The Wayback Machine - http://web.archive.org/web/20040318183332/http://www.janegalt.net:80/MT/mt-comments.cgi?entry_id=4415
Comments: Open Source

I saw the article in the wee hours and thought it was excellent. My impression of the status and likely outcome of the SCO case was different, but your point, as I wrote at some length in my post on your piece, was a superb one.

Posted by Jay Solo at October 6, 2003 08:47 AM

I read you article and I think you are failing to see a major point of open source software. In case you didn't know much of the early work in software before the birth of the "software industry" operated in an open source spirit. Much of the research work executed at the universities and basement labs in the early days was shared and expanded upon to bring more and more maturity to computer software and hardware with intelectual property and trade secrets and afterthough at most. Many who think of the "software industry" today forget that it was built upon the back of these early individuals effots and "gifts" to science. Not to mention that for that past several hundred years scientific research executed in the public sector operated in an open source spirt where results of any major break through were published openly with a open invitation to be expanded on a researched futher. It is only more recently with the lawyers getting involved with NDA's accoppaning research grants and the private/public cross pollenization that have turn a once very public and open process into a more private closed one. And who are the winners of this outcome? The private companies or the public who finances their profits? I feel that the open source development model is the result of a natural reaction to some of the actions taken by the very greedy (80% ROE anyone?) and the very shady (vendor lock in, security as an afterthought, etc., DCMA) software industry of today. Todays "software industry" is a very powerful one which insures its continued success though product defects that can sometimes only be addressed with a purchased upgrade. Not only that but the fast moving pace of industry standards and the very small amount time it takes to reproduce and distribute a completed software product combined with 24 year patents, 90 year plus life of author copyrights and things like the DMCA give large software companies a guaranty of profit for the forseeable future. Guess who funds this profit???? All the users/liscensee's of software. Given the trend these days who will eventually that be???? All of socieity. So many members of said socieity have realized we do have a choice in this matter and can spare ourselves and our fellow members of socieity from having to pay for these enormous profits software giants have made and plan to make into perpetuity. In your mind does it make sense for a copy of 1980 MS-DOS need to be protected by copyright for until the year 2070? Or the 1990's version of MS-Word 1.0 be protected until 2090? Maybe you don't care since you and 2 generations past yours won't be around to care then, but you should because each of those generations will end up giving thier money to software companies. Given the obsolecence of software happening in at best 10 years these copyrights mean that by the time something is returned to the public domain it is useless. So opensource software does remove that undeserved profit from the private software industry. It also in the process provide a free and open education tool (if you have net access) so others can become software specialists without having to go to a certified Microsoft Testing Center and having to pay the $100/test fee. I say undeserved because the only reason they make profit is because of copyrights and the only reason we as a public allow copyrights which are really a grant of temporary monopoly (if you think life + 90 years is temporary) is to "promote the arts and the sciences". Notice it doesn't read in any portion of copyright law that the purpose is to "insure the profits of corporations or individuals". I'm a career software developer and I feel this way because I've been educated in the areas I have been and I can see through the smoke and mirrors those that don't understand the software development process get blinded by. Onto the legal area again you aren't seen the whole picture. Think of what SCO's case really proves. Open Source software is more transparent and thus in the long term is less likely to contain copyright infringement that proprietary software. This is exacly for the reasons SCO shows that since it is open for inspection any company or individual who intellectual property has been "stolen" can see exactly where and when and who performed the "theft". Now lets say I as a software developer wrote a great product by decided to store my software code on a computer running Windows XP before service pack 1 came out. The security problems with XP would have allowed a hacker to enter my computer, steal the source code give it to thier company and sell it as theirs with little or no way for me to know or prove. If that happened in the open source world I could witness the result of the theft without hiring any lawyers or taking anyone to court. Finally with Open Source software there is still a renevue model. Any software takes knowledge to administer and to understand and extend. People involved with a software products development will naturally be the most knowledgeable on the workings of said product and will be the best able to modify or extend said product. Thus if the product or changes to the product have value to a person, company or combination there of, then the software developer will be able to negotiate a price to perform changes, training, documentation, support etc. All the non IP/Copyright related areas the bigger tech companies are currently expanding into are equally profitable for an Open Source software model if not more so. So try not to see this from the perspective of a software company but rather from the perspective of any non software company or individual. Which model best serves them?

Posted by James Miller at October 6, 2003 09:49 AM

I accurately predicted long ago that the Linux project relied too much on altruism. Human beings eventually wish to be paid for their efforts. Altruism works only in the short run--and rarely, if ever, in the long run. Developing software is usually a full time endeavor. How many people do you know willing to work substantial hours for free? Even Jimmy Carter’s house repairers only donate their time a few weekends out of the year.

Linux has always been the utopian software project of the technical elite. Only the Microsofts, Oracles, and their toughest competitors are truly able to develop software that is both user friendly and greatly beneficial.

Posted by David Thomson at October 6, 2003 10:04 AM

David, you have failed to contemplate the economics of open-source (at least in regards to operating systems). OEM's IBM,HP,SUN etc.) are paying to have operating systems on their iron - now earlier they used to produce systems in-house, very often duplicating each other - why? because they need something to run on their iron - not because they are interested in it.... Now they are instead financing an opensource system (by hiring and paying the programmers to do something to a community project (which noone can own (see: GPL))). There is no utopian concept in this - software is a means to sell hardware - software has *never* been the the income-source of the hardware producers (quite the opposite in fact). Take one look at the programmers of the Linux kernel and you will find that 90% are employed and payed to work on the kernel.

Posted by Kim Petersen at October 6, 2003 10:14 AM

http://www.groklaw.com/article.php?story=20031005202427977#comments

Follow the link above to read an interesting thread about this Tech Central Station article. It's titled 'So ignorant it is hard to read' (search the page on 'so ignorant'). Why are there so many factual errors in this article?

Posted by A dose of reality at October 6, 2003 10:15 AM

"In case you didn't know much of the early work in software before the birth of the "software industry" operated in an open source spirit. "

I totally agree with you concerning the early history of the computer age. Alas, these same people finally got tired working for nothing. They then decided to go out and earn a few bucks. Our laws attempt to protect their creative efforts. If these laws did not exist---these folks would have given up on their software projects.

There is little question that the free enterprise system could not have accomplished so much without the earlier assistance from the government and the universities. But so what? Their aprons strings eventually had to bet cut. The Microsofts of today do not depend on governmental welfare benefits. And yes, we the tax payers have been amply rewarded. Our investment has been repaid many time over.

Posted by David Thomson at October 6, 2003 10:19 AM

Your analysis does have merit. However, there is nothing that guarantees that closed source software doesn't have stolen code in it. The reason I have chosen to be anonymous is that I am aware of a case in which open source code off the net was incorporated into a product by a coworker at a previous job. To the best of my knowledge, there was no lawsuit. The code was replaced with an in-house version.

Certainly, a large vendor can indemnify customers. That doesn't mean that the vendor can't be sued and the shipment date that you were counting on for an upgrade slips.

There are a handful of important differences between open and closed source software. Some of them are fundamental and some are circumstantial. All of the fundamental differences arise from two facts:

1) Open source software has its source code published for the whole world to see.

2) All open source licenses, to the best of my knowledge, permit modification of the source and redistribution.

In some ways, the guarantees against code copyrighted by someone else being added to an open source project are weaker than for a closed source project. Those are a product of my second point. The relationship between the parties producing the code is much looser than in any closed source project I've ever heard of. With that looser relationship, there is less leverage to enforce norms of behavior in advance. However, the first point makes it much easier to detect violation of those norms and rectify them.

If we assume that SCO is in fact correct in their assertion that IBM violated a contract with them and placed their intellectual property into Linux kernel code, then we can look at that situation as it would pertain to both open and closed source code. BTW, because nearly all of the historical Unix base of BSD Unix was found to be non-infringing in the early 90's, one of the most likely common sources for code found in both SCO and Linux would not have resulted in infringement.

So, if Linux contains SCO code, that happened because someone had access to SCO code. That person was able to contribute it to the Linux kernel. The Linux kernel developers, other than the contributor, could not determine that the code belonged to SCO. In the case of a closed source product, instead of Linux, the possibility of someone having access to other closed source code and being a contributor is neither more nor less likely in any meaningful way. Via joint project, NDAs, libraries and development tools with source code, etc., it happens all the time. If nothing else, a programmer could take a copy of source code he had access to with him from one job to the next.

More people are able to contribute to open source projects. For some of them, the barriers are trivial and effectively, anyone with net access is a potential contributor. Some are more selective about their sources. On balance, open source is more open to contribution than closed source. More importantly, the relationships between the contributors carry less legal weight than with closed source. In a closed source environment, the contributors are employees, subcontractors, and occasionally customers in a joint development project. Regardless of the specific relationship, there are contracts and ongoing relationships.

One of the most significant differences between open and closed source is that open source is available for any copyright or patent holder to audit for infringement. I don't know how much auditing is actually done. The fact that the SCO lawsuit is the first after a couple of decades of open source projects leads me to believe that either violations aren't common, or that very little checking is done by copyright holders, or both.

When copyright violations are buried inside of closed source software, the owner of the copyright is not going to have any way to find them. That makes it more likely that when such violations occur, they will go undetected for longer periods. It will require insider knowledge to find them.

Some day, a whistleblower at Microsoft is going to point out a copyright violation in some of Microsoft's code. I am not accusing Microsoft of knowingly violating anyone's intellectual property rights. In fact, I think that Microsoft is more careful than most software vendors. But the cost of ensuring that there are no violations is too high to prevent them all. Because they are Microsoft, there will be a settlement. The original owner of the code will go away happy with some cash. But what happens when it is some niche product that Microsoft doesn't produce. Microsoft is in the mass-market software business. They don't produce the specialty products for every market. That is done by businesses a fraction of their size, businesses that can be killed by a lawsuit. Do you want to bet your company's future on those?

Whether the SCO lawsuit can kill Linux has wider ramifications than just whether open source will sink or swim. It is about software liability. It is about what size company will be necessary to survive producing software. It is about the balance between how much businesses depend on general-purpose software and how much they use specialty products designed for niche markets.

Yes, one lawsuit could destroy me financially and prevent me personally from developing open source software ever again. Under the right circumstances, a lawsuit over a specific open source project could make all of the code from that project untouchable for fear that it would open anyone using it up to a lawsuit. But to frame the SCO suit as being just about the future of open source is to miss a very important wider context.

Posted by Anonymous at October 6, 2003 10:20 AM

"Take one look at the programmers of the Linux kernel and you will find that 90% are employed and payed to work on the kernel."

Yup--and that’s why the lawsuits were inevitable! Throwing an occasional bone to the open source movement is one thing. It’s totally another to spend enormous hours merely to benefit the masses.

