Surprise surprise surprise. What surprises me is that it took this long for the Democrats to get cold feet.
As you may recall, the hate crimes bill (adding sexual orientation, gender identity, disability and gender to the already-existing federal hate crimes law) was added on to a defense bill in the Senate (Bush threatened a veto, thus the reason it was added on to a must-pass bill that Bush would be uncomfortable vetoing), it passed the House as a free-standing bill. Well, it appears that House Republicans are now balking at adding the hate crimes legislation on to the same defense bill in the House, which would pretty much guarantee it would make its way to the president's desk, then he'd have to veto a defense bill, which would be quite interesting. The House Republicans are up in arms about attaching a gay thing to a defense bill (surprise), and the Democrats, the conservative ones at least, are siding with the House Republicans (again, big surprise there). So let me ask the following question: At what point did we not think that the Republicans were going to squawk because this was added on to a defense bill? I mean, I'm all for adding it to must-pass legislation like the defense bill in order to try to short-circuit Bush's veto - in fact, it's a very smart strategy. But it was also painfully obvious months ago that the GOP would complain that we were "polluting" a defense bill. So why is everything heading south now, as if the GOP complaint, and conservative Dem defection, is suddenly some kind of surprise we weren't prepared for?
This is looking very much like the ENDA debacle where, suddenly, everyone was surprised that adding "gender identity" (e.g., transsexuals, cross dressers) was somehow a controversial notion. Like no one thought it might be controversial before the brouhaha?
And a final PS. The bill is already passed in the House as a free-standing bill, and it's already been passed as part of the defense bill in the Senate. That means that the real issue here is whether the Dems have the courage to keep the hate crimes provisions in the House-Senate conference report (i.e., after they reconcile the House and Senate versions of the defense bill). The Dems run the House and Senate, so if it drops from the conference report, it means that senior Dems agreed to drop it. Just remember that.
Read More......