and goodness toward those that are disciplined and a certain hope of God’s everlasting consolation in heaven ”  (Heb. 12:1-11).
            If then these sorrows, diseases, and sicknesses, and also death itself, are nothing else but the way that our heavenly Father disciplines His naughty children and through which He assures us of His love and gracious favor, tests and purifies us, gives us holiness, and certifies us as the children of Our merciful Father, shall we not then humbly, as obedient and loving children (1 Pet. 1:14) embrace Our heavenly Father’s discipline, and echo in our hearts the cry of Our Savior Jesus Christ, “Father, if this anguish and sorrow which I feel, and death, which I see approach, may not pass, but it is your will that I suffer them, let your will be done”?  (paraphrase of Matt. 26:42).

(3)
In this Homily against the Fear of Death, I declared two reasons why we might fear to die and argued that these reasons should not trouble faithful Christians when death comes but rather give them much reason to rejoice, because they shall be delivered from the sorrow and misery of this world and be brought to the great joy and happiness of the life to come.
            Now the third and special reason why death indeed is to be feared is the wretched condition of the ungodly after their death. This is, of course, no reason why godly and faithful people should fear death; but, on the contrary, their godly behavior in this life and belief in Christ, clinging continuously to his merits, should give them an almost painful desire for the life they shall have after the death of their bodies. The Holy Scriptures clearly discuss an immortal state after the changes and chances of this life, where we shall live eternally in God’s presence joyfully and at rest, having been made victorious over all sickness, sorrow, and death. These parts of Scripture should strengthen the doubtful against the fear of all grief, illness, sin, and bodily death, calm our trembling and ungodly fear, and encourage with the comfort and hope of a blessed state after this life. St. Paul prayed for the Ephesians, “that the God and Father of glory would give to them the spirit of wisdom and understanding that the eyes of their hearts would be enlightened to know Him,” to see how great were the things to which He had called them, and the richness of the inheritance He had prepared after this life for those who love Him (Eph. 1:17-18). And St. Paul himself declared that, “the desire of his heart was to be dissolved” and separated from his body “to be with Christ,” which he said was “much better for him, although it was more necessary for his auditors that he should live” a situation he accepted for their sake (Phil. 1:23-26). Indeed, St. Martin of Tours felt the same way and said, “Good Lord, if I am necessary to do good to your people, I will not refuse any task, but if not, I ask you to take my soul.”
            The holy fathers of the old Law, and all faithful and righteous men who died before our Savior Christ’s ascension into heaven, did escape their troubles by death and enter into rest, and fled from the hands of their enemies into the hands of God, from sorrows and sicknesses into joyful refreshment. The Scriptures clearly tell us that they entered the bosom of Abraham, a place full of comfort and consolation. The Book of Wisdom says that “the souls of the righteous are in the hands of God and torment can touch them. In the eyes of the unwise, they appeared to die, and their death was counted a misery and their departure from this world seemed wretched, but they are at rest” (Wisd. 3:1-3). And in another place, this book says, “the righteous shall live forever. Their reward is with the Lord and their minds are with God, who is above all: therefore, they shall receive a glorious kingdom and a beautiful crown at the Lord’s hand. And in addition, Wisdom says, “The righteous, though they die suddenly, will be at peace” (Wisd. 4:7). We should not doubt that Abraham’s bosom existed, Christ’s words are so obvious that a Christian needs no more proof of it (Lk. 16:22-25).
            Now then if this were the state of the holy fathers and righteous prior to the coming of our Savior and His glorification, how much more should we all have a steadfast faith and sure hope of this blessed state and condition after our death? Indeed, our Savior has performed the whole work of our redemption and has gloriously ascended into heaven to prepare dwelling places with Him and said to His Father, “Father, I desire that wherever I am, my servants shall be with me” (John 14:2-3; 17:24; 12:26). And we know that, whatever Christ desires, His Father desires the same. Therefore, there is no other conclusion we can make but that our souls will be with God after our departure from this present life, if we are His faithful servants.
