I guess I
should have been more outraged with the accounting firm (E&Y;) who worked with Lehman to play accounting games, but I'm not. It's not that I agree with their actions or think they shouldn't be punished but we've been seeing this over and over.
Enron? Parmalat? Tyco? What the hell do the authorities need to see to actually change the system? Now that we're down to only the
Big 4 auditors, should we expect anything else? As I mentioned the other day when the Lehman report came out, these firms desperately want to hold on to these lucrative contracts so they will agree to almost anything to hold them.
Thanks to consolidation in the market there are fewer alternatives and the size of these contracts grows every year. Until there's a serious effort in Europe and the US to address this situation we can expect more of these scandals. Maybe this latest effort will instigate reform but somehow that's doubtful. Political leaders have decided that they're OK with these scandals or else they would have done something serious after the last round of mega-accounting scandals.
When we can have reports showing the rapid collapse of multi-billion dollar operations such as Lehman yet no clear violation of the law, you have to wonder what is wrong and rotten in our legal system. It only reinforces the belief that business always has the upper hand and they own politicians. Look at how badly the Wall Street reform has gone in Washington. Trillions blown away yet Washington can't find agreement on reform? Yes it's the GOP who is blocking reform and backing Wall Street but how hard is it to
shove the 82% down the throats of Republicans? It doesn't say much about the Democrats if they can't win over the public and force the GOP to back down on this issue. Time to call it a day if that happens.
Of course we should expect more from our political leadership. How many more Enron's or Lehman's before they care enough to ignore the lobbyists and do something? How many more billions need to be lost before the laws make that a
criminal offense?Prem Sikka, a professor of accounting at Essex University and a leading critic of the accounting profession, warned that without deep-rooted reform the crisis could repeat itself. "The report into the collapse of Lehmans is indicative of a deeper malaise," he said. "We rely on the discretion of eminent firms of auditors and lawyers that are paid millions of pounds for their efforts, but that discretion is too often abused."
A damning 2,200-page report commissioned by the US bankruptcy courts into the collapse of Lehman said that Ernst & Young's failure to act over off-balance sheet accounting practices which allowed the bank to hide $50bn of debts, and failing to investigate the concerns of a whistleblower, amounted to "professional negligence".
Read More......