Posted by David Thomson at October 6, 2003 10:30 AM

Um, how do I put this without seeming to yell at you? You say "Nonetheless, if SCO wins this lawsuit -- or loses on technical grounds other than copyright infringement -- I think you'll see corporations taking a pass on open source software." The problem with this analysis is that SCO has not alleged copyright infringement in its complaint. SCO's suit against IBM rests on breach of contract and misappropriation of trade secrets. SCO knows full well that IBM is the copyright holder of the code that was allegedly misappropriated; SCO's position is that nevertheless the contracts that IBM signed with SCO's predecessors give SCO control of that code. This rests on a rather...creative...reading of the contract, but the point is that win or lose SCO's cause of action with IBM cannot carry over to any other distributors of Linux, let alone users such as corporate IT shops (unless they're foolish enough to sign a contract with SCO, say by accepting SCO's binary-only license--now there's copyright infringement!).

Posted by Joshua at October 6, 2003 10:55 AM

“SCO's suit against IBM rests on breach of contract and misappropriation of trade secrets. “

It matters little whether you describe the lawsuit as one of copyright violation or “misappropriation of trade secrets. “ The corporate world only cares about avoiding lawsuits! The semantics are of secondary importance.

Posted by David Thomson at October 6, 2003 11:11 AM

"Or possibly I'm just too thick to understand how cutting off a multi-billion dollar revenue stream from software sales, without putting anything else in its place, could be good for the software business."

Very little software is bought just to have it. Mostly, it is bought in order to help complete other tasks. It is not important what is good for the software business, but what is good for all other business. If free software can make the tasks it's meant to help cheaper, then we will all benefit (except those who own a lot of MSFT). Having FLOSS available for the tasks you do is like having your factory next to a sea port or near cheap energy sources.

As the 3rd world enters the info age, FLOSS will become more and more important, and gain more and more developers. They are not going to be particularly concerned with SCO v IBM. If FLOSS becomes taboo in the US then it will be the signal that the info age has been outsourced.


Posted by some random person at October 6, 2003 11:22 AM

"It matters little whether you describe the lawsuit as one of copyright violation or “misappropriation of trade secrets. “ The corporate world only cares about avoiding lawsuits! The semantics are of secondary importance."

Only if you don't know or care about what the law (and your actual liability) is. You can't be sued for breach of contract if you are not a party to the contract; similarly you can't be sued for misappropriation of trade secrets if you haven't entered into an agreement to keep those secrets. The SCO v. IBM case has no bearing on anybody's legal liability except IBM's, and saying otherwise just contributes to SCO's FUD campaign.

Posted by Joshua at October 6, 2003 11:43 AM

Corporate leaders do not worry only about direct legal action. They are also concerned regarding the indirect results of these legal fights might have on the bottom line. Could a possible court victor demand additional money from these companies? Also, what about other open source programmers coming out of the woodwork? When does the worrying cease?

Posted by David Thomson at October 6, 2003 12:26 PM

But Joshua, the issue isn't this particular lawsuit, as I said repeatedly in the piece. The point is that companies right now have no one to guarantee that they won't be sued. Traditional software companies provide a backstop: if Microsoft steals code, Microsoft gets sued. Whether or not these particular claims are valid, as they may or may not be, the lawsuit could still have a chilling effect on the decision to implement Linux.

IBM is being sued for, among other things, inducing others to distribute code, stolen by IBM or others, in order to cover up its own liability. It's also being sued for misappropriating code under license. These claims have been widely referred to in the media as copyright claims; I followed common usage. We can argue about whether or not it was legally allowed to do what SCO is claiming is misappropriation, but that doesn't get to the heart of the matter, which is how you guarantee the provenance of the software you're using. That's why SCO is bringing this suit. I agree that the suit is a publicity stunt, but it could still shut down open source if it goes badly.

Posted by Jane Galt at October 6, 2003 01:08 PM

"...but that doesn't get to the heart of the matter, which is how you guarantee the provenance of the software you're using. "

This is another way of saying that the purchasing company may have to pay out further money in the future. Paying money to a Microsoft or an Apple is a one time shot. There are no future financial surprises to be worried about.

Posted by David Thomson at October 6, 2003 01:22 PM

The worrying ceases as soon as enough time goes by and SCO is forced to put up or shut up with regards to their Linux claims. They can only do this for so long with out taking direct legal action. While not a direct comparison look at the problems RIAA and MPAA are having collecting revenue from something that's not even legally contested from a copyright violation standpoint with P2P networks and the massive distribution of Copyrighted works. They showed by example that talk is cheap even in the face of blantant & obvious disregard for copyright. Now compare with SCO's highly questionable claims regarded old IP rights to a code base that was largely tainted in the IP sense with the whole AT&T; BSD thing. Just like in the P2P world once enough of a user base is establised in Linux their will be too many end points to go after directly and OSS software can be cleansed all too quickly once the claims are out there in the public (as Darl rightfull fears). Companies are going to realize that just due to pure numbers and the fact that they can be running a distro that is clean by the time any legit case makes it to court will leave companies ignoring these types of claims. I think even in the end if SCO turns out to be right the speed with which the Linux code base will be cleaned will show companies with Linux investments / commitments that they made the right choice. They may have to upgrade all their servers to be in the legal clear but hey they should be doing that anyway to stay up to date with security patches etc. Whether SCO turns out to be right or wrong I think Linux will come out in the end smelling like roses since legal ramifications will not see the light of day for customers using the product. Right now they are saying pay us or else but are not actively invoicing customers or even taking direct legal action. This can only go on for so long until people eventually begin calling their bluff or think that these types of ploys are a cry wolf game. Now granted legal departments of corporations are more careful and wary than your average file trader but corporate legal teams will eventually get the picture when the study the case more closely. The worry is a result of SCO claims and drastic action to try and collect on their claims even before they are proven or even identified. If I as a company felt my claims were 100% solid I'd wait until they were proven in court before trying to collect on said claims but hey maybe I'm just a little too honest to be a CEO these days. I think in the end this case is going to do more for the OSS community than it does against it.

Posted by James Miller at October 6, 2003 01:24 PM

Megan,

I just read & commented on your article.

It was very poorly written. Your analysis seems clearly to be based upon ignorance of the issues involved.

Please do us a favor, and at least research the basic facts before publishing something. Unless you like to look ignorant.


And, BTW, as bad as that article was, I find your nom de plume "Jane Galt" an insult to Ayn Rand. [unless, of course, your ignorance also extends to your use of the feminine of "John Galt" from Atlas Shrugged."] Her protagonists always possessed a very strong ethical philosophy. All stood for TRUTH & HONESTY that bordered upon perfectionism. None would have suffered that tripe which you have fosted upon us.

rho

Posted by rho at October 6, 2003 01:35 PM

Dave I think saying Linux depends on Altruism is an oversimplification of the truth if not an outright distortion of it. Altruism is giving of oneself for the benefit of others. But with OSS both the all users of the software benefit and I'd challenge you to find a Linux code contributor that doesn't in turn run Linux themselves. See they aren't just giving of themselves for others they are giving of themselves to directly benefit themselves and the benefit to others is just a side effect of that process that the developer decided not to capitialize upon since his motivation wasn't capital in the first place it was function. I think Utilitarianism is a greater force at play here which assumes the giving of one's effort and knowledge to produce a product that does something useful for them. The payment is the usefulness the product gives them not the licensing fees others pay for the right to use it.

Posted by James Miller at October 6, 2003 01:49 PM

Jane --

"IBM is being sued for, among other things, inducing others to distribute code, stolen by IBM or others, in order to cover up its own liability. It's also being sued for misappropriating code under license. These claims have been widely referred to in the media as copyright claims....

I haven't read the entirety of the complaint against IBM, but I haven't heard that particular bit before. IBM is being accused of contributing code to Linux, but the code in question is its own. SCO is claiming that the code was originally written as part of AIX (IBM's version of Unix), and thus is a derivative work, and therefore that SCO has control over its distribution. SCO's interpretation of 'derivative work' is so broad as to be ludicrous, as I am sure you are aware.

The copyright claims (and the fact that the media are generally misrepresenting the entirety of the situation) are due to an entirely different action, one that was until recently purely a PR ploy (I say until recently because they have recently brought suit again SGI). SCO is claiming that parts of the unix code base that it bought (several incarnations ago) are in Linux; it has not produced any evidence that this is true. The analysts who say that they "may have a case" have said that they were shown chunks of code that look identical, but they have no way of knowing from whence it came. The only instances of code that SCO has actually produced have been shown to be public domain.

I don't know that SCO has brought suit against any makers of linux boxes. Red Hat has sued SCO, asking the court for a declaration that SCO is basically full of it.

The fact that this suit is a publicity stunt, as you point out in your comment above, is important. But the outcome, should it actually get to trial, will likely be good for open source. The code base cannot be declared clear for good and all, but it will create a precedent for complaints, and clarify the responsibilities of end users. Admittedly, the court system produces the occasional truly stupid ruling, but barring something phenomenally moronic, the result should be a better understanding of the legal footing of open source.

Or I can hope so, anyway.

Posted by chichka at October 6, 2003 02:12 PM

"The payment is the usefulness the product gives them not the licensing fees others pay for the right to use it."

It appears that not everyone involved in the open source movement agrees with you. Sadly, it only takes a few to mess it up for everybody. A mere .00001% is sufficient to scare the heck out of a major corporate entity.

I am also, by the way, not an enemy of open source software. It was obvious that sooner or later, though, that someone would demand added compensation for their efforts. The proverbial crap has finally hit the fan.

Posted by David Thomson at October 6, 2003 02:17 PM

But Megan, it's simply not true that when MS releases code, it's only MS that can be sued. Witness the Microsoft v. Timeline case: MS licensed patents from Timeline, but didn't license the rights for third-party developers. The Washington state appeals court found for Timeline, and it appears that developers who use SQL Server 7 are liable to Timeline for royalty payments, and the CEO of Timeline is threatening to sue at least some of them for treble damages.
http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/53/29419.html

You can't get a guarantee that you won't be sued, not from open source and not from closed source; the best you could hope for is indemnification if you do get sued, as HP is offering for its Linux, or MS offers--with many caveats--to "volume" purchasers (as far as I know, they have not offered to indemnify any SQL Server developers against Timeline's suit, though).

The point is that despite a lot of scary noises made by SCO, nobody has ever sued any organization for copyright infringement for its use of Linux, let alone prevailed, so it is irrational to count being sued as a significant risk for Linux but not for closed-source code like SQLServer.

Posted by Joshua at October 6, 2003 02:46 PM

Joshua, I'm speaking of corporate desktop/server implementations, not third party developers, which I agree is a different sort of market, but also not really the crucial problem for Linux right now. All I can do is repeat what I said: the legal experts I saw quoted stated that corporate clients faced increased risk of liability and penalties from a Linux installation.

No one has -- yet -- sued end-users for Linux, but that doesn't mean they can't or won't; SCO was threatening to do just that.

Posted by Jane Galt at October 6, 2003 03:00 PM

I think it's worth pointing out here that "open source" does not begin and end with Linux. Much of the critical infrastructure of the Internet (sendmail, Apache, etc...) is open-source code. The so-called "open source movement" is in fact just a continuation of larger trends toward open standards (TCP/IP, SQL, HTML) that have been going on for quite some time - and it doesn't have anything to do with altruism or "gift economies" - it's just good business sense for companies to avoid lock-in to one vendor and take advantage of the economies of scale that shared development provides.

Sorry, Jane - usually I'll give you props for reasonableness even when I disagree, but you're really missing the boat on this one...

