I will admit to being poisoned by the Viet Nam experience, where the whole thing started as a "training" exercise. Maybe Afghanistan isn't Southeast Asia but the slope is just as slippery from training to something more. But what nobody seemed to realize after the President's speech was the massive reality gap between Afghan history and reality, and our stated mission of surging our troop strength to buy time to train the Afghans.
Training isn't and never was the problem in Afghanistan. We are talking about a people that defeated the
Soviet Union without any formal training. Clearly, training isn't going make a huge difference to guys like that - they already know how to fight. The real issue is where people's loyalties lie. No amount of training is going to convince an Afghan to shoot his cousin. Similarly, if the Taliban is coming back, there is a limit to how far soldiers are going to go in rooting out people who are going to be their bosses at some point in the future.
Let's face it folks, the one point we know for
certain is that at some point we are going to leave Afghanistan. Maybe not this year, but you can bet the rent that in ten years we won't be there any more. Who will then be in charge? I would bet double rent it won't be the corrupt Karzai and his drug-running relatives. It might well be the Taliban or some faction thereof.
So lets focus on what our real national interests are in that country. I think there are only two:
1. Don't harbor terrorists
2. Don't produce heroin
It would be nice to create a modern open society with equal rights for all in Afghanistan. It would also be nice to do that in the USA. But it really isn't in our own national interest to invade and occupy every country that isn't as free and Democratic as our own. The only question I have isn't whether we should get out. It's when. As it happens, the Taliban, abhorrent though they may be, are also xenophobic. It should be possible to convince them not to harbor foreign terrorists. They did indeed harbor them in the past, partly because they were paid well for doing it, but the result was that they lost control of their country. Many of them are reported to think that the cost/benefit ratio of harboring al Qaeda is way too high. The Taliban have also been the only government ever to succeed in curbing the heroin trade. They may be awful for the more enlightened Afghan people, and for most of us, but if they are going to eventually replace our corrupt puppet, no matter what we do, it's time to start recognizing that the devil we know may still enable us to meet our core national interests.
Read More......