Danish Imams Propose to End Cartoon Dispute
Update (7 February 2006): The Cartoon Hoax
The Danish imams, who protested the publication of 12 Muhammad cartoons [see them all below] in the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten last September, have announced that they want to end the dispute. For four months the imams and their radical Muslim organizations have unsuccesfully demanded government censorship. However, despite immense pressure (also from international organizations such as the UN and the EU) the Danish government refused to call the newspaper to account.
Last week a couple of Norwegian papers decided to publish the cartoons in support of the Danish paper while in Denmark moderate Muslims, encouraged by the governmentâs refusal to be intimidated by the radicals, have distanced themselves from the imams. The latter announced on Friday that they no longer demand apologies from Jyllands-Posten for the publication. Instead they said they just want two things: a guarantee from the Danish authorities that Muslims can freely practice their religion without being âprovoked and discriminated.â And a declaration from Jyllands-Posten that the cartoons were not published with the intention of mocking the Muslim faith. âWe want Jyllands-Posten to show respect for the Muslims. This can happen with an apology, but it can also happen in some other way. We will leave it to Jyllands-Posten to come up with some ideas,â said Ahmed Akkari, spokesman of the Muslim organizations. âWe want respect for Muhammad restored and we want him to be described as the man he really was in history, and that he gets the respect he deserves,â Akkari stressed that Muslim organizations are still deeply opposed to the publication of the cartoons.
The Muslim organizations and Jyllands-Posten met last week to discuss the matter. âIt was a good and constructive meeting. We agreed that we need to find a solution,â said Carsten Juste, editor of Jyllands-Posten. Juste stressed that the meeting was one step in a reconciliation process which the Muslim organizations and the newspaper began in December.
Some sceptics wonder whether the demands of the imams have changed fundamentally. They still insist that Jyllands-Posten admit that publishing the cartoons was wrong and make amends for it. The sceptics argue that the paper should not settle for a compromise on freedom of expression by justifying itself. Others wonder why the radical Muslims appear to be softening their demand and seem so eager to make a deal. Perhaps the decision of Norwegian papers such as Magazinet to support Jyllands-Posten by publishing the cartoons has made the radicals reconsider. Perhaps they fear a domino effect. Some Swedish papers are considering publishing the cartoons as well. If the Swedish government subsequently follows the position of the Danish and Norwegian governments, refusing to interfere and limit freedom of expression, the position of the radical Danish Muslims, who are looking for international support, will only weaken.
According to a poll taken this week among 1,047 people in Denmark 57% of the Danes support Jyllands-Postenâs decision to publish the cartoons, while 31% disagrees. Young people and men are more likely to support the decision. Almost two out of every three males and 61% of people aged between 18 and 25 years of age did so.
Meanwhile an international organization of Muslim intellectuals has threatened to mobilize âmillions of Muslims all over the Worldâ to boycott Danish and Norwegian products unless the Danish and Norwegian government condemn the publication of the cartoons, which is called an âattack on the Muslims of the World and on the Prophet.â In Saudi Arabia people are receiving e-mails and sms messages urging them to boycott Danish products âuntil Denmark offers an official apology.â The Organization of the Islamic Conference protested last weekâs publication of the cartoons in the Norwegian paper Magazinet. The Iranian embassy in Oslo said that freedom of expression cannot justify publishing the cartoons. However, Finn Jarle Sæle, the editor of the Norwegian Christian newspaper Norge I DAG, announced that his paper is also considering publishing the cartoons. He called upon other Norwegian editors to do the same. Sæle says that so far many of them have only written editorials supporting freedom of expression but have not dared to publish the cartoons themselves.
Asked if wider publication will not lead to unnecessary confrontations between Christians and Muslims Sæle said the intention was not to provoke just for the sake of provoking, but rather to confront radical Islam in Norway. Perhaps it is necessary to provoke in order to do that, he said. Sæle wants the Norwegian imams to publicly oppose the death threats that have been sent to Magazinetâs editor Vebjørn Selbekk. According to Sæle these threats are not just directed against Magazinet. They affect the entire Norwegian media, not just one editor who dared to stand up for freedom of expression.