Posted by jimbo at October 6, 2003 03:53 PM

Mr. Miller: One word. PARAGRAPHS.

Posted by Sigivald at October 6, 2003 05:04 PM

James Miller: does Linux have a return key? Geez, dude!!

Megan: if I were going to get on a blogging kick right now so that I could be viewed as a prescient prognosticator in 2 years, this would be the topic. "Open Source Software" is tired rhetoric and a movement on the decline.

Posted by Brad Hutchings at October 6, 2003 05:50 PM

It looks like the problem will disappear if "loser pays" is adopted.

Posted by Joseph Hertzlinger at October 6, 2003 09:23 PM

There are many things that require response in this article. I believe it was written not out of malice but without some understanding of the reason that free software and open source evolved.

It has never been the goal to copy existing works line for line and make it "free" for everyone. The driving passion for most of us is to write software that works the way we want it to work. We write because we have a belief we can write it better. Commercial software is constrained by budgets and market-driven deadlines. If you read "Peopleware" by Tom DeMarco and Tom Lister you'll get an idea of the issues for developing software in a commercial environment. You'll see phrases like "quality - if time permits" and "we haven't got time to think about this job, only to do it". That is the constraint that developers have fought against.

Open source and free software (open software) development evolved from an existing mode of development - skunkworks projects. These projects were hidden away from upper management because the belief of the development team was so strong that they defied the management decision to kill the projects. These beliefs also drove us to develop these projects by even committing our own leisure time. So this stuff on open software hasn't emerged full blown and without precedent.

However, the corporatisation of research and development from the mid-eighties has killed real innovation. Short term gains, with a yearly and more usually a quarterly focus has allowed only the low hanging research and development fruit to be reaped. Look at the contributions of Bell Labs to technology and compare it to the contributions of the corporatised Lucent. That's corporate reality. And the tight fiscal control imposed since the eighties has driven skunkworks from the corporate world into the wilderness - it is what most people call the FLOSS world.

Things perhaps evolve at a slower pace in the open software environment, but more effort is spent in getting the engineering right. There are no pressures for corporate deadlines and there is no pressure to cut corners. There is a strong effort to get it right and a belief that the finished product is going to be better than a commercial product. This to a large extent also means that developers are less inclined to want code tainted by commercially cut code mainly because of the in-grained belief system and mind set of these developers. Given specifications we might develop similar implementations. However, appropriating proprietary code is not even a consideration for the vast majority of open source and free software developers.

The current UNIX/SCO dilemma exists because of the cross-pollination of code and the availability of publicly released code. For the record, UNIX is both a trademark and a brand, neither of which is owned by SCO. The Open Group own the UNIX trademark and are the maintainers of the Single UNIX Specification. Any UNIX-like implementation that passes the certification tests for the Single UNIX Specification can use the UNIX brand for their product. The specification allows developers to produce specification-compliant systems. And the public release of code, even by SCO itself has contributed to this deluge of UNIX-compliant code. There has never been any malicious intent to use proprietary code. The collaborative and open practices for open software development has made the code implementation process transparent and available for the public record. This makes it uniquely different to proprietary coding practices and allows immediate scrutiny by any viewer, including proprietary development houses.

The code that SCO have so far highlighted does not indicate any breakthrough advances that greatly benefit the Linux product. Further the code in question related to a very specific hardware platform - the ia64 (Itanium 64-bit processor) and to performance improvements related to this development. This work was contributed to by SCO in various ways and in various incarnations. For further background, I would suggest looking at the Trillian project and the Monterey project to see the tangled developments between SCO, Caldera, IBM and SGI. Information on these are available publicly and on-line. So there are a number of layers of deception about the claims and SCO have not helped themselves by contributing to the releases of code, tainting any work in the areas in question. However, this is merely an aside in addressing the misconception that open software developers are somehow actively looking to misappropriate code at every opportunity. Sheer self-belief and weight of numbers will suffice in developing good software implementations.

Linux and open software are not about and have never been about toppling Microsoft in any concerted and corporate way. Many analysts take the notion that the products have been developed as some sort of corporate strategy by FLOSS. This is not the case, and to portray it in such a manner does us a disservice.

The developers have a belief that they can produce a better computing system. Whether or not the business world adopt open software is really a side issue. The banner against commercial competitors may be taken up by business advocates or by the services organisations but for the rest of us as open software developers, we built software because we didn't like what was available commercially. Free software is about freedom of choice.

Finally, I think the comparison to car dealerships is a poor one. Open software development should not be likened to the car dealerships because they represent the producer or manufacturer. The car dealerships are analogous with Red Hat, IBM, HP, SGI and SuSE. This middle-tier provides services to the customer. They are the value-add. As many people are at pains to point out, open software developers cannot provide guarantees on support. However, organisations with good service arms can provide service guarantees and they avoid the costly investment in research and development by using open software products. They might help seed or help better engineer the open software products as evidenced by IBM's efforts, but at nowhere near the same cash burn rate as internal product might.

Posted by JonB at October 6, 2003 11:41 PM

Believe me, JonB, I was not meaningfully attempting to compare Linux with a car dealership, except in the sense that things can have qualities that are non-obvious because they aren't valuable to you, but are nonetheless critical. Nor am I trying to make any sort of comment about how open source works, or why people develop it. I'm looking at it from a market perspective: will it be adopted, or not?

Posted by Jane Galt at October 7, 2003 12:03 AM

Wow. There are a huge number of people here who hold obvious malice against Linux. I'm not talking about disregard or disinterest. It's not even as benign as arguing the position of devil's advocate. There are people here who obviously hate Linux and feel no qualms about insulting the developers, the users and the software itself.

I honestly can't understand why. Linux developers write their code and give it away, for free, for any use, and they ask nothing in return. They're happy to share the code with you. They don't force the code upon you. It's a gift, not a burden.

So why so much vindictive against Linux? It's like spitting on Santa Claus.

Posted by Nathan Hand at October 7, 2003 03:01 AM

Analysing whether the business market will adopt or will not adopt open software is fine. But don't assign to the open software movement any ambition other than a desire to build better software. As developers, we can build alternative software if we don't like what we have to use now, whatever the personal reasons. That is what has been done. Whether the business market wants to use the products created is a question for the business market.

But from a market perspective, I believe the beneficiaries will be service organisations. It is the "dealerships" that become the important value add. This is the area in which IBM is focusing. It makes sense of the acquisition of Price Waterhouse Coopers. The integration of products into a coherent business framework, the delivery to the corporate customer of a custom business solution are areas into which the open software developer does not venture. The software components themselves are just a part of the solution and open software initiatitives have commoditized certain components.

SCO for want of a better term, has failed in the value chain as a reseller and failed as a value-added service provider, against competition such as Red Hat, SuSE and IBM. They are now trying to return to an OS market where there is not much competition, with few OS providers and where the OS is therefore of high value. It is doubtful that they will be able to reverse the progress of the past 12 years. Even in the unlikely event that SCO should succeed in their suit against IBM, there is an alternative to Linux in BSD. And SCO rely on many pieces of open software including compilers and development tools, and the Samba technology, to name but a few of their dependencies. So their victory may limit their own on-going capability to establish new future business. But that is quite beside the discussion at hand.

For what it is worth, I believe the next strategic battle will be over the business service infrastructure. It will be about the ability to quickly deploy business solutions that are aligned with each company's unique and changing value proposition to their customers, and about enhancing that proposition. This will firstly be the choice between the J2EE framework and the ability to connect with many open standards based business infrastructure; or Microsoft and its proprietary .NET framework. Secondly it will be about the service personnel who can achieve the delivery of this to the business plans.

The OS in an open standards world can be replaced by another standards compliant OS. It is of little moment in the value chain. In a sense, open standards lead to open software and interchangeability of components. There is a limit on product differentiation for components and this acts to drive the perceived market value of the component down. Therefore, the OS market itself should not be the burning strategic desire of any IT company with an expectation for any significant future business in an open standards world. But that, I believe, is a topic for another time.

Posted by JonB at October 7, 2003 03:56 AM

I'm amazed and saddend at what a closed mind can see when writing about open concepts.

Posted by Dave at October 12, 2003 10:14 AM

hi,your homepage looks really good and gives great information! Keep up the great work! good look,



sonneries
sonneries polyphoniques
sonnerie monophonique
repondeur
logo operateur
logo couleur
big logo
logo groupe
logo animé
jeux mobile
joke et canulars
sonneries
sonneries polyphoniques
sonnerie monophonique
repondeur
logo operateur
logo couleur
big logo
logo groupe
logo animé
jeux mobile
canulars
sonnerie
">sonneries
sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries hifi
repondeur mobile
logos couleurs
logos
logos couleur animes
logos kamasutra
big logos
logos groupe
creer un logo
big logos perso
logos prenom
navigateur sonyericsson
photos perso
messages image
jeux java
envoi sms
?part=isonn">Façades et Coques
sonneries
sonneries mono
sonneries poly
sonneries gags
sonneries voix
sonneries digital
mini sonneries
logos couleurs
logos couleurs animes
logos operateurs
big logos
mini logos
logos kamasutra
logos groupe
logos persos
big logos persos
createur logos
logos prenoms
special sonyericsson
message images
jeux java
repondeurs
canulars
envoi sms
boutique mobile
sonnerie
sonnerie monophonique
sonnerie polyphonique
sonnerie gag
sonnerie voix
sonnerie digital 40
mini sonnerie
logos couleurs
logos couleurs animes
logos operateurs
logos groupe
logos persos
logos prenom
createur logos
big logos
big logos persos
messages images
mini logos
logos kamasutra
sonyericsson
jeu mobile
annonces repondeurs
canulars
videos pour portable
envoi sms
sonneries
sonneries mono
sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries hifi
sonneries digital
logos couleurs
logos couleurs animes
logos operateurs
mini logos
big logos
logos kamasutra
logos groupe
logos persos
big logos persos
createur logos
logos prenoms
sonneries sonyericsson
message images
annonces repondeurs
surprises vocales
canulars
jeux java
sonneries compatibles
sms quizz
sms astro
sms blagues
jeux sms
envoi sms
chat sms
boutique mobile
sonnerie-polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique
sonnerie polyphoniques
hifi
digital 40 tons
mini
couleur
couleur anime
logo
big logo
mini polyphonique
kamasutra
logos groupes
logo perso
big logo perso
createur logo
logo prenom
sonyericsson
image
repondeur
surprise
dedicace
canular
sonnerie compatible
jeu
sms quizz
sms astro
sms blague
jeu sms
videos mobile
envoi sms
chat sms
boutique mobile
sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries monophoniques
sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries gags
sonneries voix
sonneries digital
mini sonneries
logos couleurs
couleurs animes
logos operateurs
big logos
mini logos
logos kamasutra
creation logo
logos prenoms
sony ericsson
messages images
jeux java
annonces repondeurs
canulars
top videos
envoi sms
sonnerie
sonneries
polyphoniques
hifi
digital
logo couleur
couleur anime
Logos opérateurs
big logo
kamasutra
groupe
logo perso
big logo perso
creation logo
logo prenom
sonyericsson
image message
repondeur
surprise vovale
sonnerie dedicace
canular
jeu java
sonnerie compatible
sms quizz
sms astro
sms blague
jeu sms
envoi sms
chat sms
boutique pour mobile
logo
logo couleur
logo couleur anime
logo operateur
big logo
logo kamasutra
logo persos
big logos perso
createur logo
logo prenom
special sonyericsson
message image
sonnerie mono
sonnerie poly
sonnerie hifi
sonnerie digital
annonce repondeur
surprise vocale
canulars
jeux java
compatibilite amoureuse
jeux sms
envoi sms
boutique mobile
logos gratuits
logos couleurs
couleurs animes
logos operateurs
big logos
mini logos
logos kama