            Consider St. Stephen. When he was stoned to death and in the midst of pain, what was he thinking about? The Acts of the Apostles says, “When he was full of the Holy Spirit, having lifted his eyes toward heaven, he saw the glory of God and Jesus standing at God’s right hand.” And when he had proclaimed what he was seeing boldly before the enemies of Christ, “they took him out of the city and stoned him there as he cried out to God, saying, ‘Lord Jesus Christ, receive my spirit” (Acts 7:55-59). And does not our Savior say clearly in the Gospel of John, “Truly, truly, I say to you, whoever hears my word and believes in Him who sent me, has eternal life and comes not to judgment but shall pass from death to life” (John 5:24)? Should we not consider death to be precious, because it is the way to life? Therefore, the Prophet truly said, “Precious in the sight of the Lord are the deaths of his servants” (Ps. 116:15). Holy Simeon, after he had checked off the chief item of his bucket list in seeing our Savior, for whom he had longed his entire life, he “took Him in his arms and said, ‘Now, Lord, let me depart in peace, for my eyes have seen the Savior whom you have prepared for all the world to see” (Lk. 2:28-31). It is true therefore that the death of the righteous is called peace and the benefit of the Lord, as the Church says in the name of righteous departed from this world, “Turn, O my soul, to your rest, for the Lord has been good to you and has rewarded you” (Ps. 116:7). And we see in the Holy Scriptures and the ancient histories of the Martyrs, that the holy, faithful, and righteous, ever since Christ’s Ascension, did not doubt at the hour of death that they would go to be with Christ in spirit, who is our life, health, wealth, and salvation.
            John in his holy Revelation saw 144,000 virgins and innocents, of whom he said, “These follow the Lamb [Jesus Christ] wherever He goes.” And shortly thereafter he writes, “I heard a voice saying to me, ‘Write, “blessed hereafter are the dead who die in the Lord, for they rest from their labors, says the Spirit, and their works do follow them”’” (Rev. 14:1-5, 13). So those who sowed with labor and pain will reap their crop with joy and comfort, for “those who sow in the Spirit, shall harvest eternal life through the Spirit. Let us therefore never tire of doing good, for when the harvest time arrives, we will reap without any exhaustion” eternal joy (Gal. 6:8-10). Therefore, as St. Paul encourages us, while we have time, let us do good to all and not accumulate treasure on earth, where rust and moth consume (Matt. 6:19), for that rust, St. James tells us, will testify against us at the Day of Judgment and shall torture our flesh like the flames of a fire (James 5:3).
            Let us beware of managing our money like those sad, grasping, and wretched people, whom St. James exhorts to mourn and bewail their greedy accumulation and ungodly hoarding of property (James 5:1-4). Let us wisely take a page from the good example of the wicked Steward (Luke 16:1-9). Let us wisely manage the possessions God has given us for the brief span of our lives that we may truly hear and obey this commandment of our Savior Christ : “Truly, I say to you, use worldly wealth to make friends for yourselves, so that they may welcome you into eternal dwellings.” He called wealth wicked because property can be abused in a variety of wicked ways, even though it is otherwise the good gift of God and a means by which God’s servants can truly serve Him. He commanded His disciples not to make rich friends, to obtain high offices or titles of honor, or to give great gifts to rich people who do not need them but to make friends with poor and wretched people. Indeed, the gifts they receive, Christ regards as if they were made to Him. And Christ in the Gospels gives great honor and preeminence to the poor and wretched, for He says that they will welcome their friends into everlasting dwellings. He does not mean that the poor will reward us for the good we do them, but that Christ will reward us, accounting whatever good we do to such friends as done for Him. Thus if we make the poor and suffering our friends, we make Our Savior Christ our friend, for they are his hands and feet, whose misery He bears as His own misery and whose comfort, relief, and help He regards as His comfort, relief, and help. And He will thank and reward us for the good we show to the poor and suffering just as if we had done the same good to Him, as He testifies in the Gospels, saying, “Whatever you have done to the least of those who believe in Me, you have done it to Me” (Matt. 25:40; 10:42; 18:6).