More on the Danish cartoon case which The Brussels Journal has been covering from the beginning: See links at the end of this article
Trackback URL for this post:
SELF-CENSORSHIP....I happen to think Andrew Sullivan's crusade to browbeat American newspapers into printing those now-famous Danish cartoons is severely wrongheaded. Freedom of speech gives Jyllands-Posten the right to run the cartoons if they want to, b
"Moco Loco" has alerted us to some Breaking News! Apparently, DrawMohammad.com is off the air. You'll remember such great DrawMohammad hits as my drawing: And also Environmental Republican's drawing: If you have more information on exactly what has happen
Those cartoons. I've seen more offensive things, towards all sorts of races and religions. Certainly nothing to kill anyone over, or even punch someone over. Both sides are acting like asses to varying degrees but the difference is, only one
With all the fuss over the Danish cartoons, it occurred to me that readers of this blog might want to see them. And thanks to Right on the Left Coast, you can! Here's a web site which has all of...
With all the fuss over the Danish cartoons, it occurred to me that readers of this blog might want to see them. And thanks to Right on the Left Coast, you can! Here's a web site which has all of...
A New York Times article says "West Begining to See Wide Islamic Protests as Sign of Deep Gulf" (and it...
A few words about the Mohammed cartoons . . . While offensive, I don't think the caricatures of Mohammed are...
A New York Times article says "West Begining to See Wide Islamic Protests as Sign of Deep Gulf" (and it...
By Andrew L. Jaffee, netwmd.com Some of my leftist friends have one thing in common with the Muslims now sacking foreign embassies: a fundamental lack of understanding as to how democracy works, and how precious it is. The leftists have...
"Even Satire must stay within the limits of civilized and decent behaviour" - Maurizio Gasparri in his capacity as Minister for Communications[1] "There was nothing to laugh about. It wasn't all satire. In certain moments [...] it appeared like a...
Warning: if youâre offended by visual images of the Prophet, donât click to read more. Just back away slowly from the blog, and nobody gets hurt.
People have died now because of this mess. Have any of the rioters actually seen the cartoons? ...
I have to admit I've been puzzled by the whole Danish Cartoon ??? I don't even know what to call it. Controversy seems too mild a word when buildings are burning and people are dying. Debacle implies that the Danish...
Cartoons provoke strong feelings don't they. The imjages kinda get below the belt in a way that words do not; especially the more provocative ones that take strong stands on controversial issues. An example: Tom Toles The reaction The ferocious Muslim pro
Here they are. Towards the end of the post and before all of the comments are all of the cartoons that have the middle east up in arms. Probably the most up in arms people I've ever heard ...
Welcome to the Big Apple Blog Festival (BABF), a representative roundup of this week's posts by NYC bloggers. The Big Apple Blog Festival likes to go on tour ... if you don't like what we covered here, and if...
Do not expect the governments of America and Britain to defend our right to free speech against Muslim theocrats. The...
That cartoon issue simply will not go away. I do intend to write a more substantial piece on it but I can summarise my position fairly quickly: * The cartoons are generally pretty average. One or two are slightly amusing...
The Church (I'm not speaking of individual Catholics, just the church hierarchy, or at least its authoritative voices), still seems not to have accepted free expression about religion, or for that matter religious freedom. Here'...
We care about Europe for the same reason we care for the suicidal: because a chosen fate is not inherently a just one, and we are called to act when an unjust end threatens. And we care about Europe out of common interest: its enemy is ours.
I have written a couple of times before about the very useful cultural confrontation with intolerant Muslims that occurred when Danish newspaper Jyllands Posten published some less than flattering cartoons featuring the Prophet Mohammed. Well in case you
The great British philosopher John Stuart Mill wrote in On Liberty, "Strange it is, that men should admit the validity of the arguments for free discussion, but object to their being 'pushed to an extreme'; not seeing that unless the...
And Vienna is not spared. Five hundred Muslims went to the Wiener Ballhausplatz to protest for the "injustice" brought by the 12 Danish cartoons, asking the West to give respect to their religion. Well, I am thankful that they don't...
I was going to let this whole issue slip by, but a headline caught my attention as I was about to go to bed: Embassies in Syria Are Burned in Furor Over Prophet Cartoon. While this was not very surprising, considering the attack in Gaza days ago, it was n
The great British philosopher John Stuart Mill wrote in On Liberty, "Strange it is, that men should admit the validity of the arguments for free discussion, but object to their being 'pushed to an extreme'; not seeing that unless the...