Posted by repondeur at January 10, 2004 01:27 PM

I just surfed around and found your site, I really enjoyed the visit and hope to come back soon. Greetings,


 

sonnerie polyphonique
sonneries polyphoniques
logo
logos gratuits
sonneries
sonnerie
sms gratuits
repondeur
sonneries
sonnerie
niceur
sonneries
sonnerie
sonnerie polyphonique
polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique gratuite
sonnerie polyphonique gratuit
sonnerie polyphonique samsung
service logo sonnerie polyphonique
sonnerie and polyphonique
musique polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique portable
sonnerie portable polyphonique
telecharger sonnerie polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique sms
sonnerie polyphonique telecharger
polyphonique gratuit
sonnerie polyphonique nokia
sonnerie polyphonique pour samsung
sonnerie polyphonique sagem
composer sonnerie polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique composer
telechargement sonnerie polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique pour portable
sonnerie polyphonique motorola
soneries polyphonique
melodie polyphonique
polyphonique gratuite
sonnerie polyphonique pour mobile
sonnerie polyphonique pour sagem
sonnerie polyphonique pour motorola
sonnerie polyphonique 40 tons
samsung polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique motorola c350
sonnerie polyphonique pour panasonic gd67
polyphonique sonnerie
sonnerie polyphonique samsung a800
sonnerie polyphonique samsung t100
sonnerie polyphonique pour nokia
sonnerie polyphonique alcatel
logo couleur et sonnerie polyphonique
soneri polyphonique
logo et sonnerie polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique pour motorola c350
sonnerie polyphonique pour sagem myx5
sonnerie polyphonique pour samsung a800
sonnerie polyphonique sagem myx5
sonnerie polyphonique telecharger gratuitement
polyphonique samsung
sonnerie polyphonique nec
sonnerie polyphonique pour alcatel
sonnerie polyphonique pour telephone mobile
sonnerie polyphonique exorciste
sonnerie polyphonique pour samsung n600
telecharger sonnerie polyphonique gratuitement
composition sonnerie polyphonique
music polyphonique
polyphonique gratuite siemens
samsung t100 polyphonique
sonnerie gratuite polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique et logo
sonnerie polyphonique hi fi
sonnerie polyphonique pour telephone portable
sonnerie polyphonique samsung s300
polyphonique 40 tons
sonnerie and polyphonique and gratuite
sonnerie polyphonique alcatel 511
sonnerie polyphonique pour panasonic
lg sonnerie polyphonique
logo sonnerie polyphonique
polyphonique gratuit samsung belgique
polyphoniques gratuit sonnerie polyphonique
sonneire polyphonique
sonnerie motorola polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique et logo couleur
sonnerie polyphonique gd55
sonnerie polyphonique gratuite pour samsung
sonnerie polyphonique lg
telecharger polyphonique
centre art polyphonique
polyphonique gratuit samsung
samsung sonnerie polyphonique
sonnerie gangsta lovin polyphonique
sonnerie gsm polyphonique
sonnerie polyphonique a800
sonnerie polyphonique ac dc
sonnerie polyphonique envoi sms
sonnerie polyphonique gratuite composer
sonnerie polyphonique ich will
sonnerie polyphonique motorola t720
sonnerie polyphonique nokia 6610
sonnerie polyphonique panasonic gd67
sonnerie polyphonique pour t100
sonnerie polyphonique techno
sonnerie polyphonique telechargement gratuit
sonneris polyphonique
t100 polyphonique
telechargement gratuit sonnerie polyphonique
telecharger sonnerie polyphonique gratuit
gsm polyphonique
midi polyphonique
partition sonnerie polyphonique
sonneries polyphoniques
polyphoniques
sonneries polyphoniques gratuites
sonneries polyphoniques gratuits
sonneries polyphoniques samsung
services logos sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries and polyphoniques
musique polyphoniques
sonneries polyphoniques portables
sonnerie portable polyphonique
telecharger sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries polyphoniques sms
sonneries polyphoniques telecharger
polyphoniques gratuits
sonneries polyphoniques nokia
sonneries polyphoniques pour samsung
sonneries polyphoniques sagem
composer sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries polyphoniques composer
telechargement sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries polyphoniques pour portables
sonneries polyphoniques motorola
soneries polyphonique
melodies polyphoniques
polyphoniques gratuites
sonneries polyphoniques pour mobiles
sonneries polyphoniques pour sagem
sonneries polyphoniques pour motorola
sonneries polyphoniques 40 tons
samsung polyphoniques
sonneries polyphoniques motorola c350
sonneries polyphoniques pour panasonic gd67
polyphoniques sonneries
sonneries polyphoniques samsung a800
sonneries polyphoniques samsung t100
sonneries polyphoniques pour nokia
sonneries polyphoniques alcatel
logos couleurs et sonneries polyphoniques
soneris polyphoniques
logos et sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries polyphoniques pour motorola c350
sonneries polyphoniques pour sagem myx5
sonneries polyphoniques pour samsung a800
sonneries polyphoniques sagem myx5
sonneries polyphoniques telecharger gratuitement
polyphoniques samsung
sonneries polyphoniques nec
sonneries polyphoniques pour alcatel
sonneries polyphoniques pour telephone mobile
sonneries polyphoniques exorcistes
sonneries polyphoniques pour samsung n600
telecharger sonneries polyphoniques gratuitement
composition sonneries polyphoniques
music polyphoniques
polyphoniques gratuites siemens
samsung t100 polyphoniques
sonneries gratuites polyphoniques
sonneries polyphoniques et logos
sonneries polyphoniques hi fi
sonneries polyphoniques pour telephones portables
sonneries polyphoniques samsung s300
polyphoniques 40 tons
sonneries and polyphoniques and gratuites
sonneries polyphoniques alcatel 511
sonneries polyphoniques pour panasonic
lg sonneries polyphoniques
logos sonneries polyphoniques
polyphoniques gratuits samsung belgique
polyphoniques gratuits sonneries polyphoniques
sonneires polyphoniques
sonneries motorola polyphoniques
sonneries polyphoniques et logos couleurs
sonneries polyphoniques gd55
sonneries polyphoniques gratuites pour samsung
sonneries polyphoniques lg
telecharger polyphoniques
centre art polyphoniques
polyphoniques gratuits samsung
samsung sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries gangsta lovin polyphoniques
sonneries gsm polyphoniques
sonneries polyphoniques a800
sonneries polyphoniques ac dc
sonneries polyphoniques envoi sms
sonneries polyphoniques gratuites composer
sonneries polyphoniques ich will
sonneries polyphoniques motorola t720
sonneries polyphoniques nokia 6610
sonneries polyphoniques panasonic gd67
sonneries polyphoniques pour t100
sonneries polyphoniques techno
sonneries polyphoniques telechargement gratuits
sonneris polyphoniques
t100 polyphoniques
telechargement gratuits sonneries polyphoniques
telecharger sonneries polyphoniques gratuits
gsm polyphoniques
midi polyphoniques
partitions sonneries polyphoniques
logo
logo couleur
logo et sonnerie
logo gratuit
logo sonnerie
logo portable
sonnerie et logo
sonnerie logo
logo skate
logo anime
logo mobile
logo nokia
creation logo
logo pour portable
logo de telephone
logo couleur gratuit
logo gsm
sonnerie et logo gratuit
logo sagem
logo marque
logo et sonnerie gratuit
logo portable gratuit
logo et sonnerie gratuite
telechargement de logo
logo pour mobile
logo alcatel
logo motorola
logo sms
logo telecharger
logo pour telephone portable
big logo
logo pour telecharger
logo sonnerie gratuit
telecharger des logo
logo design
logo sexy
creer logo
logo samsung
logo couleur anime
logo et sonnerie portable
logo sonnerie.com
logo operateur
logo psg
logo telephone portable
logo et sonnerie pour portable
logo pour nokia
logo geant
logo pour sagem
sonnerie et logo de portable
logo om
logo renault
logo couleur portable
logo ferrari
logo sonnerie portable
logo couleur pour portable
telechargement logo gratuit
telechargement logo portable
sonnerie logo portable
nokia logo
sonnerie et logo pour portable
logo skateboard
.logo-max.com">logo foot
logo sonneries
petit logo
logo sonnerie gratuite
logo pour motorola
sonnerie logo gratuit
logo marque skate
logo gratuis
logo et soneries
logo nike
logo philips
logo cannabis
logo voiture
logo manager
logo siemens
mobile logo
logo pour alcatel
logo moto
logo nokia gratuit
logo perso
logo anniversaire
logo sport
logo peugeot
telecharger logo gratuit
logo gratuit pour portable
logo alcatel 311
1001 logo
logo matrix
logo sfr
logo pour telephone
logo prenom
logo hot
logo pour gsm
logo et sonnerie gratuit
logos
logos couleurs
logos et sonneries
logos gratuits
logos sonneries
logos portables
sonneries et logos
