Heretical Ideas
We challenge the orthodoxy--so you don't have to.
|
|
June 06, 2004
D-DAY
Today is the 60th Anniversery of D-Day. I doubt I can say anything to add to the multitude of voices expressing gratitude for the soldiers in Normandy that fateful day when the liberation of Europe from Nazi oppression began. However, one of my favorite aspects of D-Day was the brilliantly audacious Operation Fortitude in which the Allies convinced the German High Command that the Normandy invasion was just a feint. It is probably the greatest work of deception ever committed in warfare and it made the difference in the success of the Normandy invasion. Without the hard work of the spies, generals, and soldiers in this operation, D-Day may well have been remembered as the day the Allies lost their gambit to win World War II. My hats off to them, as well.
QUOTE OF THE DAY
"Ronald Reagan's love of country was infectious. Even when he was breaking Democrats' hearts, he did so with a smile and in the spirit of honest and open debate."
June 04, 2004
THOUGHTS ON THE SAT
Gail Heriot has some good comments on the popular sport of "SAT-bashing" that is well worth the read. One good point she makes is this: Moreover, insofar as the children of successful parents do score more highly, the test is measuring something real and not something that will disappear if the SAT is abolished. Such students, on the whole, don't just tend to get better scores, they tend to do better in college too. Ignoring SAT scores just because the children of high-achievers tend to do well would be like ignoring height in basketball players just because the children of tall people tend to be tall.More to the point, a lot of the SAT bashers tend to ignore the purpose of the SAT: it is a predicitve evaluator of how likely a student is to perform in college. And all of the empirical studies have read suggest that the SAT is, in fact, a pretty good predictor of how well a student will do in college. But facts are harsh, cruel things, and I'd never expect an education theorist to actually consider them...
GOOD NEWS FROM SAUDI ARABIA
This is great news. The Saudi government yesterday outlined plans to dismantle all international charity organizations operating in the kingdom and place their holdings under a new commission in what officials said is an effort to stop the flow of funds to terrorist groups.This is a great big blow to al-Qaeda and similarly minded Islamist groups. As Stephen Green points out: As all us chickenhawks have known for a couple years at least, international Saudi "charitable" groups have long been a source of terrordollars. If the Saudis are serious about cracking down on those organizations (which remains to be seen), then that's a victory on par with Libya's decision late last year to dismantle its WMD programs.No arguments from me. There are no doubt a number of reasons why the Saudis are changing their tune on this, but I would suggest three primary reasons: 1) The recent terrorist attacks in Saudi Arabia have changed the House of Sauds minds on the wisdom of funding terrorists. After all, if they're attacking their financers, what's the point of protecting them or financing them? 2) Iraq and the withdrawal of US troops for Saudi Arabia have taught the House of Saud two lessons: 1) that the US keeps its word in the sense that we said we'd move out the troops, and we did. 2) that the US keeps its word in the sense that we said if Saddam wouldn't comply with UN resolutions, we'd attack. And we did. 3) The House of Saud's desire to join the WTO. Saudi Arabia is about 95% of the way there of being granted full membership in the WTO. The only thing keeping them out is us. I've no doubt that the Saudis hope that this step will help convince the US that WTO membership for Saudi Arabia is a good idea.
ON THE NEW IRAQI PRESIDENT
Zeyad, the indispensible Iraqi blogger, has a great post on Iraq's new President, the new Cabinet, and his hopes for the future. He concludes his post by saying: So, perhaps I'm a bit optimistic today? Maybe. But Iraqis need to be optimistic at such a critical moment. There is no use in shrugging your shoulders and saying "I don't care.." anymore. You will be left behind along with the dark forces that insist on killing more Iraqis and disrupting the new changes. I'm confident that the Arab world is now watching Iraq with eyes wide open (or wide shut). Some Iraqis are saying the new government will be just a copy of the GC. It depends. Another problem is that I can already feel that the majority of Iraqis are expecting miracles from this new and young government. Unrealistic expectations tend to create endless problems and frustrations. Just like when the GC was formed, or when the Americans first entered Baghdad and people expected that their decades long problems would be fixed in a week.I hope that the Iraqi people and their new government are going to work to solve the country's problems. They can't, by their very nature, be solved by Americans. As time goes on, only the Iraqis themselves are going to make things better.
QUOTE OF THE DAY
We know John Kerry is a decorated Vietnam war hero, chiefly because he has the annoying habit of reminding us of it every chance he gets. We know he came home and spoke out against the war and maybe or maybe not threw his medals or ribbons or whatever over the White House fence. We know some of his compatriots thought he was a good guy and some thought he was a phony, and, and, and -- all of it ancient history. But after that -- what? In his nearly two decades as a United States Senator, John Kerry has not stood out as a leader on any key issue."
June 03, 2004
PROFILED IN MOTHER JONES--AND NATIONAL REVIEW
Andrew Leigh has a nice little profile of Roger Simon, who is easily one of the best bloggers, period. Anything that boosts Roger's standing in the world is good, in my opinion. I'm currently slogging my way through all of the Moses Wine novels, and I'd highly recommend that you do, too.
TENET RESIGNS
Looks like George Tenet has finally resigned. That's certainly good news. The bad news is that he wasn't fired 3 years ago. But I'll take what I can get.
WHO TO VOTE AGAINST?
This Onion article is pretty much the dead-on truth. WASHINGTON, DC—According to Gallup Poll results released Monday, 6 percent of Americans are still undecided about whether to vote against President Bush or Democratic challenger John Kerry in November's presidential election.I sympathize. I'm not 100 percent certain who I want to vote against, either.