The great British philosopher John Stuart Mill wrote in On Liberty, "Strange it is, that men should admit the validity of the arguments for free discussion, but object to their being 'pushed to an extreme'; not seeing that unless the...
I’m going to try to feed some more information and viewpoints on the cartoons of Mohammed situation. Please remember that I can’t verify everything, but I’m hoping to generate some more discussion as well as use different sources.
A ...
Muslims around the world are chanting “Death to Denmark” because a Danish newspaper published satirical cartoons of Mohammed. And in other news from the 16th fucking century, there are exciting career opportunities in Rome with the n...
Some might see this as an example of the power of cartoons. I flash on David Byrne singing "Burning Down...
The source...
Look, I understand that there are (Some) Muslims who are pissed that a Danish newspaper published drawings of somebody important to those (Some) Muslims. (In case you're wondering, here are the incredibly "offensive" drawings.) But responding in this way
Another day, another Muslim riot. So it seems. The Western
(Christian) world has been appeasing Islamic idiots for a long time
now. The vast majority of Muslims may be sensible, decent,
hard-working, law-abiding people. However, the mindset of some ...
The US State Department of the Bush Administration would prefer that the press not run material that is offensive to...
So much print and airtime has been wasted over a bunch of f***ing cartoons! And to think this has been boiling up for four months... :eyecrazy: Personally, I think the Islamic world perhaps needs to lighten up a little. They were only cartoon...
I haven't commented on those Muslim cartoons so far. I'm conflicted. Why, you might ask? It's a clear-cut case of religious insanity, exactly the sort of thing I ought to relish wagging an arrogantly atheistical finger at. And of course...
PRINTER-FRIENDLY FORMAT Protests by some - I emphasize some Muslims - against European newspapers for publishing caricatures of the prophet Muhammad continues unabated. The latest outrage is an attack on the Danish embassy in Syria, which was set on fire.
PRINTER-FRIENDLY FORMAT Protests by some - I emphasize some Muslims - against European newspapers for publishing caricatures of the prophet Muhammad continues unabated. The latest outrage is an attack on the Danish embassy in Syria, which was set on fire.
Every religion gets made fun of: how many comedy skits feature people dressed as nuns or priests? How about the Church Lady? Evangelical Christians get it a lot—and so do Jews. Not to mention what we do to New Agers....
[L]ast September [2005] a Danish newspaper published some satirical cartoons about Mohammed, which simply isnât done. Compared to the illos you find in the Arab press, which could be described as âThe Protocols of the Elders of Zion for Dummies,â...
[L]ast September [2005] a Danish newspaper published some satirical cartoons about Mohammed, which simply isnât done. Compared to the illos you find in the Arab press, which could be described as âThe Protocols of the Elders of Zion for Dummies,â...
Die dänische Zeitung „Jyllands-Posten” (JP) hat den von ihr in betriebenen [sic] „Kampf um die Meinungsfreiheit” durch Veröffentlichung von Mohammad-Karikaturen für verloren...
There hasn't been much coverage of this in the US media, but, this fight has been going on since last September. A series of 12 cartoons were published in a Danish newspaper, Jyllands-Posten, that portray prophet Mohammad and then followed...
There hasn't been much coverage of this in the US media, but, this fight has been going on since last September. A series of 12 cartoons were published in a Danish newspaper, Jyllands-Posten, that portray prophet Mohammad and then followed...
I've been asked by several people what I think of the "Danish Cartoons". So I'll tell you what I think: I think Americans are very slow to catch this story, and our press is not doing it justice. Bloggers are...
Interesting article in The Guardian:The battle is set, of religious extremism versus freedom of speech. These are the lines drawn, or so we are told, in the escalating tensions worldwide surrounding the airing of Jerry Springer: The Opera in Britain
Danish Imams Propose to End Cartoon Dispute | The Brussels Journal In case you were curious about just what the twelve cartoons depicting Mohammed that have the Arab world in a carefully orchestrated uproar were about, the Brussels Journal is...
Paul Belien: Will the twelve cartoons mark the beginning of the clash of civilizations?(Click here for background.) I hope not... but who knows? The Brussel's Journal is reporting on the day's developments. In France a newspaper editor has been fired...