sonneries logos
logos skate
logos animes
logos mobiles
logos nokia
creation logos
logos pour portables
logos de telephones
logos couleurs gratuits
logos gsm
sonnerie et logos gratuits
logos sagem
logos marques
logos et sonneries gratuits
logos portables gratuits
logos et sonneries gratuites
telechargement de logos
logos pour mobiles
logos alcatel
logos motorola
logos sms
logos telecharger
logos pour telephones portables
big logos
logos pour telecharger
logos sonneries gratuits
telecharger des logos
logos design
telechargez des logos
creer logos
logos samsung
logos couleurs animes
logos et sonneries portables
logos sonneries
logos operateur
logos psg
logos telephones portables
logos et sonneries pour portables
logos pour nokia
logos geants
logos pour sagem
sonneries et logos de portables
logos om
logos renault
logos couleurs portables
logos ferrari
logos sonneries portables
logos couleurs pour portables
telechargement logos gratuits
telechargement logos portables
sonneries logos portables
nokia logos
sonneries et logos pour portables
logos skateboard
logos foot
logos sonneries
petits logos
logos sonneries gratuites
logos pour motorola
sonneries logos gratuits
logoss marques skate
logos gratuis
logos et soneries
logos nike
logos philips
logos cannabis
logos voiture
logos manager
ogos siemens
mobiles logos
logos pour alcatel
logos motos
logos nokia gratuits
logos perso
logos anniversaire
logos sport
logos peugeot
telecharger logos gratuits
logos gratuits pour portables
logos alcatel 311
1001 logos
logos matrix
logos sfr
logos pour telephones
logos prenom
logos hot
logos pour gsm
logos et sonneries gratuits
code sonneries
compose sonneries
composer sonneries nokia
composer sonneries portable
composer sonneries
composer une sonneries
compositeur sonneries nokia
compositeur sonneries
composition sonneries nokia
composition sonneries portables
composition sonneries
logos et sonneries gratuites
logos et sonneries gratuites
logos et sonneries portables
logos et sonneries pour portable
logos et sonneries
logos sagem
logos sonneries gratuites
logos sonneries
matrix sonneries
nokia sonneries
partition sonneries portable
partition sonneries
service logos sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries 3310
sonneries a composer
sonneries alcatel
sonneries compose
sonneries composees
sonneries composer nokia
sonneries composer pour nokia
sonneries compositeur
sonneries digital
sonneries ericsson
sonneries et logos gratuits
sonneries et logos
sonneries gratuit
sonneries gratuite
sonneries gratuites composer
sonneries gratuites motorola
sonneries gratuites nokia
sonneries gratuites portables
sonneries gratuites pour nokia
sonneries gratuites pour portable
sonneries gratuites
sonneries gratuits
sonneries gsm
sonneries hi fi
sonneries hifi
sonneries lg
sonneries logos
sonneries matrix
sonneries mmf
sonneries mobile gratuites
sonneries mobile
sonneries motorola c350
sonneries motorola
sonneries nokia 3310
sonneries nokia 3410
sonneries nokia composer
sonneries nokia gratuites
sonneries nokia
sonneries panasonic
sonneries poliphoniques
sonneries poly
sonneries polyphonique
sonneries polyphoniques gratuites
sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries portable composer
sonneries portable gratuites
sonneries portable gratuits
sonneries portable
sonneries portables nokia
sonneries pour alcatel
sonneries pour gsm
sonneries pour motorola
sonneries pour nokia
sonneries pour portable
sonneries pour sagem
sonneries pour samsung
sonneries pour telephone portable
sonneries sagem myx5
sonneries sagem
sonneries samsung a300
sonneries samsung
sonneries siemens
sonneries sony ericsson
sonneries t68i
sonneries taper
sonneries telecharger
sonneries telephone gratuites
sonneries telephone mobile
sonneries telephone portable
sonneries telephone
telechargement sonneries gratuites
telechargement sonneries portable
telechargement sonneries
telecharger sonneries gratuites
telecharger sonneries portables
telecharger sonneries
telechargez sonneries
 sonnerie -
sonnerie portable -
sonnerie gratuite -
composer sonnerie -
composer une sonnerie -
sonnerie pour portable -
sonnerie polyphonique -
logo et sonnerie -
sonnerie et logo -
logo sonnerie -
sonnerie logo -
sonnerie nokia -
sonnerie pour nokia -
sonnerie mobile -
sonnerie pour mobile -
sonnerie a composer -
sonnerie telephone -
sonnerie portable gratuite -
composition sonnerie -
sonnerie sagem -
sonnerie gsm -
compositeur sonnerie -
telecharger sonnerie -
sonnerie alcatel -
sonnerie samsung -
sonnerie gratuit -
sonnerie pour telephone portable -
sonnerie motorola -
telechargement sonnerie -
sonnerie hifi -
service logo sonnerie polyphoniques -
sonnerie telephone portable -
sonnerie telecharger -
sonnerie portable gratuit -
sonnerie gratuite pour nokia -
sonnerie hi fi -
sonnerie portable composer -
sonnerie gratuite composer -
matrix sonnerie -
sonnerie ericsson -
partition sonnerie -
sonnerie taper -
sonnerie et logo gratuit -
sonnerie nokia gratuite -
sonnerie polyphoniques gratuite -
sonnerie gratuite nokia -
sonnerie nokia 3310 -
sonnerie nokia composer -
sonnerie composer pour nokia -
sonnerie gratuite pour portable -
partition sonnerie portable -
logo et sonnerie gratuit -
sonnerie polyphonique gratuite -
sonnerie telephone mobile -
logo et sonnerie gratuite -
composer sonnerie portable -
sonnerie panasonic -
sonnerie siemens -
sonnerie compose -
composition sonnerie portable -
sonnerie motorola c350 -
telechargez sonnerie -
sonnerie pour sagem -
sonnerie poliphonique -
composer sonnerie nokia -
sonnerie composee -
sonnerie pour motorola -
sonnerie gratuite portable -
logo sonnerie gratuit -
sonnerie lg -
nokia sonnerie -
sonnerie sagem myx5 -
telechargement sonnerie portable -
sonnerie mobile gratuite -
sonnerie samsung a300 -
sonnerie compositeur -
sonnerie gratuite motorola -
telecharger sonnerie portable -
sonnerie t68i -
compositeur sonnerie nokia -
sonnerie pour gsm -
sonnerie portable nokia -
sonnerie pour samsung -
sonnerie pour alcatel -
logo et sonnerie portable -
compose sonnerie -
sonnerie nokia 3410 -
telecharger sonnerie gratuite -
sonnerie 3310 -
sonnerie matrix -
composition sonnerie nokia -
telechargement sonnerie gratuite -
sonnerie sony ericsson -
code sonnerie -
sonnerie telephone gratuite -
sonnerie poly -
sonnerie composer nokia -
sonnerie mmf -
logo et sonnerie pour portable -
sonneries logos -
sonneries et logos -
logos sonneries -
logos et sonneries -
sonneries sagem -
sonneries pour sagem -
logos sagem -
logos pour sagem -
logo sagem -
logo pour sagem -
sonneries nokia -
sonneries pour nokia -
logo nokia -
logo pour nokia -
logos nokia -
logos pour nokia -
sonneries polyphoniques -
logo couleur -
logos couleurs -
logos couleur -
sonneries -
logo -
logos -
melodie -
melodies -
sonneries hifi -
sonneries digital -
sonnerie digital
sms gratuit
 sms
 envoi de sms gratuit
 envoi sms
 envoi gratuit de sms
 envoyer sms
 envoyer sms gratuit
 alerte sms
 sms gratuit belgique
 sms gratuit orange
 sms sfr
 sms gratuit sfr
 sms gratuis -
 envoyer sms gratuitement
 sms gratos
 sms musical
 sms and gratuit
 message sms
 free sms
 sms gratuitement
 sfr sms gratuit
 service sms gratuit
 sms gratuit sans inscription
 sms gratui
 france telecom sms
 envoi sms gratuitement
 sms love
 sonnerie sms
 sfr sms
 blague sms
 sms sfr gratuit
 logo sms
 envoi gratuit message sms
 sms amour
 sms gratuit vers sfr
 message sms gratuit
 sms gratuit bouygues
 jeu concours sms
 service sms
 sms orange gratuit
 sms gratuit vers orange
 sms orange
 aol sms
 sms ascii
 serie sms
 envoi de message sms
 sms gratuit sur orange
 sms gratuit et illimite
 sms gratuit sur sfr
 communication sms
 sms bouygues
 diffusion mailing sms
 sms texto
 alert sms
 sms rigolo
 sms gratis
 sms aol
 envoi sms gratuit sans inscription
 envoye sms
 forfait sms
 diffusion sms commercial
 envoye sms gratuit
 sms free
 service d envoi de sms
 sms gratuit france
 envoi sms gratuit vers orange
 sms envoi
 ecrire sms
 gratuitement sms
 sms photo
 diffusion sms publicitaire
 gratuit sms
 sms gratuit suisse
 envoi sms sfr
 langage sms
 orange sms gratuit
 envoi sms gratuit sfr
 orange sms
 sms image
 sms gratiut
 sms gratuit envoi
 envoi sms gratuit vers sfr
 sms amusant
 sms blague
 sms texto gratuit
 sms gratuit envoyer
 envoi sms gratuis
 sms gratuit vers bouygues
minimessage
telemessage
repondeur
repondeurs
repondeur
 message de repondeur
 repondeur de portable
 repondeur mobile
 repondeur pour portable
 repondeur gratuit
 repondeur telephonique
 annonces de repondeur
 message sur le repondeur
 message pour repondeur
 message repondeur gratuit
 repondeur telephone
 repondeur pour mobile
 repondeur gsm
 messagerie repondeur
 sonnerie repondeur
 message repondeur portable
 telephone repondeur
 repondeur telephone portable
 

