John recently wrote about how he's not a big fan of the
term LGBT. I actually disagree - I like the term for a few reasons, let me explain
I may not consider myself to be a “G” a “B” a “T”, or, for that matter, an “I,” a “Q” or an “A”, but I do consider myself an LGBT American, and I feel very strongly that we are linked together in a single, common struggle. Our fellow contributor, Tim Beauchamp, summed up my feelings about the matter some time ago with a brief comment: "it's all about gender expression." One or two commenters on John’s LGBT post alluded to this point-of-view, but did not elaborate on it much. I want to elaborate on it here. (And btw, here's
more from Tim on the subject).
No matter what letter(s) of the alphabet you consider yourself to be, all of us challenge gender norms in one way or another. We might wish we lived in an age where such roles no longer matter, but we do not live in a post-gender world. Men are still expected to act like men and women to act like women, regardless of what form those roles may take. When a man has sex with another man, he is gender non-conforming regardless of how masculine he may feel or how closely he may otherwise adhere to our society's conception of masculinity. When a "biological" woman lives as a man, he is gender non-conforming. When a bisexual refuses to express a preference for men or for women, that person is gender non-conforming. The norms may be a bit more fluid than they used to be – when I was a girl, for instance, my insistence on wearing jeans was met with major resistance – but they are still there.
Some of us can pass more easily than others if they want to, but that does not change the validity of the group’s existence. Just because someone is a lipstick lesbian or an MTF who passes as a woman or a bisexual person in a relationship with a member of the opposite sex does not mean that those people do not belong to our community.
As for LGBT being just a clumsy string of letters, I prefer it to terms like “sexual minority” that cover up our differences. Even though I believe we are aligned in the struggle, we do have separate identities and face different challenges, and using LGBT acknowledges these differences while binding us together in common cause. And I like that the term can embrace new groups. We need all the allies we can get.
Read More...