Welcome to this personal website. It is intended to keep my students at the University of Canterbury posted with readings relevant to their courses. I’ll also be developing links to my own published scholarly writing and journalism.

Happy reading.

Recent Highlights

Time magazine in its issue of 14 June 2004 (U.S. edition) has an article on weblogs that includes a flattering remark or two. I have never viewed Arts & Letters Daily as a weblog, in that it does not present a running commentary. The progenitor of the modern weblog, by the way, is not the personal diary, but the nineteeth-century commonplace book, a scrapbook of newspaper cuttings, favorite poems, and creative prose. ALD is just a daily reading list with attitude.

At any rate, this mention does prove that Time has circulation grunt: thousands of new readers have come to Arts & Letters Daily off the website alone. Many more will come on account of the paper edition, which has a print run of about four million copies.


Human Accomplishment, by Charles Murray, was the subject of a long review in the New Criterion. Murray’s book is a splendid achievement, so full of facts and hypotheses that critics have had a field day poking holes in it. While I poke a few, there is much to admire in this provocative work.


My pan of the absurdly overrated Lord of the Rings films has been published in the Press, the New Zealand Herald, the Sunday Los Angeles Times, and the Australian. Here is the complete version from which these different edits derive.


The importance of maintaining equality before the law is the topic of this recent column in the Press and the New Zealand Herald.


The Washington Post also ran this review of Jenifer Michael Hecht’s Doubt: A History.


You may have seen this photo in a black and white version:

It used to appear in blow-up form in the Margaret Mead Hall at the American Museum of Natural History in New York. It was also reproduced in an abysmal book called Gone Primitive: Savage Intellects, Modern Lives, by Marianna Torgovnick. Thanks to help from friends at the Museum of Natural History and across Central Park at the Metropolitan Museum, I am able to present the original color version of the photo. For an updated account of the controversy surrounding it, click here.


Courses

Philosophy 227 / Art Theory 203

I’m going to be missing (off to the International Aesthetics Congress in Rio de Janiero) for the first two weeks of the semester. Grant Tavinor, philosophy lecturer at Lincoln University, has kindly consented to fill in for me. The classes will meet at the regular times, and reading assignments will be made (out of the assigned text) by Dr. Tavinor, assisted by the tutor for the class, Mark Roberts, newly arrived from Northwestern University in Illinois.


Philosophy 140 / Art Theory 101.

In order to give you more time to think about Kant and consider what Richard Bullen will say in his lectures, I’m extending the due date for the essay by two weeks, to Friday July 30th. The topic and instructions can be accessed by clicking here.

I’ve corrected the wrong URLs below. Much appreciate the spirited input from all sides in the class on Wednesday. Very interesting ideas from those who spoke up.

Writing in the New Yorker, David Denby has moderate praise for the new Troy. The Guardian has some interesting (and rather negative) coverage of Troy, including an amusing quiz. The New York Times has now run a second review, one worth considering. The Washington Post review, on the other hand, seems almost childish in its pose of cool sophistication.

Here is one that says it is a cartoonish joke of a film. Roger Ebert urges Homer’s estate to sue the producers. The Australian has this backgrounder from the Times of London. Robert McCrum has done a nice piece on Homer for the Observer, while The Age delivers a stinging pan of the film.

Here are a couple more reviews: Troy is “a clunky bit of storytelling that rarely rises to its source material.” Touched by glory and grandeur, Troy is a good film.”

Here is a very spirited defence of the film. And from an academic, a checklist of what is right, what wrong in the films translation of the Iliad.

Here is yet another backgrounder.

One of the best sources Ive come across are new articles on the real history of Troy at the website for Archaeology magazine. Check it out here.

Prof. John Zuern of the University of Hawaii has developed a superb web guide to the Poetics. It is very much worth studying.

 


 

 
Contact Denis Dutton