www.victorhanson.com

This Week in Private Papers

Front Page
Faux Populism
by Victor Davis Hanson


Allies, Friends, Neutrals, or Enemies?
by Victor Davis Hanson

Ayatollah of Anti-Americanism
by Bruce Thornton

Civilization vs. Trivia
by Victor Davis Hanson

Another 9/11?
by Victor Davis Hanson

Politics
Reagan, the Legacy
by Victor Davis Hanson

Culture
Gibson's "Passion"
by Honora Howell Chapman

Troy's Literary Offenses
by Bruce Thornton

Power to do Good
Book review
by Victor Davis Hanson

Wars New and Old
Book review
by Victor Davis Hanson

"The ancient Greeks: Were they like us at all?"
by Victor Davis Hanson

Education
This page is under construction

Collection of Curiosities
Homepage

Thucydides

Napoleon

Wellington

Patton




July 14, 2004
Faux Populism
By Victor Davis Hanson
Private Papers

It is going to be hard to convince the American people that two East Coast, liberal lawyers, one Senator married to a billionaire, the other worth $75 million, are men of the people. No wonder they and their supporters have introduced some very strange arguments.

The first is that John Edwards really has not embraced the privileged life of a multimillionaire who got rich suing obstetricians because he was born poor. But there are two problems with this. First, being the son of a postal employee and a mill worker doesn't necessarily make one impoverished in America. Some of my best friends are postal hourly-wage employees—including my wife and daughter.

July 10, 2004
Allies, Friends, Neutrals, or Enemies?
By Victor Davis Hanson
Private Papers

For all the mayhem in the Sunni Triangle, and for all our mishaps at trying to reconstruct a pathological society reeling from 30 years of mass murder, we are beginning now to see the emergence of new civilized beginning in Iraq. Sadly our allies are mostly neutral, if not hostile to this radically new world, mostly out of spite, narrow self-interest, and deductive anger and envy of the United States. In the process, they have done the near impossible: lost the good will of the American people, a development that will have radical repercussions in the years ahead.


July 10, 2004
The Ayatollah of Anti-Americanism
By Bruce Thornton
Private Papers

The Anti-Chomsky Reader, ed. by Peter Collier and David Horowitz (Encounter Books)

Of all the pseudo-religions corrupting our thinking--Freudianism, Marxism, Darwinism, to name a few--anti-Americanism is the most bizarre and dangerous. The facts of American life and American history simply do not support the widespread view that the United States, in the lunatic words of playwright Harold Pinter, is a "fully-fledged, award-winning, gold-plated monster" that "knows only one language--bombs and death." Such hatred usually is spawned by a diseased religious sensibility, an irrational passion for a narrative that bestows meaning on the world and one's exalted place in it as a champion of the revealed truth and righteousness. Yet the cult of anti-Americanism is worse than any dysfunctional religion, for it masquerades as reasoned analysis based on historical fact.

July 9, 2004
Civilization vs. Trivia
By Victor Davis Hanson
National Review Online

Last week, the carnivore Saddam Hussein faced the world in the docket. There was none of the usual Middle East barbarity. The mass murderer was not hooded and then beheaded on tape, in the manner of al Qaeda. Civilization has come to Iraq.

Nor was the destroyer of Iraqi dissidents hitched — Saudi-style — to a Humvee and dragged to pieces through the streets of Baghdad. The pillager of Kuwait did not lose a limb on the precepts of a sharia-inspired fatwa. A young Saddam-like Baathist assassin did not break in and shoot the desecrator of the Mesopotamian marshlands in the back of the head. And a West Bank-like mob did not lynch the torturer of dissidents in the public square. Even al Jazeera, an enthusiast of the usual barbarity, was wondering what the heck was going on in its own neck of the medieval woods.


July 6, 2004
Another 9/11?
The awful response we dare not speak about
By Victor Davis Hanson
National Review Online

Almost daily we are assured that another attack on the homeland, commensurate with 9/11, is inevitable. What a scary mood of fatalism we are in! Where will it happen? The Olympics? The party conventions this summer? A week before the election? Chicago? L.A.?

Our experts weighed in over the 4th of July weekend and seemed to disagree only over the method of the mass murder to come. Will it be chemical, biological, radiological, or involve hijacked planes, car bombs, or waves of suicide terrorists?

July 11, 2004

Response to Readership
(Updated daily)

What nationality were the Trojans and language did they speak?

Hanson: From archaeological and philological evidence, Trojans were probably some sort of early Semitic people and their language akin to Hittite; but as a creative device “they” of course speak Greek in the Iliad to communicate in those wonderful dialogues and recriminations before the opposing warriors square off >>>


Recent Works by Victor Davis Hanson

Review of Rural Greece under the Democracy, by Nicholas F. Jones, in Times Literary Supplement, June 25, 2004

"The ancient Greeks: Were they like us at all?" in The New Criterion, Vol. 22, No. 9, May 2004

"The Power to Do Good" : a review of Niall Ferguson's "Colossus" in the New York Post, April 25, 2004

Review of John Gaddis's Surprise, Security, and the American Experience

Introduction to the Modern Library's Plutarch's The Life of Alexander the Great


More works by Bruce Thornton

July 11, 2004
Response to Readership
Victor will post a response to readers' questions daily. If you have questions that Victor can answer, email them to author@victorhanson.com.

Current Affairs and Classics

What nationality were the Trojans and language did they speak?

Hanson: From archaeological and philological evidence, Trojans were probably some sort of early Semitic people and their language akin to Hittite; but as a creative device “they” of course speak Greek in the Iliad to communicate in those wonderful dialogues and recriminations before the opposing warriors square off. There is a large bibliography both on the “real” language of Troy and on Homer’s use of Greek to portray speaking Trojans.

What are your impressions of Mr. Knox and his collected work “The Oldest Dead White European Males”?

Hanson: Bernard Knox is one of the great classicists of our times. Most of our current ideas about Sophocles and his characters—especially the Ajax, Antigone, and Philoctetes—in some ways derive from his criticism. He is one of those now mostly lost who did almost everything—military experience, ran the Hellenic Center in Washington, professor, poet, translator, critic—and is emblematic of the age of serious classics before the wave of postmodernism washed all that away. There is now not one serious critic of the classics in any major university who could write and interpret as he did.


We will post events as information about them become available.
Click to view calendar
Reprinting permission click here