            Therefore, let us diligently ensure that our faith and hope in Almighty God and Our Savior Christ neither shrink, nor our love for Christ grow cold, but let us eagerly each day show ourselves to be the true worshippers and lovers of God by keeping His commandments, doing good deeds to our needy neighbors, relieving their poverty with our abundance and plenty to the best of our ability, their ignorance with our wisdom and knowledge, and their spiritual weakness with our strength and authority. We should steer all from evil deeds by our godly advice and good example, persevering in doing good as long as we live. And if we do this, we will not need to fear death for any of the three reasons I have mentioned or for any other reason that can be imagined. On the contrary, we will view our lives as they really are: full of many sicknesses, troubles, and sorrows; a perilous pilgrimage in which our spirits are weighed down heavily by the sinfulness and fragility of our bodies; exposed to the many sorrows and dangerous frauds of this world that assail us on every side, the temptations of pride, greed, and lust in time of prosperity as well as the impatient whining of all that is worldly in us in time of adversity, which never stop dragging and snatching us from the life, wealth, and everlasting joy and salvation we have in God in Christ Jesus; full of the countless assaults of our spiritual enemy, the devil, with all of his fiery arrows of ambition, pride, lust, vanity, jealousy, malice, slander, and the other numerous tricks, schemes, and traps he uses to enslave human beings “like a roaring lion seeking someone to devour” (1 Pet. 5:8). And when we consider these miseries, dangers, and inconveniences to which we are subject as long as we live in this world and compare them to the blessed and comfortable condition of the life to come and the sweet condition of those who die in the Lord, we will not fear death. When we compare being subject to the weaknesses of our body and the assaults of the world and the devil to being free from all of it to live in peace, rest, and eternal quiet in the fellowship of the angels (Heb. 12:22-23), Patriarchs, Prophets, Martyrs, and Confessors and in the presence of Almighty God and Our Savior Christ, we will not fear death. When we reflect on these things and believe them wholeheartedly, standing firmly in this true faith in God and having a quiet conscience in Christ because of firm hope and trust in God’s mercy extended through the merits of Jesus Christ to obtain this quiet, rest, and eternal joy, we definitely will not fear the death of our bodies when it comes but indeed we will share with St. Paul the happy and heartfelt desire to die when God wills it (Phil 1:23), so that when God calls us out of this life, we will be free of every opportunity to do or suffer evil and live eternally to please God and perfectly obey His will, along with our Savior Jesus Christ. May the Lord in His infinite mercy and grace bring us all into the gracious presence of Christ to reign with Him in eternal life. To Christ with our heavenly Father and the Holy Spirit be the glory forever and ever. Amen. 

Notes
27 January 2015: Mac Stewart points out the 1549 Prayer Book explanation of illness. It is unsurprisingly identical to that in this Homily.

Friday, October 24, 2014

Book I, Homily 8 Remixed: Losing Your Religion Is A Very Bad Thing (Author Unknown)

(1)
Ben Sirach says that our basic motivation to turn away from God is pride, “For pride is the fountain of all sin. He who has it shall be full of curses, and it will destroy him in the end” (Ecclus. 10:12-13). And as sin and pride turn us from God, so will God and all goodness leave us. And the Prophet Hosea clearly tells that those who turn away from God to pursue an immoral life, yet seek to pacify Him by sacrifices, are wasting their time. They may sacrifice all they want, but He still will leave them, “They do not apply their minds to return to God. Although they lead whole flocks and herds in search of the Lord, they shall not find Him, for He has gone away from them” (Hos. 5:4,6).
            There are many ways of turning from God. Sometimes, it can be done quite directly by idolatry, as Israel and Judah did. Sometimes people leave God, because they do not have enough faith in God or even mistrust Him, as Isaiah says, “Woe to those who go down to Egypt to seek help, trusting in horses and putting their faith in the number of chariots and power of horsemen. They have no confidence in the Holy One of Israel, nor do they seek the Lord” (Is. 31:1). And what were the consequences? Isaiah tells us, “The Lord shall let his hand fall upon them and both the helper and the one helped shall be destroyed together” (Is. 31:3).
