Date: 15 April 2000 Summary: Brilliant in every respect
I don't think there are enough superlatives in the English language to
adequately describe this film. It succeeds in every possible way. This is
not only one of the best war movies ever, but among the very best films
period. The story is based on a true story of a German Submarine and its
crew during WWII. The plot is simple. A bunch of ordinary young guys are
crammed into a little tin can and go out and do their duty while trying to
avoid getting killed. This slice of life film gives a chillingly detailed
look at the rigors of war in a U-boat.
We are treated to the stark reality of submarine warfare; the hours of
boredom; the camaraderie and simultaneous aggravation that comes with living
in such close quarters, the exultation of victory when a torpedo hits, the
stark terror of the sound of a destroyer's propeller just above or the
insane fear of the boat being crushed by the water pressure as you go too
deep.
This film is unique in that it is done from the German perspective. Most
films about WWII are from the Allied perspective since they were produced in
Hollywood or England. What is striking about this film is how it depicts
war as a human event rather than a nationalistic conflict. It makes us
realize that for the foot soldier and sailor on the battle lines, no matter
what side, war is the same. It is more a matter of survival than
glory.
Director Wolfgang Peterson did a brilliant job on this film. The set and
props were authentic in minute detail and the work in tight quarters was
truly remarkable. You get a real sense of the cramped quarters and how
nimble the men had to be scrambling from compartment to compartment.
Peterson spares us none of the unpleasantness of submarine life. The stark
reality of it is startling.
By far Peterson's greatest accomplishment is the spine tingling suspense.
The effect is so terrifying you feel like you are part of the crew. His use
of angles, lighting, actor's reactions and most especially sound makes this
film far more frightening and suspenseful than anything the horror genre has
ever produced. I viewed this on DVD (Director's Cut) and the sound was
probably the best I've ever experienced. You hear water dripping behind
you, bolts explode and go screaming diagonally across the room to clank on
the other side, the sound of the destroyer's propeller escalates from a fly
buzz to a roar as the ping from the sonar gets ever louder. You find every
muscle in your body tensing as you hear them drop the depth
charges.
The ending is superb. It is triumphant, poignant and ironic; unexpected and
yet not surprising. It is neither what the viewer is apt to want nor
expect, and yet it is not disappointing.
I can't think of any negative criticism I would give this film. It was
nominated for six Academy Awards and won none. That speaks volumes about
the dubious nature of the Academy. Even if you don't normally enjoy war
movies, you should see this film. It is ultra excellent drama,
entertainment and filmmaking. A perfect 10.