Posted by hebergement web at January 10, 2004 01:31 PM

Hi everybody.I just surfed on IN and found your really awesome site.It yields a lot of interesting content.Congratulations to this wonderful effort. Hold on.



free logos free ringtones
ringtones for ericsson
free ringtones for samsung
logos ringtones
panasonic ringtones
free siemens ringtones
ringtones for nokia phones
ringtones for samsung a300
composing ringtones
www free ringtones
free ericsson ringtones
ringtones for mobile
www ringtones
free ringtones sent
nokia keypress ringtones
7210 ringtones
find free ringtones
free keypress ringtones
nokia free ringtones
ringtones for samsung t100
sony ringtones
free ringtones for siemens
free downloadable ringtones
nokia ringtones and logos
free ringtones free logos com
hindi ringtones
ringtones for panasonic
free ringtones for nokia 3310
poly ringtones
composer ringtones for nokia
nokia polyphonic ringtones
bhangra ringtones
ringtones to compose
ringtones for mobile phones
sms ringtones
free nokia 3310 ringtone
c45 ringtones
hip hop ringtones
free ringtones for nokias
free ringtones for motorola
where can i find free ringtones
3210 ringtones
www free ringtones free logos
gd67 ringtones
ringtones download
ringtones galore
ringtones for mobiles
free indian ringtones
sony ericsson ringtones
ringtones siemens
nokia ringtones composer
nokia ringtones free
cheap ringtones
midi ringtones
ringtones motorola
free nokia ringtones and logos
get free ringtones
polyphonic ringtones for nokia
www free ringtones free logos com
ringtones for a nokia
8310 ringtones
free sagem ringtones
siemens c45 ringtones
3330 ringtones
latest ringtones
nokia 7210 ringtones
ringtones for composer
ringtones for my nokia
polyphonic ringtones for samsung
samsung polyphonic ringtones
download free ringtones
football ringtones
ringtones for sony ericsson
free bollywood ringtones
free ringtones composer
v50 ringtones
free ringtones for nokia phones
rock ringtones
free sms ringtones
ringtones for 3310
free ringtones for sagem
alcatel ringtones
www ringtones com
panasonic gd67 ringtones
nokia 3210 ringtones
a50 ringtones
ringtones and graphics
ringtones keypress
7650 ringtones
free logos ringtones
ringtones and logos for nokia
ringtones & logos
my ringtones
key press ringtones
compose your own ringtones
ericsson t68 ringtones
v66 ringtones
polyphonic ringtones free
ringtones ericsson
nokia 3330 ringtones
ringtones sony
ericsson t68i ringtones
find ringtones
free ringtones for mobile
free nokia keypress ringtones
3510 ringtones
arabic ringtones
ringtones for nokia 3210
rap ringtones
ringtones to download
rtttl ringtones
nokia 8310 ringtones
polyfonic ringtones
t300 ringtones
send free ringtones
ringtones sent to your phone
free ringtones for ericsson
free ringtones com
new ringtones
polyphonic ringtones nokia
ringtones compose
download polyphonic ringtones
mobile ringtones and logos
ringtones nokia 3310
ringtones and screensavers
free ringtones for sony
nokia 7650 ringtones
ringtones for nokia mobile
ringtones
free ringtones
nokia ringtones
free nokia ringtones
motorola ringtones
ringtones for nokia
polyphonic ringtones
phone ringtones
ringtones nokia
free motorola ringtones
3360 ringtones
free ringtones for nokia
ringtones for motorola
cell phone ringtones
download ringtones
downloadable ringtones
ringtones free
samsung ringtones
nokia 3360 ringtones
ericsson ringtones
3390 ringtones
composer ringtones
v60 ringtones
nextel ringtones
free polyphonic ringtones
nokia 3390 ringtones
ringtones motorola
free ringtones nokia
mobile ringtones
verizon ringtones
cingular ringtones
ringtones for samsung
free nokia 3360 ringtones
motorola v60 ringtones
t720 ringtones
free cell phone ringtones
free downloadable ringtones
free ringtones for motorola
wireless ringtones
5165 ringtones
keypress ringtones
download free ringtones
v60i ringtones
cellphone ringtones
pcs ringtones
nokia 5165 ringtones
nokia free ringtones
kyocera ringtones
midi ringtones
ringtones com
rtttl ringtones
free samsung ringtones
ringtones for nokia 3360
8260 ringtones
at & t ringtones
t68i ringtones
nokia composer ringtones
ringtones samsung
hip hop ringtones
ringtones download
motorola t720 ringtones
ringtones usa
free nokia 3390 ringtones
cellular ringtones
ringtones composer
rap ringtones
ringtones and logos
att ringtones
motorola v60i ringtones
ringtones for cell phones
ringtones for nokia 3390
free ericsson ringtones
nokia 8260 ringtones
ringtones for nokia phones
free ringtones motorola
ringtones for free
t68 ringtones
nokia ringtones free
sony ericsson ringtones
sms ringtones
free ringtones for samsung
panasonic ringtones
ringtones for ericsson
siemens ringtones
compose ringtones
hindi ringtones
ringtones for a nokia
ringtones and graphics
anime ringtones
free mobile ringtones
v66 ringtones
free ringtones and logos
rttl ringtones
free ringtones for nokia phones
free composer ringtones
ringtones ericsson
motorola free ringtones
free download ringtones
send ringtones
ringtones for sony ericsson
mobile phone ringtones
free sms ringtones
free ringtones samsung
arabic ringtones
indian ringtones
bollywood ringtones
gsm ringtones
free ringtones sent
motorola v66 ringtones
nokia ringtones composer
free nokia composer ringtones
nokia keypress ringtones
logos and ringtones
t300 ringtones
ringtones for siemens
ringtones downloads
where can i find free ringtones
chinese ringtones
ringtones keypress
free ringtones for ericsson
free keypress ringtones
free ringtones com
ringtones logos
ringtones sony
ericcson ringtones
composed ringtones
eminem ringtones
ericson ringtones
www ringtones
ringtones and screensavers
ringtones for panasonic
send free ringtones
ericsson t68 ringtones
ringtones to download
poly ringtones
get free ringtones
ringtones sent to your phone
7210 ringtones
composing ringtones
ericsson t68i ringtones
new ringtones
free ringtones download
tamil ringtones
rock ringtones
ringtones for nokias
ringtones siemens
www ringtones com
free ringtones free
ringtones sony ericsson
nokia polyphonic ringtones
ericsson free ringtones
ringtones for composer
ringtones sms
nokia 7210 ringtones
my ringtones
free hindi ringtones
free logos and ringtones
free ringtones ericsson
composable ringtones
free ringtones composer
free siemens ringtones
key press ringtones
3310 ringtones
ringtones and free
sony ringtones
ringtones panasonic
free ringtones free logos
free indian ringtones
ringtones nokia free
polyphonic ringtones free
ringtones free download
composer ringtones for nokia
ringtones uk
ringtones compose
ringtones for nokia composer
nokia ringtones and logos
free nokia keypress ringtones
free mobile phone ringtones
free ringtones for nokias
nokia 3310 ringtones
free ringtones logos
free bollywood ringtones
garage ringtones
ringtones for mobile phones
polyphonic ringtones for nokia
ringtones
ringtones
klingeltoene
klingeltoene
polyphone
digital polyphone
farbige logos
animierte logos
bildmitteilungen
handy logos
bildnachricht
gruppen logos
play handyspiele
ringtone
polyphonic
operator logos
color logos
screensavers
java games
big logos
picture message
group logos
sonneries
sonneries natel
sonneries polyphoniques
sonneries nokia
sonneries gratuites
logos et sonneries
logos sonneries
sonneries ericsson
sonneries pour natel
sonneries et logos
sonneries polyphonique
logo sonneries
sonneries portables
sonneries de natel
sonneries pour nokia
sonneries logos
sonneries portable
sonneries samsung
sonneries siemens
logo et sonneries
sonneries mobile
sonneries panasonic
nokia sonneries
sonneries motorola
sonneries pour ericsson
sonneries natels
sonneries sony ericsson
sonneries mobiles
sonneries pour portables
sonneries t68i
sonneries à composer
sonneries pour portable
sonneries t68
sonneries polyphoniques nokia
sonneries midi
sonneries pour siemens
sonneries polyphoniques gratuites
sonneries pour samsung
ericsson sonneries
sonneries téléphone
sonneries pour natels
sonneries gratuite
sonneries de portable
sonneries ericson
sonneries natel nokia
sonneries natel gratuites
logos et sonneries pour natel
logos sonneries natel
sonneries nokia gratuites
logos et sonneries natel
logos
sonneries et logos
logos nokia
logos and ringtones
logos de skate
sms
gratis sms
sms gratis
send free sms
envoi de sms
envoi sms gratuit
envoyer des sms
envoi de sms gratuit
sms gratuit orange
sms gratuit sfr
repondeur
message repondeur
logos et sonneries
logos sonneries
sonneries et logos gratuits
logos et sonneries gratuites
logos et sonneries gratuits
sonneries logos gratuits
sonneries et logos gratuit
logos et sonneries gratuit
logos sonneries gratuit
logos sonneries gratuits
logos sonneries nokia
sonneries et logos pour nokia
sonneries logos gratuit