Some cartoons in a Danish newspaper that showed Islam's founder Mohammed as a terrorist with a bomb in his turban...
Normally when a website or publication is under attack over some sort of controversial article or image, it is copied around the world. This is partly so people can see what the fuss is about, and also partly to support free speech and make people realise
BBC News is reporting that the Managing Editor of France Soir, the paper which has reprinted these cartoons, has been sacked. The front cover of...
Saloute,
Mahomet fait encore parler de lui, où plûtot ses descendants ! En effet, le magazine chrétien Danois Jyllands-Posten a lancé une planche, de 12 caricatures du prophète de l'Islam, visible sur ce site : http://www.brusselsjournal.co
Thanks to the Brussels Journal for publishing the cartoons. Helgoland today is Danish, too.
Some thin-skinned Muslims appear to be quite insecure about themselves. At least that's what is implied by their obsession with how other people view them and their religion. After denouncing Danish cartoons depicting the prophet Mohammed, many Muslims ar
Right on France Soir.I don't know how many of you have been following this story, but the short version is that a Danish paper dared to publish a cartoon satirizing Mohammed as a terrorist. The Muslim world erupted in riots. The Danes (these guys used
With all the fuss over the Danish cartoons, it occurred to me that readers of this blog might want to see them. And thanks to Right on the Left Coast, you can! Here's a web site which has all of...
Does anyone want some cheese or furniture while I'm out? How about a car? Or some beer? Candy? Or, you know—I could get you some sort of breakfast pastry. Laurence says we can stop now, but I happen to like...
The story of the satirical pictures of the Prophet Muhammed published by Jyllands-Posten just refuses to die away. I first posted an article about this on 12 November 2005, followed by another on 9 December 2005, indirectly on 10 December 2005 and finally
Looking for Comedy in the Muslim WorldWhile on every news bulletin and slightly politically coloured blogs, people are talking about Muslims and humour from one perspective, I noticed an ad for Looking for Comedy in the Muslim World on my favourite gossip
January has been an interesting month. In the UK The "hate-speech" trial of British National Party leaders Nick Griffin and Mark Collett is drawing to a close, with a decision expected tomorrow. Meanwhile, the UK's Commons is debating the Racial...
Images of the Prophet Mohammed printed recently in the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten continue to inflame the Muslim world: Some Muslims, who deem images of prophets...
Cartoon depictions of the prophet Muhammed , originally published September 30 in a Danish newspaper, remain a hot issue among Muslim clerics and political
Seems that a sense of humour is lacking in the Islamic world regarding the showing of cartoons of the phropet Mohammed in
More cartoon rage going on in Saudi - this time from a Saudi cleric
Brussel Journal has all the background info on the Danish "cartoon rage" issue.
Hat tip: Jihad Watch
RIYADH, Jan 28 (KUNA) -- Muslim World League (MWL) called Saturday on the UN Secretary General Kofi Annan to activate international laws against
Take Back the Culture. That is roughly what we're beginning to see in some parts of Europe recently. From France to Norway, citizens and
Here's the e-mail from the official
I am sorry that the publication of a few cartoons in a leading American newspaper has caused upset among Christians. I fully understand that these drawings are seen to give...
At the end of last week, it was starting to look like some sort of sanity might prevail in the Jyllands-Posten Muhammad cartoons controversy.
I go over to The Brussels Journal to read the news that for some reason or the other doesn't find it's way into Reuters or the BBC very
The Brussels Journal has another update on the Danish cartoon kerfuffle. Is this Europes loose equivalent of the Zenger trial? It seems to be setting a more powerful free speech precedent with every European government that refuses to act
La Unión Internacional de "Estudiosos" Musulmanes ha urgido a Noruega y a Dinamarca a parar los actos en ofensa del Islam (vía Ji ...
Radical Muslim groups are turning up the heat in the cartoon war by using mass e-mails and text messages to organise a
Recent comments
9 min 47 sec ago
17 min 55 sec ago
34 min 12 sec ago
54 min 19 sec ago
56 min 14 sec ago
59 min 24 sec ago
1 hour 20 min ago
1 hour 20 min ago
1 hour 27 min ago
1 hour 31 min ago