             Sometimes, people turn away from God by neglecting His commandments concerning the treatment of their neighbors. We are commanded to express heart-filled love for everyone, as Zechariah said to the people on God’s behalf, “Give true judgment and show mercy and compassion to your brother. Do not defraud the widow or the orphan, the alien, and the poor. Let no one forge evil in his heart for his brother. But they did not heed these words. They turned their backs and followed their own way. They plugged their ears in order not to hear. They hardened their hearts as hard as stone so that they would not have to listen to the law and the words that the Lord had sent through His Holy Spirit by His ancient Prophets. And this is why the Lord has turned His fierce anger toward them and has said, ‘Because they would not listen to my words, I did not listen to their cries. I drove them out among the nations and turned their own country into a wasteland’” (Zech. 7:9-14).
            And therefore, all those who do not show concern for the word of God but follow the ideas and stubbornness of their own hearts, they turn their backs rather than their faces to God, as Jeremiah says (Jer. 7:24). Origen says that a person turned toward God, “applies and gives himself to God’s word with eagerness, deeds, thought, and care; reflects upon God’s laws day and night; gives himself entirely to God; and consistently practices God’s precepts and commandments.” And Origen also describes a person turned away from God as someone who, “is busy with fables and tales when hearing or reading God’s word; or is thinking about secular business, money, or new ways to make money.” He continues, “Whoever is entangled with concern for their possessions, is filled with the desire for riches, and is eager for the glory and honor of this world is turned from God.” Therefore, in Origen’s opinion, whoever is not focused on what is commanded or taught by God; whoever does not listen to it, embrace it, and imprint it on his heart, so that he can shape his life according to God’s commandments; that person is turned from God, though he does other things that seem good to his own mind and appeal to his own sense of devotion. Of course, these things seem to him better and more appropriate to God’s honor, when they deeply dishonor God.
            The Holy Scriptures teach us what it means to turn away from God through the example of King Saul, who was commanded by God through the Prophet Samuel, to kill the Amalekites and destroy all of them along with their property. Yet Saul, motivated partly by pity and partly (as he thought) by devotion to God, saved Agag their king, and their choicest cattle in order to sacrifice to God (1 Sam. 15:1-22). And for this reason, God said to the Prophet Samuel, “I repent of having made Saul king, for he has turned away from me and has not obeyed my instructions” (1 Sam. 15:11). And he commanded Samuel to tell Saul what He had said.
            And when Samuel asked why Saul had saved the cattle contrary to God’s commandment, Saul excused himself by saying that he was afraid that his troops would not be satisfied without spoil and that he figured that God would be content with the sacrifice of choice beasts to Him and would look favorably on Saul’s good intentions ad devotion rather than his disobedience. But Samuel criticized Saul’s intentions and devotion, however much they seemed to honor God. What mattered was for Saul’s actions to agree with God’s word, the only assurance of God’s pleasure. And so Samuel said, “Does the Lord desire whole-offerings and sacrifices, as he desires obedience? To obey is better than sacrifice and to listen better than the fat of rams. Rebellion is as sinful as witchcraft; arrogance as evil as idolatry. Because you have rejected the word of the Lord, He has rejected you as king” (1 Sam. 15:22-23).
            All of these examples from the Holy Scriptures teach us that if we turn away from God, He will always turn away from us. And God has given us terrible warnings of the miserable consequences that necessarily follow. We cannot possibly measure the whole extent of this misery. It exceeds our capacity to do so while we are in this life. Yet if our hearts are softer than stone or not harder than diamond, we should fear, tremble, and quake to remember God’s warnings to us.
            First, the Scriptures commonly describe the displeasure of God toward us in two ways: (1) showing His terrifying countenance to us; or (2) turning His face or hiding it from us. Showing his terrifying countenance to us signifies His great anger; but turning His face or hiding His face signifies something many times worse, that is, He clearly abandons whatever he has turned away from.
