When I put up the Van Jones video from NN10 last night — you can open another window with that video — I expected many of the comments would express views ranging from disappointment to anger, and some surprise that Jones remains an ardent supporter of the President. But I was surprised that only one or two commenters picked up on Van Jones’ Titanic and Lord of the Rings metaphors.
Those metaphors reveal a great deal about the large split between patient but concerned loyalists and the disillusioned/disgusted and those beyond. They also help clarify the issue that has been misnamed the “Obama paradox,” something I don’t think is the slightest bit paradoxical, though I understand how the loyalists might see it differently. What do these metaphors tells us, not so much about Jones, but about all of us?
In his Titanic metaphor, Jones said something like this,
Remember, Obama volunteered to be the captain of the Titanic, after it hit the iceberg.
. . . and then he used that to express his own more sympathetic portrait of the President and the challenges he and the country face. So let’s take that where it might lead.
I’m fairly certain Van Jones does not believe the end of the real drama called American democracy is that the ship sinks and most aboard her are lost, save for a few rich people who steal the lifeboats. The real Titanic sank and thousands died. In the real and Hollywood versions, the ship was highly segregated between the wealthy class and steerage, the privileges of wealth were beyond counting, the deprivation below decks a different story. The people in charge were fools, the security people’s main job was to enforce the unfair distribution of wealth and privilege, those steering the ship were driven by greed and arrogance to take excessive risks but were asleep at the helm. . . .