logos et sonneries pour nokia
logos sonneries portable
logos et sonneries nokia
logos sonneries gratuites
sonneries logos nokia
sonneries et logos pour portable
logos et sonneries de portable
logos et sonneries pour portable
logos sonneries portables
logos et sonneries gsm
sonneries logos portable
logos sonneries gsm
logos et sonneries pour portables
sonneries logos portables
sonneries et logos pour portables
logos et sonneries pour alcatel
sonneries et logos pour sagem
sonneries et logos pour alcatel
logos et sonneries portable
sonneries et logos de portable
logos et sonneries portables
logos et sonneries de portables
sonneries logos gsm
sonneries logos alcatel
sonneries et logos gsm
logos sonneries alcatel
logos et sonneries pour sagem
logos et sonneries gratuite
logos et sonneries pour gsm
sonneries et logos portable
sonneries et logos portables
logos sonneries com
sonneries et logos pour gsm
sonneries logos sagem
telecharger logos et sonneries
sonneries et logos de portables
logos sonneries sagem
sonneries et logos alcatel
telecharger sonneries et logos
sonneries et logos a telecharger
télécharger logos et sonneries
logos et sonneries a telecharger
sonneries et logos gratuites
sms logos sonneries
sonneries et logos sagem
sonneries et logos à télécharger
téléchargement de logos et sonneries
logos et sonneries pour siemens
sonneries et logos pour siemens
sonneries et logos pour motorola
logos et sonneries alcatel
télécharger sonneries logos
télécharger sonneries et logos
sonneries logos siemens
telechargement de logos et sonneries
telecharger des logos et des sonneries
logos et sonneries pour mobiles
logos et sonneries pour motorola
logos et sonneries sagem
sonneries et logos gratuits pour nokia
logos sonneries siemens
telecharger logos sonneries
sonneries logos motorola
logos sonneries mobiles
logos sonneries motorola
logos sonneries sms
télécharger logos sonneries
logos et sonneries pour mobile
nokia sonneries logos
www logos sonneries com
logos et sonneries par sms
logos et sonneries pour nokia 3310
logos sonneries pour portable
logos et sonneries de gsm
logos sonneries mobile
téléchargement de sonneries et logos
sonneries et logos motorola
sonneries et logos pour ericsson
sonneries et logos gratuis
sonneries et logos pour mobile
sonneries et logos pour nokia 3310
sonneries et logos de gsm
logos sonneries gratuite
logos sonneries pour nokia
logos sonneries répondeurs
logos sonneries telephone
logos sonneries belgique
nokia logos sonneries
sonneries et logos pour mobiles
téléchargement logos et sonneries
sonneries logos mobiles
sonneries logos répondeurs
logos sonneries ericsson
sonneries et logos pour sagem myx 5
sonneries et logos mobiles
sonneries logos mobile
logos et sonneries com
logos et sonneries gratuis
logos et sonneries nokia 3310
sonneries et logos mobile
logos sonneries repondeurs
logos et sonneries pour natel
logos et sonneries mobiles
logos et sonneries pour sagem myx 5
logos sonneries natel
alcatel sonneries logos
sonneries et logos pour siemens c45
sonneries et logos à télécharger gratuitement
logos sonneries alcatel 511
sonneries logos alcatel 511
logos et sonneries natel
logos et sonneries belgique
klingeltöne
gratis klingeltöne
polyphone klingeltöne
klingeltöne gratis
kostenlose klingeltöne
handy klingeltöne
klingeltöne siemens
klingeltöne nokia
siemens klingeltöne
nokia klingeltöne
klingeltöne für nokia
klingeltöne für siemens
ericsson klingeltöne
klingeltöne download
klingeltöne ericsson
klingeltöne handy
logos und klingeltöne
klingeltöne fürs handy
logos klingeltöne
klingeltöne und logos
klingeltöne für ericsson
klingeltöne kostenlos
klingeltöne at
gratis polyphone klingeltöne
klingeltöne logos
klingeltöne österreich
gratis klingeltöne für nokia
polyphone klingeltöne gratis
klingeltöne zum selbermachen
klingeltöne per sms
gratis logos und klingeltöne
free klingeltöne
klingeltöne samsung
samsung klingeltöne
klingeltöne zum abtippen
www klingeltöne
klingeltöne für handy
gratis klingeltöne und logos
gratis klingeltöne für siemens
gratis klingeltöne fürs handy
gratis handy klingeltöne
poliphone klingeltöne
klingeltöne sony
polyphone klingeltöne download
klingeltöne zum eintippen
motorola klingeltöne
klingeltöne für samsung
klingeltöne toneditor
klingeltöne für sony
klingeltöne zum downloaden
klingeltöne komponieren
klingeltöne downloaden
klingeltöne free
klingeltöne motorola
klingeltöne zum abschreiben
polyphon klingeltöne
klingeltöne für handys
midi klingeltöne
gratis klingeltöne siemens
klingeltöne für motorola
gratis klingeltöne nokia
klingeltöne noten
klingeltöne zum selber machen
www klingeltöne at
gratis logos klingeltöne
gratis klingeltöne logos
handy klingeltöne gratis
klingeltöne herunterladen
klingeltöne für das handy
sms klingeltöne
download klingeltöne
klingeltöne für toneditor
klingeltöne für nokia 3510
sony klingeltöne
t68 klingeltöne
klingeltöne zum eingeben
3510 klingeltöne
türkische klingeltöne
klingeltöne für sagem
sagem klingeltöne
klingeltöne midi
klingeltöne selber machen
freie klingeltöne
klingeltöne polyphon
noten für klingeltöne
polyfone klingeltöne
gratis nokia klingeltöne
c55 klingeltöne
klingeltöne nokia gratis
klingeltöne für sony ericsson
klingeltöne sony ericsson
klingeltöne gratis download
klingeltöne zum herunterladen
s55 klingeltöne
toneditor klingeltöne
klingeltöne de
klingeltöne für siemens handys
kostenlos klingeltöne
polyphone klingeltöne nokia
klingeltöne für nokia 3310
sony ericsson klingeltöne
gratis klingeltöne handy
klingeltöne sagem
nokia 7650 klingeltöne
klingeltöne selbermachen
t65 klingeltöne
klingeltöne für nokia handys
klingeltöne nokia 3510
nokia 3510 klingeltöne
polyphone klingeltöne für nokia
gratis siemens klingeltöne
klingeltöne abtippen
nokia klingeltöne gratis
handylogos und klingeltöne
siemens klingeltöne gratis
s45 klingeltöne
klingeltöne nokia 7650
polyphone klingeltöne siemens
klingeltöne runterladen
gratis klingeltöne per sms
klingeltöne editor
polyphone klingeltöne samsung
klingeltöne zum runterladen
klingeltöne t68
t68i klingeltöne
klingeltöne gratis nokia
klingeltöne für nokia 7650
klingeltöne polyphone
klingeltöne siemens c55
ericson klingeltöne
kostenlose klingeltöne für nokia
handylogos klingeltöne
polyphonic klingeltöne
klingeltöne sms
klingeltöne s55
klingeltöne ericsson t65
kostenlose polyphone klingeltöne
klingeltöne handy gratis
siemens c55 klingeltöne
klingeltöne nokia 3310
klingeltöne zum anhören
pholyphone klingeltöne
klingeltöne für siemens handy
klingeltöne anhören
klingeltöne abschreiben
klingeltöne für ericson
jugoslawische klingeltöne
klingeltöne eintippen
klingeltöne ericcson
klingeltöne c55
mobile klingeltöne
klingeltöne logos gratis
klingeltöne gratis siemens
logos klingeltöne gratis
klingeltöne siemens m50
klingeltöne t68i
www klingeltöne de
klingeltöne 7650
klingeltöne für den toneditor
klingeltöne selbst komponieren
t300 klingeltöne
nirvana klingeltöne
klingeltöne siemens gratis
klingeltöne zum selber eingeben
klingeltöne für siemens mt50
kroatische klingeltöne
eminem klingeltöne
klingeltöne 3510
klingeltöne ericson
klingeltöne free download
klingeltöne s45
siemens s55 klingeltöne
klingeltöne zum selber eintippen
klingeltöne mid
klingeltöne zum selber komponieren
billige klingeltöne
klingeltöne downloads
siemens m50 klingeltöne
ericsson t68 klingeltöne
metal klingeltöne
klingeltöne download gratis
download polyphone klingeltöne
klingeltöne siemens s55
polyphonische klingeltöne
polyphone klingeltöne für samsung
kostenlose logos und klingeltöne
nokia 3310 klingeltöne
klingeltöne zum selber schreiben
sonneries
sonneries gsm
sonneries nokia
sonneries gratuites
sonneries polyphoniques
logos et sonneries
sonneries et logos
sonneries de gsm
sonneries ericsson
logos sonneries
sonneries pour gsm
sonneries siemens
sonneries pour nokia
sonneries polyphonique
sonneries logos
sonneries a composer
sonneries alcatel
sonneries gsm gratuites
logo et sonneries
sonneries samsung
sonneries gsm nokia
sonneries gratuite
sonneries à composer
logo sonneries
gsm sonneries
composition de sonneries
nokia sonneries
composer sonneries
sonneries gratuit
sonneries nokia 3310
sonneries pour ericsson
sonneries sony
sonneries motorola
sonneries et logo
sonneries pour siemens
sonneries gsm belgique
composition sonneries
sonneries compositeur
sonneries logo
compositeur sonneries
sonneries ericson
composer des sonneries
sonneries portable
sonneries gratuits
sonneries sony ericsson
logos et sonneries gsm
sonneries 3310
ericsson sonneries
sonneries belgique
sonneries gratuites nokia
télécharger sonneries
sonneries gratuites pour gsm
sonneries gsm siemens
logos sonneries gsm
sonneries gsm gratuit
compositeur de sonneries
sonneries pour samsung
sonneries pour nokia 3310

