I keep hearing of the recent success stories in Iraq that are attributed to the surge. Of course President Bush will
capitalize on this temporary phenomenon with his usual optimism that his plan for Iraq will be successful -- whether he actually believes it or not. His allies in Congress will continue to tout the so called progress along with the Republican presidential candidates going into the 2008 election -- provided it lasts long enough. One thing I'm sure about is that now more than ever we as Americans need to engage in a continuous debate on Iraq that involves a significant amount of critical thinking. Most of all we must lobby our members of Congress to do so as well.
Lets take a look at the reported progress:
- For the first time in years there is a sense of
normalcy in Baghdad
- Thousands of Iraqi refugees have returned to a
safer Iraq
- Iraqi civilian deaths have
dropped to the lowest level this year
- Significant
decrease in roadside bomb attacks
- Security operations and
control of Karbala turned over to the Iraqis
- A drawdown of US forces in the volatile
Diyala province
- Bush declared the drawdown of
20,000 troops (possibly).
Factoring in the bad news:
-
3,850 US troops killed
- Approximately 30,000 US troops wounded
- An uncountable number of Iraqis killed
- A continuous cycle of
deadly violence
- Conflicting reports that Iraqi deaths have
increased not decreased
- An Iraqi government that is run by religious tribal leaders
- The reemergence of the
PKK terrorist organization
- The government of Turkey at
war with PKK rebels in northern Iraq
- No halt in the multi-front Iraqi civil war
- An Iraqi security and police force rampant with
corruption- Very little progress toward political
reconciliation- A
50 year US military presence in the Middle East
- The warning of
World War III against Iraq's neighboring country of Iran
- And the list goes on and on
The milk is spilled. The damage is done. So where do we go from here?
Congress has demonstrated that we can not rely on them to set aside their bickering, finger pointing, and
extreme partisanship to work together in an effort to solve the problem. We as average American people can do nothing short of voting them out of office in the next election.
But will we trade them for leaders who will promise us solutions and deliver nothing like our current members Congress? Quite possibly. That is a very reasonable assumption considering how we are lied to over and over again by politicians in Washington.
To be fair there are many
members of Congress who ardently oppose this war, but lack the numbers to bring about change. Sadly, we are stuck in Iraq for a while.
Do we just simply try to balance out the good with the bad in the hopes of breaking even? Is that the best we can hope for? Considering there is any "good."
In order to pacify Iraq it would take at a minimum 350,000 troops. And most likely that would still not be enough. Furthermore, it would never be sustainable because most Americans are unwilling to commit any sacrifice of their own. Especially supporters of the war who fall into the financially "well-to-do" chickenhawk category. They are not even willing to sacrifice their tax cuts to help pay for it. Real American patriots they are (sarcastically said). But oh how quick they are to call me a traitor for my views against a war that I fought that they support but would never have the courage to go and fight themselves.
Do these fools even know what they support and advocate for? We invaded and occupied a country that did not want war with us. A total act of un-American hostile aggression.
I have tried to put aside my strong anti-war beliefs and consider the possibility that Iraq could one day be a better place because of our invasion and continued occupation -- as ridiculous as that sounds. I have tried so many times and thought for many long hours. But I never could find any rationale or logic to convince me that Iraq will ever be a safe and peaceful part of the world because of the war George W. Bush has inflicted upon them.
When I balance out the supposed successes of the surge with the failures of the war as a whole I am just more and more convinced that we just need to give Iraq back to the Iraqi people. After all, it is their country not ours. And furthermore, we owe the Iraqis reparations as well -- for the sake of humanity. I know it won't happen yesterday or tomorrow, but the process must start.
How? In my opinion we must learn from the lesson of the last election. In 2008 we can't allow ourselves to be fooled again. Candidates who want my vote need to do an exceptional job of ensuring me that they will do everything in their power to end the war. It's not until then that we can stop spending all of our political energy on Iraq and start taking care of the problems we face at home.
We have a long road ahead.
Keep up the fight and thank you for reading.
John Bruhns
Iraq Veteran
Read More......