The meanings of these phrases can be illustrated from human manners. We show good, cheerful, and loving expressions to those whom we favor, so that the face, expression or countenance of a person indicates his attitude toward the person to whom he or she shows it. So, when God shows His terrifying visage toward us, that is, He sends dreadful plagues of war, famine, or pestilence upon us, it appears that He is greatly angry with us. But, when He withdraws from us his word, the right doctrine of Christ, His gracious assistance and aid, which is ever joined to His word… Well, then He leaves us to make our way by our own wits, will, and strength. And thus He declares that that He is beginning to forsake us. For since God has shown His face of mercy in Jesus Christ to all who truly believe His Gospel, which so lightens their hearts that they, if they see it as they should, are transformed into His likeness, made participants in the heavenly light and His Holy Spirit, and have been created in Christ Jesus for good works appropriate for God’s children (2 Cor. 3:18, 4:4,6; Eph. 2:10). So if afterwards, they wander away from this road, they are ungrateful to God, and they do not arrange their lives according to His example, teaching, and the proclamation of His glory, He will take away from them His kingdom and His holy word, through which He reigns in them. And why? Because they do not bear the fruit He seeks (Matt. 21:19-21).
            Nevertheless, He is merciful and so very patient. He does not pour his anger upon us the very moment that we begin to shrink from His word, and do not believe it or express it in the way we live. First, he sends His messengers, the true preachers of His word, to reprimand and warn us of our duty. For let us not forget that He showed His great love to us by offering to us His only Son to suffer death, so that by His death we might be freed from death and restored to eternal life, to dwell with Him forever and share His inheritance of glory and dominion in heaven. And He only asks from us that we should walk in a godly life, as is appropriate to our status as his children. However, if we do not listen to those who warn us or are not properly overawed by His generosity toward us, we are in great trouble. If we continue to disobey His word and will, not knowing Him, not loving Him, not fearing Him, not putting our whole trust and confidence in Him; and moreover, if we continue to treat our neighbors uncharitably with contempt, jealousy, and malice, or by committing murder, robbery, adultery, gluttony, deceit, lying, swearing, or other detestable works and ungodly behavior; then He threatens us with terrible curses (e.g., Heb. 4:1-13; Gal. 5:21; Ps. 95:1), swearing in great anger that whoever does these things shall never enter His rest, which is the Kingdom of Heaven.

(2)

In the first part of this Homily, I have described the many ways we may turn away from God: (1) idolatry; (2) insufficient faith; (3) ignoring or badly treating their neighbors and their welfare; (4) not listening to God’s word; and (5) overindulging in worldly pleasures. You have heard the terrible consequences of turning away from God, but that God’s infinite goodness persuades Him to turn us back toward Him by the gentle rebukes of preachers before He resorts to terrible threats.
            Now if these gentle warnings and terrible threats have no effect on us, He will show his terrifying countenance to us and pour unbearable plagues upon our heads. And after He does so, He will take away all of his aid and assistance to us, which is our only defense against disaster. Indeed, I can illustrate this with a metaphor used by both the Prophet Isaiah and the Lord Jesus in the parable of evil tenants.
God has planted a wonderful vineyard for his beloved children, “He planted hedges around it. He built a wall around that, planted it with chosen vines, and made a watchtower and wine press in the middle of it. But when He came to harvest it, he found wild grapes had grown rather than good” And what was the result?: “Now I shall show you,” said God, “what I will do with my vineyard. I will uproot the hedges so that they will wither away. I will destroy the walls that any one may come and trample the vines. I will let the land lie fallow. It shall not be tilled or weeded, but briers and thorns will flourish upon it. And I will command the clouds not to rain upon it” (Is. 5:1-6; Matt. 21: 33-41).
            Here we are rebuked and warned that if we, the chosen vineyard of God, do not produce good grapes, that is, good works, which are good and pleasant in his sight… If we do not produce such good fruit when He looks for it or when He sends His messengers to ask us for them… Or indeed if He or they find wild grapes, which I interpret to mean sour works, bitter and unfruitful, then He will remove all which defends us and He will permit horrible plagues of famine, war, disease, and death to afflict us. And if we do not repent after these disasters, He will let us become a wasteland. He will abandon us. He will turn away from us. He will not bother to weed or turn the soil around us. He will leave us alone and let us bear what fruit we can produce by ourselves: brambles, briers, and thorns: all vice, all wickedness, and in such abundance that they will outgrow us, choke us, strangle us, and utterly destroy us.
