TO: President Obama
FROM: John Aravosis
RE: Why a lot of your supporters are cranky
Mr. President, a lot of your supporters have gotten cranky. And it seems that you're getting the wrong advice for why that is. To the extent you don't understand the problem, you can't fix it. So here's my attempt, as one supporter, to explain the problem as simply as possible.
The issue isn't that people's expectations of you were too high. No one
expected you to be Superman. We did however expect you to at least try to do your job, and attempt to keep your promises. It often doesn't feel like you attempt either one. It sometimes even feels that you don't fully realize that you're President.
About BP. There are others who understand the spill far greater than I, but I would like to respond to one argument that your supporters constantly raise: that Americans shouldn't expect you to do the high-profile public relations stuff that typically goes with being president during a national disaster. Your presidency is different, we're told. You're thoughtful and contemplative. You take your time, and don't feel the need to emote. Emotion is a waste of time and energy that you can't afford, while you think about the nation's big problems.
Well, maybe. But that isn't the way America works. The voters expect their president to work on solving problems, to be sure, but they also expect him to be their leader, to be there when things go bad, and to reassure them that everything is going to be okay. It's a fact of life in American politics: People want to see their leaders lead. And all the explanations of how this isn't your style are meaningless. If anything, the explanations we're hearing are hurting you even more in the public eye.
No one wants to be told that their desire for you to assuage the country's concerns is somehow adolescent of them. Whether it is or isn't is irrelevant. It's what this country expects of its leaders. So please tell your staff, and your remaining supporters, to stop lecturing the American people about how silly they are to expect you to show your face when a crisis arises.
But there's a larger problem here, Mr. President. Your staff and supporters would have us rest assured that your subdued leadership style, while not very flashy or paternalistic, is quietly and consistently getting the job done behind the scenes, even if it doesn't look that way to the public. The problem is, I don't think people believe you're actually working diligently behind the scenes. That isn't your style, as we've seen on issue after issue since you've taken office.
You don't, Mr. President, grab onto an issue like a dog with a bone, tenaciously working it until you get the best deal possible, even if all your hard work goes on under the radar, behind the scenes. More often than not, you make a public statement about your general goal, and then you sit back and don't get involved until things are ready to fall apart. It's what you did on health care reform, it's what you're doing on Don't Ask, Don't Tell, and immigration, and lots of other issues you campaigned on. Time after time, you didn't work behind the scenes to fulfill your public promise. Instead, you sat back and let your staff, or worse, the Congress, take a stab at the issue, while you waited to see what they came up with, as the issue careened out of control. Then, at the last minute, after your initial promise had been obliterated, you got involved, only to find that the compromise being discussed looked little like what you had promised the American people in the first place.
This is why people aren't satisfied by explanations of how your superior intellect requires you to remain behind the scenes and work these issues in secret, without being bothered by the silly public's need to occasional see your face and hear your voice.
People don't believe you're working behind the scenes at all.
What people believe is that you prefer to avoid what you consider "controversial" issues all together. And should one be thrust upon you, you stay far away until a final deal appears near, so you can jump on board at the last minute, whatever the deal, and claim credit. After all, if you were involved in the deal-making from the beginning, you might not get 100% of what you wanted, and your staff thinks that would make you look weak. So better to not get involved at all, and then at the end decide if you want credit for what everyone else has come up with, even if its bears no resemblance to what you promised the American people in the first place.
It's a shitty way to make policy, and an even worse way to get people to vote for you a second time.
Your problem, Mr. President, isn't that people think you're Superman. It's that they don't believe you believe in, or do, much of anything at all.
Read More......