WHY THE PADILLA "EVIDENCE" IS USELESS
Dahlia Lithwick has a must-read article on the "evidence" obatained regarding Jose Padilla. In his comments accompanying the release of the Padilla document, Deputy Assistant Attorney General James Comey offered the following weird little tribute to the joys of suspending the Constitution at will: Had the government charged Padilla criminally, he said, "He would very likely have followed his lawyer's advice and said nothing, which would have been his constitutional right. ... He would likely have ended up a free man." Comey's point seems to be that constitutional protections produce bad evidence, in which case we should probably get rid of the Constitution in every criminal case. What he was really saying was that if you permit them to perform unconstitutional interrogations, the administration can get the accused to say exactly what we all wanted to hear.Evidence obtained by confession has an extremely poor track record, even in cases where there was a lot less coercion than there was against Padilla. As Lithwick rightly notes, we'll probably never know the truth about Padilla, and that's largely because of the Administration's neglect of his civil rights.
SMART, ACTUALLY...
I've no doubt that some people are going to make this out to be more than it is. President Bush has consulted an outside lawyer in case he needs to retain him in the grand jury investigation of who leaked the name of a covert CIA operative last year, the White House said Wednesday.This is the logical, reasonable course of action for anyone who might face legal trouble. Talking to a lawyer about something is hardly evidence of criminality.
IS SUPERMAN RELEVANT?
There's a really good discussion going on in Cinescape's Comicscape column as to whether or not Superman is still relevant as an icon in modern times. Personally, I think he is. To me, Superman stands for an ideal--that even with extraordinary power, it's possible to act with duty, morality, and responsibility. One thing that is certainly true, however, is that Superman comics are frequently bad. To be sure, there are exceptions to this. Notably, Mark Waid in Kingdom Come, Jeph Loeb's Superman for All Seasons, Paul Dini's Superman: Peace on Earth and every time Alan Moore's ever written him. But overall, they're pretty mediocre at best. If the writers really want to make Superman worth reading again, they ought to take a cue from the writer's of Smallville (which is, by the way, the best currently running show on television). As one commentator in the column puts it: I think that the WB has done a great job in re-defining the character of Superman. SMALLVILLE shows that Clark Kent thinks and wants to act like the rest of us, but he knows that his abilities give him a greater responsibility to restrain himself. A healthy upbringing with loving parents has taught him a sense of fair play and using his abilities for revenge or out of anger goes against the morals he was taught. Seeing this portrayed on the screen really gives you a feel for how difficult it actually would be to be Superman. Superman is the ideal of what we hope and wish to be. He is a dream of morality and decency, but in SMALLVILLE he becomes more real to us because of the talented writers, actors, and directors of the show. I think that this could be translated to the comics with a little thought. We need to see what Kal-El is thinking to truly appreciate what he goes through on a day to day basis.In my mind, Superman is best treated on a mythic level, and his stories should reflect that. That doesn't mean that he is a character that we can relate to, but rather that his legend should resonate with us and reflect the deeper asperations of our culture. Click here to the rest of this post...
WE SHOULD DEAL WITH BIOTERRORISM. REALLY.
John Kerry had some good things to say about bioterrorism. Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry said Wednesday that in spite of deadly anthrax attacks and warnings of further biological assaults on the United States, significant gaps remain in the nation's preparations for bioterrorism.As usual, however, Kerry can talk the talk, but he can't walk the walk. It seems that when the Bush Administration developed a plan along the lines of what Kerry suggested, every member of the Senate voted for it. Every member, that is, except John Kerry. (link via Vodkapundit)
QUOTE OF THE DAY
"Folks, it's the first mark of fanaticism when you assume all your opponents are either stupid or immoral."
June 02, 2004
MORE ON IRAQ AND AL-QAEDA
Andrew McCarthy has some solid collections of evidence regarding meetings between al-Qaeda members and the 9/11 hijackers with Iraqi officials. There's some interesting reporting linked here, and I'd suggest you check it out.
QUOTE OF THE DAY
"The Olympic committee is telling American athletes not to wave the American flag at this years Olympics because it might be seen as boasting. Other countries can wave their flags, just not us. Which is ironic because without us a lot of these countries would be waving a flag different from what they are now." |
The Weblog Heretical Essays Heretical Ideas Store Syndicate this site (XML) Email the Heretics:
Pauly: paulymuller -at- hotmail.com Addressing Terrorism Art Blog Stuff Books Breaking News Business Comic Books Domestic Politics Education Foreign News Foreign Policy Foreign Politics History Humor! I love it! Iraq Reconstruction Iraq and Terrorism Jurisprudence Just Thinking Media Navel-Gazing Military Misc. Movies Music Pop Culture Quotes of the Day Religion Required Reading Science! Sports TV That's just bloody weird... The Final Frontier Video Games Warblogging Monthly Archives: June 2004 May 2004 April 2004 March 2004 February 2004 January 2004 December 2003 November 2003 October 2003 September 2003 August 2003 July 2003 June 2003 May 2003 April 2003 March 2003 Donations: Blogroll: * - recently updated Straight News: Drudge Report The Washington Post Yahoo! Daily News Google News The New York Times The Boston Globe The Onion Christian Science Monitor Chicago Sun-Times L.A. Times Commentary: The New Republic National Review Reason Enter Stage Right Tech Central Station Opinion Journal Slate Liberty Related Sites: Free-Market.net Consumer Freedom.com The Anti-Slavery Portal Bureaucrash Libertarian Party Top 25 Libertarian Sites Movies, Comics and Other Entertainment: Cinescape Online Liberty's Lungs at the Movies The Fourth Rail Comic Book Resources The Flick Filosopher Internet Movie Database
Visitors:
Powered by Movable Type 2.63 All material on this website is copyright (c) 2001-2003 by Alex Knapp unless otherwise indicated. |