From David Frum:
President Obama has placed big bets on the board: the $787 billion stimulus plan to generate employment, the Afghan surge to fight the Taliban, a bailout fund to cushion the financial crisis, diplomacy to stop the Iranian bomb. These are actions of historic scale; if they fail no spin doctor can explain them away.
But thus far, they are failing. And, especially with domestic policies, there is little reason to believe that will change.
Anti-Bush feeling among Democrats pushed the party to the left over the past eight years. Then the economic crisis created a seeming opportunity for a Franklin Roosevelt-style 100 Days. President Obama’s own rhetoric of hope and change overcame all inhibitions, and the administration committed itself to fighting the recession with pork-barrel spending and one-time tax rebates; stricter regulation of finance, health care and energy producers and users; and imminent increases in the tax burden on work, saving and investment. It has not worked.
What this president needs is not new messaging. It is new thinking.
Now wait a minute. The stimulus worked. CBO proved that, to the tune of millions of jobs saved and created. The problem is that the stimulus wasn't big enough to FULLY work, and that is the fault of the President, who refused to push for the larger stimulus he knew we needed, and the Republicans, who refused to endorse ANY stimulus. But to suggest that the stimulus didn't work - as in, it was a bad idea to do a stimulus - is simply wrong.
Then there's the bailout for the financial crisis. First off, it was Bush's bailout, thank you. Second, as even
David Obey admitted, it worked.
Third, I'm not going to defend the one-time tax rebate - and, let's not forget, that was a Republican idea that Obama, God knows why, accepted. It was a dumb idea, and didn't work, but hey, the Republicans came up with it.
Then there's health care reform. It didn't work? It hasn't even started yet. Suggesting that health care reform didn't work only months after the legislation was passed is disingenuous. I'm as big a critic as anyone about the President's unwillingness to push for the health care reform he promised. But you can't criticize legislation that hasn't even been implemented yet.
Contrary to what Frum says, the President doesn't need new policies, he needs better messaging and MORE of the policies he's already adopted. Either the President didn't do enough of the policies he wanted - health care reform and stimulus - and/or he didn't do a good enough job defending those policies, and messaging on those policies. The problem, in few situations that I can find, at least on domestic policy, is not the WRONG policy (well, okay, there was that offshore drilling idea, and the decision not to prosecute torture, and the reversal on the Patriot Act...). Rather, the problem is usually that the President opts for policy-lite and then refuses to adequately defend his choice.
Obama needs to reinvent himself, to be sure. But he doesn't need to become a Republican. He needs to become the guy we voted for. Because, as Frum just showed, Obama will be criticized by Republicans for whatever he does - hell, the religious right is claiming, incredibly, that the President's defense of DOMA in the courts is actually, somehow, a
secret pro-gay plot!
President Obama might as well do what he promised, full-bore, since he's going to be blamed for doing it full-bore, regardless of how much he actually waters the promise down.
Read More......