August 20, 2004

A Cheesy Lie

Awhile back, Kerry visited Philly and proved himself an incapable commander-in-chief and all around bad human being by ordering a cheesesteak with swiss cheese, a faux-pas of Hitlerian proportions. Never one to act like an adult, Bush traveled to Philly a few days ago and took a shot at Kerry, saying:

A lot of people wonder why I'm coming [to Pennsylvania] so much," Bush said. "It ought to be obvious to you; I like my cheese steak Whiz with."
It was picked up all over the liberal media, as CNN, the NY Times, Fox and others decided to devote space to the contender's condiment preferences.

The uh, funny thing, is that it isn't so:

Bush actually "prefers his steak absent of the usual Cheez Whiz and provolone, accompanied only by cheese of the American variety," information that she obtained from her own Deep Throat, one Caeser Barnabei, the owner of the well-known cheesesteak shop, Jim's Place. Barnabei, who has fed the Bush camp on previous swings through Pennsylvania and provided "70 to 80 hoagies" for the Bush campaign yesterday, confided to Carey that "the Jim's Special is altered to whet the 'W' appetite."

In Philadelphia, the classic cheesesteak recipe is hot beef strips and fried onions dripping with grease, slathered with Cheez Whiz straight from the squeeze bottle, all atop white bread. Solemnly, Carey reported her devastating conclusion: "The commander-in-chief fooled thousands Tuesday to believe he eats like the epicureans here."

Matt sums it up perfectly:
It's hardly the most consequential of presidential deceptions, but it serves nicely as a metaphor for a White House with zero concern about the truth, obsessed with politicizing everything in sight, and dependent for public support on an essentially fraudulent presentation of an Andover-education trust fund baby as representative of the heart and soul of working-class America.

Posted by Ezra Klein at August 20, 2004 11:03 AM | TrackBack
Comments

This was also exactly the sort of stupid-ass fib about inconsequential shit that somehow resulted in Gore being portrayed as a pathological liar in 2000.

Posted by: Haggai at August 20, 2004 11:10 AM

I didn't think anyone past the age of five still ate cheez-whiz.

Anyways, this whole story is just fucking ridiculous. Most people who didn't grow up in Pennsylvania or the immediate Northeast wouldn't know what the classic cheesesteak is. It's such a stupid measure of how "with the common people" someone is. I guarantee half the people from rural Kansas wouldn't know exactly what's on a classic cheesesteak either.

Until a cheesesteak is the actual president, I fail to see the relevance.

Posted by: Kate at August 20, 2004 11:12 AM

Man, I wish people would quit flogging this story. I had planned to have a healthy lunch. Now I'm craving an artery-plug of a cheesesteak.

Posted by: covington at August 20, 2004 11:18 AM

"It ought to be obvious to you; I like my cheese steak Whiz with."

Is that a typo or more dumbfuckery from the C-in-C?

Posted by: Gozer at August 20, 2004 11:25 AM

Gozer, I was wondering that too, but click on the link to Matt Yglesias' post at TAPPED for an explanation. It's some sort of special cheese-steak code.

Posted by: Haggai at August 20, 2004 11:27 AM

Gozer, that's actually a PA regionalism.

Example:
"I'm going to the store?"
"Really? Mind if I come with?"

Posted by: Anonymouse at August 20, 2004 11:31 AM

By that measure, they would say "Mind if I come you with?"

Posted by: GB at August 20, 2004 11:35 AM

What if it was Cambodian cheese? Then I don't know what to think. Somebody tell me!!

Posted by: Grumpy at August 20, 2004 11:37 AM

It's the shorthand for ordering cheesesteaks at Pat's. 'With' = with fried onions. If you want peppers, you say that before the cheese and onions, so a cheesesteak with cheese whiz, peppers and onions would be a 'pepper wiz with'. The whole thing is pure dumbfuckery and a lie on top of that, but the language is accurate.

The guys at Pat's have a reputation for kicking people out of line for ordering improperly, but they rarely do that. If you stand in line for 15 minutes on a Saturday night and then walk up and say something like 'Do you have cheese whiz', you will be asked to step aside.

Posted by: Buckethead at August 20, 2004 11:39 AM

I'm a Philadelphian.

"Whiz Wit" (note, no terminal "h") means you want your steak with Cheez Whiz AND fried onions. At the touristy cheesesteakeries (Pat's & Geno's & Jim's), you will be ridiculed unless you use this system of ordering. You say the kind of cheese you want first, then it's either wit or witout onions. Cheez Whiz on a cheesesteak isn't as bad as it sounds, but most people I know seem to prefer provolone (which, along with American, is a standard option) and sometimes mushrooms or peppers.

The President is a douche.

Posted by: gabe at August 20, 2004 11:47 AM

I don't know which is worse. The fact that Bush felt the need to drag this idiotic attack on Kerry back up or the fact that he had to lie to do it.

Posted by: Gordon at August 20, 2004 11:56 AM

I was gonna say. 'Cause out here in the Midwest, provolone or American seems to be the primary stuff you get on a cheesesteak--never cheese whiz. That's nothing against the people of Philly--after all, they patented the thing--it's just to say that if I flew in, there's a good chance I'd order my cheesesteak with provolone--and while I am sorta French (my mom's maiden name was Parriott, but we were from Alsace-Lorraine! Which used to be German! I swear to God, I ain't no Frenchie!), I never went to prep school.

Posted by: Jeff Fecke at August 20, 2004 12:39 PM

Embrace your Frenchness, order that mofo with some Reblochon!

Posted by: Gozer at August 20, 2004 01:27 PM

Ordering a cheese steak with Reblochon is likely to get you a cheese steak with some sort of hand cream for psoriasis (or whatever ointment they put on grill burns).

Posted by: badger ellen at August 20, 2004 04:33 PM

As a Philadelphian who loves his cheesesteaks with Whiz, can I just say what a wad Bush is? Anyone this sways shouldn't be allowed to vote.

Posted by: banana slug at August 20, 2004 06:58 PM

I'd be proud to wiz on the C-in-C's filly. Then, I'd take a wiz on him too. If that's the way he likes it, I know a few web sites where he can get his rocks off.

Posted by: rick pietz at August 20, 2004 07:23 PM
Post a comment












Remember personal info?