            But those in this world who do not live in the fear of God but follow the freedom of the flesh, do not sense the great wrath of God, that God no longer clears or weeds around them, that He leaves them to their own devices. They indeed see it as a great gift of God that they have such freedom and live as if the freedom to indulge the flesh were the true freedom of the Gospel. But may God forbid, my dear friends, that we should ever want such freedom. For, although God does sometimes allow the wicked to have such pleasure in this world, recall that ungodly living inevitably results in destruction. The murmuring Israelites in the wilderness had their heart’s desire. They had more quail meat than they knew what to do with (Numb. 11:4-6, 31-33). But what was the result? Their sweet meat had sour sauce. Even when the meat was in their mouths, the plague of God came upon them and they died straightaway (Ps. 78:30-31). So if we live contrary to God’s will and God lets us follow our own wills, to indulge our own desires and seek our own pleasures, and if God does not correct us with some plague, there is no doubt that He is completely fed up with us.
            And although it might take more or less time, when He smites such a person, they are smitten forever. So when he does not strike, afflict, beat, or punish us; when he permits us to embrace all ungodliness and every worldly pleasure we desire without punishment and adversity, it is terrifying proof that He does not love us any more, that He does not care for us anymore, but He has left us to our own devices. Consider that as long as a vine grower prunes her vines, digs at their roots, and refreshes the soil, she cares about them, she sees some sign of fruitfulness that she may gain from them: but, when she stops working with them, it is a sure sign that she does not want anything to do with them because they will never be any good.
And a father, as long as he loves his child, he is angry with the child and disciplines the child for misbehaving. But when discipline has no effect and he then lets the kid do what he wants, it is a sign that he wants nothing to do with the child anymore. As soon as he can, he will disinherit the kid, kick him out of the house, or let him fall into the cold hands of the justice system.
            So surely nothing should wound our heart so much or terrify us as when we know in our conscience that we have grievously offended God and continue to do so, but God does not strike us and quietly allows us to pursue those sinful things we delight to do. Then it is definitely time to cry as David did, “Do not drive me from your presence or take your Holy Spirit from me” (Ps. 51:11); “Do not hide your face from me or turn away your servant in anger” (Ps. 27:9); “Do not hide your face from me or I shall be like those who go down into the abyss” (Ps. 143:7). David’s mournful prayers show us the horrible danger of being one from whom God has turned his face. And if we do come near that awful situation, David’s example should galvanize us to cry aloud to God with all our heart, that we may not enter or continue in that state, which is undoubtedly so sorrowful, miserable, and dreadful that no one can sufficiently express or any heart consider it. For it must be an absolutely fatal grief to be under God’s wrath; to be separated from the Holy Spirit, the source of all good things; to fall to such a condition that you are fit for nothing better than to be condemned to hell.
Our examples of this terror come from David and Isaiah. David tells us that when God turns His face from us, we are emptied of all goodness and placed far from any relief. Isaiah tells us that we are like a vineyard, and when we are unfruitful, we can expect to be left alone without pruning and tilling so that we become overgrown with briers and thorns. We are denied even the nurture of the rains because of our unfaithfulness, which I interpret to mean the teaching of the Holy Scriptures, since St. Paul uses planting and watering to mean the same thing (I Cor. 3:6-9). And once denied the Holy Scriptures and the teaching of the gospel, we no longer belong to His kingdom or are governed by His Holy Spirit. We are excluded from the grace and benefits that we had and might have enjoyed eternally through Christ; we are deprived of the heavenly light and life, which we had in Christ when we lived in Him. We shall be, as we were before we first believed, “in a world without God” (Eph. 2:12). Indeed, we will be in even worse condition, since we will be handed over to the power of the devil. This is the way God disposes all He alienates from Himself, as he did to Saul and Judas (1 Sam. 15:23-35; 16:14; Lk. 12:3; John 13:2, 27) and to all those who live according to their own desires, children of mistrust and unbelief.