Posted by hebergement web at January 21, 2004 09:22 AM

cliparts + kostenlose cliparts + free cliparts + clip arts SMS Sprüche Handylogos Klingeltöne SMS-Sprüche Free SMS Free MMS + MMS Bilder Bildmitteilungen Fun Bilder Fun Videos SMS Sprüche + SMS Freie sms + sms sprüche + free sms free sms ohne anmeldung gratis sms ohne anmeldung kostenlos sms ohne anmeldung Fun + Humor + Fun Bilder + Fun Videos + Fun Games liebes sms sprüche + liebessprüche + liebes sms + liebes sprüche mms + mms bilder + free mms musik herunterladen + kazza download + free mp3 downloads + musik download sms-sprüche + klingeltöne + mms bilder Handysprüche + sms-sprüche + sms spruch + liebessprüche SMS Sprüche + kostenlose sms sprüche musik herunterladen + kazza download + free mp3 downloads sms verschicken + sms grusskarten casting Klingeltöne + SMS Sprüche handycodes + ringtones Klingeltöne + Handymelodien klingeltöne + Klingeltöne per sms + kostenlose klingeltöne klingelton + Klingeltöne ohne anmeldung + kostenlose klingeltöne free games + pc spiele + flashgames + flash games sms grüsse Klingeltöne + Handymelodien + klingelton gifs Liebes SMS + Logos freegames free games flash games + flashgamesspiele zum download cliparts + kostenlose cliparts Grusskarten fun videos liebes sms sprüche + liebessprüche + liebestexte + liebe spass bilder Flirten Kontakte Nackte Stars + stars nackt grußkarte + grußkarten Free Sex geschenke + geburtstagsgeschenke + hochzeitsgeschenke + weihnachtsgeschenke MMS Bilder + Polyphone Klingeltöne + SMS Bilder fahrschule + führerschein + führerscheinprüfung musik download + musik charts flashgames download cliparts hausaufgaben + referate spiele + games handylogos sms sprüche + handysprüche + sms sprüche liebe + liebes sms sprüche + kostenlose sms sprüche + sprüche sms + sms spruch Liebe, Liebestexte, Liebessprüche, Liebes SMS Sprüche, Liebes Sprüche, SMS Sprüche Liebe, Liebesgedichte, Liebes SMS online games + spiele download + pc games + flashspiele + computer games + computerspiele download liebes sms sprüche + klingeltöne nokia + handymelodien + handylogos siemens + handyspiele + klingeltöne siemens animierte grusskarten + elektronische grusskarten + grusskarten geburtstag + grusskarten liebe + digitale grusskarten free cliparts + animierte cliparts + cliparts geburtstag + cliparts hochzeit + cliparts ostern + clipart + cliparts weihnachten kostenlose sms sprüche + gratis sms sprüche + free sms sprüche sms sprüche geburtstag Freie sms + sms sprüche + free sms free sms gratis sms kostenlos sms handylogos + logos fahrschule + führerschein + führerscheinprüfung online games handyspiele kostenlose sms sprüche + handysprüche liebe sms texte + sms bilder + free sms handysprueche - handyspruch - bildmitteilung - bildmitteilungen - handy bildmitteilungen - logo - download handy logo klingeltoene - klingeltoene logo - logo design - handy logo - handylogo - sms spruch - handylogos - kostenlose handylogos - gratis handylogos - farbige handylogos - sms sprueche - sms sprueche weihnachten - sms sprueche neujahr - hobby technik handy sms sprueche - kostenlose sms sprueche - ascii bilder sms sprueche - weihnachts sms sprueche - liebes sprueche sms - sms sprueche liebe - silvester sms sprueche - liebes sms sprueche - handyklingeltoene - polyphon - klingeltoene polyphon - polyphon klingelton - klingelton - altes telefon klingelton - post klingelton - klingelton sirene - klingelton sparkasse - handy klingelton - polyphone - polyphone klingeltoene - polyphone toene - polyphone klingeltoene per sms - polyphone klingeltoene kostenlos - handytoene - klingeltoene - handy klingeltoene - klingeltoene handy - klingeltoene abschreiben - klingeltoene zum abtippen - klingeltoene zum abschreiben - klingeltoene komponieren - klingeltoene abtippen - tuerkische klingeltoene - logos klingeltoene - midi klingeltoene - logos - handy logos - kostenlose logos - farbige logos - handy farbige logos - logos animierte logos handy klingeltoene klingeltöne + handymelodien klingeltoene nokia nokia-logos klingeltoene siemens handy klingeltoene klingeltoene handymelodien handylogos handytoene kostenlose klingeltoene klingeltoene handymelodien polyphone klingeltoene sms klingeltoene freie klingeltoene mms bilder handymelodien logos klingeltoene klingeltoene nokia klingeltoene siemens klingeltoene motorola klingeltoene kostenlos logos ericsson klingeltoene gratis klingeltoene handy klingeltoene klingelton freie klingeltoene klingeltöne kostenlos computerspiele games kostenlose games spiele spiele download flashspiele flashgames flash-games download games free games online games download free games edonkey filesharing kostenlos edonkey download edonkey edonkey kazaa download kostenlose logos klingeltöne handylogos free sms nokia klingeltöne siemens klingeltöne motorola klingeltöne ericsson klingeltöne samsung klingeltoene mms klingeltöne mms bilder klingeltöne kostenlos klingeltöne klingeltöne nokia kostenlose nokia klingeltöne klingeltöne per sms aktuelle klingeltöne nokia logos + klingeltöne per sms klingeltöne siemens handy klingeltöne sms klingeltöne per sms handy klingeltöne per sms neue klingeltöne per sms polyphone klingeltöne klingelton gratis klingeltöne free klingeltöne kostenlose klingeltöne charts klingeltöne top klingeltöne top100 klingeltöne handylogos klingeltoene nokia kostenlose logos nokia klingeltoene siemens klingeltoene ericsson klingeltoene motorola klingeltoene sharp klingeltoene klingeltoene nokia nokia logos handy klingeltoene sms klingeltoene handy klingeltoene klingeltoene polyphone klingeltoene klingelton gratis klingeltoene kostenlose klingeltoene klingeltoene charts klingeltoene techno klingeltoene free klingeltoene handylogos klingeltoene klingeltoene siemens kostenlose-logos logos klingeltoene kostenlose logos free klingeltoene kostenlose logos siemens logos nokia logos logo kostenlos Kostenlose Logos kostenlos Handylogos Klingeltöne kostenlose Logos MMS Bilder klingeltöne und klingeltoene nokia auch polyphone klingeltöne und sms sowie sms sprüche und sms sprüche auch logos und logos und handylogos sowie bildmitteilungen nokia logos handy klingeltoene Klingeltöne für Siemens, Klingeltöne fürs Handy, Klingeltöne für Nokia Kostenlose Klingeltöne und polyphone Klingeltöne kostenlos ohne Anmeldung, Handytöne, Handymelodien Polyphone Klingeltöne, MMS Bilder, Handylogos und Bildmitteilungen Klingeltöne, Handymelodien, Ruftöne Polyphone Klingeltöne Klingeltöne Top 100 Pop Rock Techno Hip Hop Oldies Polyphone Klingeltöne Top 100 Polyphone Klingeltöne, Handylogos, MMS Bilder dazu Klingeltöne aus Pop + Rock + Techno + Hip Hop + Oldies und Bildmitteilungen für Dein Handy Kostenlose Klingeltöne und polyphone Klingeltöne kostenlos ohne Anmeldung, Handytöne, Handymelodien Klingeltöne Top 100 Pop Rock Techno Hip Hop Oldies Polyphone Klingeltöne Freie Klingeltöne, MMS Bilder und Handylogos ohne anmeldung SMS-Sprüche + Polyphone Klingeltöne + Handylogos + SMS Sprüche + MMS-Bilder, klingeltöne, handylogos, sms, sms-sprüche, mms klingelton für siemens, klingelton fürs handy, klingelton für nokia Handylogos Klingeltöne Logos Handylogo Klingelton Bildmitteilungen Handy Logo Polyphone Klingeltöne, Logos, MMS Bilder, Klingeltöne, Handylogos, kostenlos, Polyphone Klingeltöne, Logos, MMS-Bilder, kostenlose klingeltöne, Bildmitteilungen klingeltöne kostenlos und klingeltöne auch kostenlose klingeltöne sowie gratis klingeltöne viel von handy klingeltöne klingeltoene nokia nokia-logos klingeltoene siemens handy klingeltoene klingeltoene handymelodien handylogos handytoene kostenlose klingeltoene klingeltoene handymelodien polyphone klingeltoene sms klingeltoene freie klingeltoene mms bilder handymelodien logos klingeltoene klingeltoene nokia klingeltoene siemens klingeltoene motorola klingeltoene kostenlos logos ericsson klingeltoene gratis klingeltoene handy klingeltoene klingelton freie klingeltoene klingeltöne kostenlos computerspiele games download + pc spiele download + gratis games kostenlose games + spiele zum downloaden + flash spiele spiele + ondine games + download spiele spiele download + free games + onlinespiele flashspiele + spiele pc flashgames flash-games download games free games online games download free games edonkey filesharing kostenlos edonkey + musikfilme download download edonkey + mp3 video download edonkey kazaa download sms sprüche geburtstag sms sprüche glueckwunsch sms sprüche gute nacht sms sprüche guten morgen sms sprüche handy sms sprüche hochzeit kostenlose sms sprüche + sms sprüche hochzeitstag sms sprüche liebe + liebessprüche sms sprüche maenner + sms spruch sms sprüche sehnsucht sms sprüche türkisch sms sprüche vermiss dich sms sprueche versaut kostenlos sprüche geburtstag free sms free sms free games + spiele download kostenlose games spiele gratis games spiele neue free games top free games + games download spiele download flashspiele flashgames flash-games download free games download free games pc spiele free games kostenlose games games gratis free games Handylogos SMS Sprüche Klingeltöne klingeltöne nokia Bildmitteilungen + Bildmitteilung sms sprüche + klingeltöne liebestexte + liebes sms sprüche + liebessprüche bildmitteilungen börse freesms polyphone klingeltöne Handysprüche sms versand sms kostenlos sms-sprüche weihnachten logo bildmitteilungen cliparts sms sprüche geburtstag sms versenden freie sms geburtstag sms-spruch kostenlose klingeltönegemeine sms-sprüche gratis sms kostenlose sms sprüche kostenlose bildmitteilungen gratis sms spruch gratis sms sprüche sms sprüche geburt handysprüche handylogos klingeltöne kostenlos sms animierte bildmitteilungen kostenlose handylogos sylvester sms-sprüche kostenlose klingeltöne liebe sms sprüche liebes sms geburtstag sms sprüche lustige sms sprüche handy bildmitteilungen lustiger sms spruch neue sms sprüche sms senden sms spruch liebes sms sprüche Klingeltöne sms spruch de sms spruch versenden free bildmitteilungen sms sprüche sms sprüche archive sms sprüche ausländer sms sprüchesms sprüche bilder sms sprüche de sms sprüche derbe sms sprüche englisch bildmitteilungen sms sprüche englische sms sprüche fertig bildmitteilungen sms sms sprüche flirtx sms sprüche freundschaft sms sprüche gedicht sms sprüche gleich versenden kostenlos sms sprüche gratis lustige sprüche gute nacht sms sprüche sms sprüche guten morgen sms sprüche jokes neues sms sprüche knuddelbär sms sprüche kostenlos bildmitteilungen siemens sms sprüche liebe partner sms sprüche liebes sms sms sprüche liebessprüche geburtstag sms sprüche bildmitteilungen fürs handy sms sprüche lustig humor sms sprüche männer sprüche geburtstag bildmitteilungen gratis sms sprüche muttertag sms sprüche nette liebessprüche sms sprüche osterhase sms sprüche scheiss mücke sms sprüche sehnsucht sms sprüche sms bilder sms sprüche sprüche sms sprüche tatoos sms sprüche valentinstag sms sprüche versand sms sprüche versenden sms texte neujahr sms-sprüche bildmitteilungen nokia sms sms and sprüche sms liebe spruch sms liebe sprüche sms sprüche liebe sms und spruch sms verschicken spruch bildmitteilungen handy sprüche sms traurige sms sprüche türkische sms sprüche bildmitteilungen kostenlos liebessprüche + liebes sms sprüche + liebes sms Logos Klingeltöne SMS Sprüche Bildmitteilungen Handylogos MMS Bilder + Polyphone Klingeltöne Cliparts Geburtstag Cliparts Geburt Cliparts HochzeitCliparts Weihnachten free cliparts musik + musikcharts + musik download + musik downloads + musik downloaden + musik herunterladen führerscheinprüfung handyspiele liebesgedichte handy spiele klingeltoene polyphone klingeltoene kostenlose klingeltoene handy klingeltoene klingeltoene kostenlos polyphone klingeltoene gratis klingeltoene klingeltoene siemens sms sms senden sms versenden free sms sms bilder nokia logos siemens logos sms verschicken sms versand gratis sms sms kostenlos sms sprüche handylogos siemens sms sprüche liebe liebes sms mms bilder free mms mms sms ohne anmeldung spiele download pc spiele bußgeldkatalog klingeltoene nokia free sms ohne anmeldung sms ohne anmeldung free games siemens klingeltoene klingeltoene handy nokia klingeltoene klingeltoene gratis klingeltoene de free klingeltoene klingeltoene download klingeltoene umsonst klingeltoene zum abtippen klingeltoene für siemens logos klingeltoene klingeltoene logos sms + free sms + handylogos + klingeltöne logos und klingeltoene kostenlos klingeltoene klingeltoene und logos www klingeltoene de logos logos handy logos nokia logos siemens logos kostenlose handylogos gratis handylogos handy logos gratis logos siemens logos nokia logos handylogos kostenlos siemens logos cliparts free cliparts cliparts download bildmitteilungen sms sprüche klingeltöne klingeltoene für nokia klingeltoene per sms klingeltoene zum abschreiben klingeltoene fuer siemens klingeltoene motorola spiele downloads online games pc games free games games download flash games download games games free kostenlose games kostenlose online games kostenlose pc games kostenlose javagames kostenlose games zum downloaden kostenlose erotik games kostenlose games download kostenlose spiele spiele kostenlos kostenlos pc games games download kostenlose computerspiele spiele online spiele pc spiele spiele download gratis spielespiele zum downloaden download spiele spiele kostenlos klingeltoene samsung klingeltoene free s55 klingeltoene motorola klingeltoene samsung klingeltoene midi klingeltoene klingeltoene s55 klingeltoene fuer nokia klingeltoene zum eintippen klingeltoene zum selbermachen s45 klingeltoene klingeltoene ericsson klingeltoene midi klingeltoene selber machen freie klingeltoene klingeltoene alcatel klingeltoene fürs handy alcatel klingeltoene handy klingeltoene kostenlos klingeltoene s45 klingeltoene selbermachen sagem klingeltoene download klingeltoene klingeltoene zum selber machen klingeltoene polyphone klingeltoene kostenlose klingeltoene Klausuren Mathe Referate Deutsch Referate Physik Referate Englisch Referate handy klingeltoene liebesgedichte Cliparts Weihnachten Handytöne klingeltoene kostenlos polyphone klingeltoene gratis klingeltoene klingeltoene siemens klingeltoene nokia siemens klingeltoene klingeltoene handy nokia klingeltoene klingeltoene gratis klingeltoene de free klingeltoene klingeltoene download klingeltoene umsonst klingeltoene zum abtippen klingeltoene für siemens logos klingeltoene klingeltoene logos logos und klingeltoene kostenlos klingeltoene klingeltoene und logos www klingeltoene de klingeltoene für nokia klingeltoene per sms klingeltoene zum abschreiben klingeltoene fuer siemens klingeltoene motorola klingeltoene samsung klingeltoene free s55 klingeltoene motorola klingeltoene samsung klingeltoene midi klingeltoene klingeltoene s55 klingeltoene fuer nokia klingeltoene zum eintippen klingeltoene zum selbermachen s45 klingeltoene klingeltoene ericsson klingeltoene midi klingeltoene selber machen freie klingeltoene klingeltoene alcatel klingeltoene fürs handy alcatel klingeltoene handy klingeltoene kostenlos klingeltoene s45 klingeltoene selbermachen sagem klingeltoene download klingeltoene klingeltoene zum selber machen sprüche sprüche sprüche sprüche hochzeit hochzeit geburtstag ostern weihnachten geschenk nackte stars nacktbilder britney spears nackt tattoos tribal tattoos tattoos vorlagen henna tattoos tattoos motive tattoos motive tattoos motive tattoo tattoo vorlagen tattoo chinesische tattoos tattoos tattoo tattoos bilder tattoo vorlagen tattoos motive henna tattoos tribal tattoos tattoos vorlagen zaubern zaubern lernen zaubertricks zauber tricks sms sprueche + sprueche + sms zaubertricks covers + cd covers + dvd covers + audio covers + vcd covers covers + cd covers + dvd covers + audio covers + vcd covers MP3 download + Mp3 downloads + Mp3 downloaden MP3 download + Mp3 downloads + Mp3 downloaden MP3 download + Mp3 downloads + Mp3 downloaden songtexte + lyrics videos + lustige videos + funny videos musik-charts + musik download + musik downloaden musik-charts + musik download + musik downloaden musik-charts + musik download + musik downloaden

Posted by dvd cover at January 26, 2004 12:55 PM
Post a comment