Bashing victims allege police arrested them, let attackers go; city launches investigation
June 13th, 2007By Susan Jordan
An alleged gay bashing took place on Goodman St. at Monroe Ave. in the early hours of June 1, but when victims called police, they were the ones to be arrested, according to a June 6 item on Channel 8 News.
The Rochester Police Department has launched an internal investigation, and is seeking the alleged assailants. Jeff Briggs, president of Rochester Wealth Management, has offered a reward of $1,000 for information leading to the arrest of one or more attacker. Briggs said, “I can’t stand injustice and am willing to post a reward.”
A press conference was held on June 12 at City Hall. Mayor Bob Duffy announced that witnesses said two men and two women assaulted the eight victims (two of whom are U.S. Marines) between 2 and 3 a.m., making comments which clearly indicated that this was an anti-gay hate crime. “It was a vicious assault,” he said.
The FBI is also investigating the assault, as a hate crime. Duffy asked for help from the public. He added that the Police Department under Chief David Moore is seeking the assailants, and that internal affairs investigators will determine whether police response was inappropriate. No officers have been removed from regular patrol.
Three of the alleged victims have been charged with infractions including arguing with officers, and those charges still stand.
Duffy said, “Discrimination – whether based on race, religion or sexual orientation – will not be tolerated.” He asked that the public withhold judgment until all the facts are in. “This will not be swept under the carpet,” he said. “We have great communication with the gay community and don’t want to fracture that relationship… No one should question where we stand and what our tolerance level is. This is unacceptable.”
Duffy stated that police had identified independent witnesses and were interviewing them, and the police officers involved would be interviewed by the following week.
Several gay men and lesbians told Mike Malloy of Channel 8 News on June 6 that they were attacked by individuals who came from a porch or yard on Goodman St. The attackers allegedly shouted anti-gay slurs and used a metal rod as well as their fists and feet, hitting and kicking the victims, som of whom sought medical attention.
The victims called police, they said, only to be manhandled by certain officers, who arrested some of the victims themselves. The police officers refused to make a report on the assault and let the alleged attackers go free, according to victims interviewed by Channel 8 News reporter Mike Molloy.
One man said his toe was cut by a police officer’s knife, requiring three stitches, and he was slammed to the ground and then put into a police cruiser. One of the lesbian victims alleged that she had been repeatedly called a “drunken dyke” by a police officer.
At the June 12 press conference, Chief Moore said, “I am 100 percent committed to getting to the bottom of this situation. There is compelling evidence that a hate crime took place. We owe it to the community and to the officers to make sure we have diligent investigation. I want to make sure I do my part. I have put tremendous resources into the investigation.”
Twenty internal affairs investigators have been assigned to the case.
City Council President Lois Geiss and Council member Bill Pritchard have become involved. Bill Pritchard told the Empty Closet on June 7, “Lois Geiss and I were contacted by several of the victims and we spoke to both Mayor Duffy and Chief David Moore, and we remain in close contact with them. I have confidence that the Rochester Police Department’s investigation will uncover the facts. Obviously something went wrong, and the investigation will determine if there were inappropriate actions by police officers; if so, I believe appropriate steps will be taken.”
Pritchard said at the press conference that he has received many calls from gay constituents, expressing concern and fear. He said that the Mayor, the Chief and Officer Jim Hall are “the right people at the right time.”
Gay Alliance Executive Director Kris Hinesley said, “The City and the Gay Alliance are working together to address the incident and its impact on our community. We fully support the City’s efforts and in meeting with the mayor and his team were impressed by the full-out investigation they have launched. The incident is strengthening our partnership with the City.”
The Gay Alliance was represented at the June 12 press conference by Kris Hinesley, Board President Sue Cowell, Anti Violence Project Coordinator Alex Cobus, and Board member Tom Ferrarese.
Hinesley said that the Gay Alliance is very confident that the investigations will move promptly. She said, “We’re not here to pre-judge, but are here to be a watchdog for the gay community.” She said that the Gay Alliance is undertaking an investigation of its own.
There is a need for extra vigilence, for rapid reporting of problems to police and for a new level of education to be made available to police on dealing with hate crimes such as this one, she said.
Hinesley added that a rise in violence against lgbt people often takes place at times when gay rights, including marriage equality, are in the news, as was shown in Massachusetts during the marriage legalization process.
Alex Cobus said, “My role is working with the victims and witnesses. We (at the Gay Alliance Anti Violence Project) provide direct services. We look forward to continuing our work with the police department.” Cobus said that anyone with information or concerns about this or other hate crimes should call 911, contact Officer Hall, or call the AVP at 697-3373.