Therefore, let us not to be unfruitful and reject God’s word, so that we remain those who obtain and retain true faith in God through his holy word and do not become the offspring of unbelief. And unbelief has two kinds of children, who are quite different. Indeed, they are exact opposites. The first kind falls into despair. They weigh their sinful and wicked lives against the purity of God’s righteousness; because they are deprived of the comfort and counsel of God’s Spirit, the very “Spirit of counsel” (Is. 11:2), their hearts never will be convinced that God can or will receive them once more into His favor and mercy. The other kind is stuck in a foolish optimism. They hear the broad and loving promises of God’s mercy, but they do not understand them through the lens of true faith and so make them wider than God ever did. They trust that they can continue in sinful and wicked living as long as they desire, indeed as long as they live. Yet they imagine that God at the hour of death will show His mercy upon them, and then they will return to Him. And both these kinds of people are in a state of damnation, yet God, “who does not desire the death of sinners” (Ezek. 18:25,32; 33:11), has opened a way for both kinds of abandoned sinners to escape, if they change their ways in time.
The first kind of abandoned sinner is consumed with fear of God’s rightful justice in punishing sinners, which correctly sends them into despair about what hope they have of saving themselves. Yet if they would consistently believe that God’s mercy is the treatment they need for their despair and distrust, not only for them, but for all who are genuinely sorry and penitent and cling to God’s mercy, they could be sure that they will obtain mercy and enter into a place of safety. Those who sail to the port of God’s mercy, no matter what they have done, they shall find a refuge from everlasting damnation. As God says through Ezekiel, “When a wicked man mends his ways, his former wickedness will not bring him down…When I pronounce sentence of death upon the wicked, then if he mends his ways and does what is just and right…he will live and not die. None of the sins he has committed will be remembered against him” (Ezek. 33:12, 14,16).
I would instruct the second kind of abandoned sinner to reflect upon this: if they readily believe God’s good promises, should they not also so readily believe God’s warnings? They should believe the Law as much as the Gospel. They should believe that there is a hell filled with everlasting fire just as much as they believe there is a heaven filled with everlasting joy. They should believe that damnation is threatened to the wicked and evildoers just as much as they believe that salvation is promised to those faithful in word and deed. In every case, they should believe God is just as earnest when promising the bad as He is when promising the good. Indeed, sinners that continue to live wickedly should believe that the promises of God’s mercy and the Gospel are not extended to them, because of their state of sin, but instead their portion is only the threats of God’s wrath and indignation in the Law and other of the Scriptures. And these reflections should make it clear to them that as they presume excessively upon God’s mercy and live viciously; God will withdraw His mercy from them all the more. And when He is incited to wrath for such a long time, it is very likely that those who presume on his mercy will be destroyed suddenly. St. Paul tells us what these sinners say, “ ‘All is peaceful, all secure’ [but] destruction is upon them as sudden as a woman going into labor” (1 Thess. 5:3).
Let us therefore beware of such wicked boldness to sin. For God has promised his mercy to those who truly repent (even at the hour of death), but He has not promised to the presumptuous sinner that he shall live long or be capable of true repentance at the hour of death. It is for that reason that God has made our time of death uncertain, so that we do not put our hope in deathbed conversions and live wickedly to God’s great displeasure in the meantime.

Therefore, let us all follow the counsel of Ben Sirach, let us “not be slow to turn to the Lord. Let us not procrastinate about it. For His wrath comes when you least expect it, and He will destroy the wicked in the time of His vengeance” (Ecclus. 5:7). Let us therefore turn to Him as often as we can, and when we turn, let us pray to God as Hosea teaches, saying, “Forgive all of our sins and receive us with grace” (Hos. 14:2). And, if we turn to Him with an humble and a very penitent heart, He will show us His favor and grace for the sake of His holy Name, His promises, and His truth and mercy, which are promised to all faithful believers in Jesus Christ, his only begotten Son. To whom, the only Savior of the world, with the Father and the Holy Spirit, be all honor, glory, and power, forever and ever. Amen.