READER COMMENTS ON
"RELEASED ONLINE: Neil Young's 'Living With War'"
(34 Responses so far...)
COMMENT #1 [Permalink]
...
Laura
said on 4/28/2006 @ 2:53 pm PT...
Thanks Brad. Thanks Neil! Absolutely the best! Neil cares enough about this country and where its going to give this to the masses free. WOO HOO! You are a true AMERICAN PATRIOT! Peace Everyone!
COMMENT #2 [Permalink]
...
Larry Bergan
said on 4/28/2006 @ 3:06 pm PT...
Guess they can's say he doing for the money. I just heard the whole thing for free!
COMMENT #3 [Permalink]
...
Arry
said on 4/28/2006 @ 4:13 pm PT...
Yes, Neil's a patriot. Honestly, I thought, oh, this is going to be OK, but not much after the first two songs, but he hits his stride with "The Restless Consumer" - Don't need no more lies tying in with the war - that's good. (And the thing starts to rock then, too. Unsubtle, straight on protest rock - what Neil's good at.)
I like "back in the days of shock and awe, back in the days of mission accomplished".
A little homage to Bob Dylan - and, so, protest songs, in "Flags of Freedom"...you know, "Chimes of Freedom"
Who couldn't like "Let's Impeach the President" --- hope it gets a lot of play.
Ok now, let's see the neocon apologists put out a good cd. The militarists gave the peaceniks such a run for the money in the Nixonian era.
COMMENT #4 [Permalink]
...
Arry
said on 4/28/2006 @ 4:52 pm PT...
Oh, thanks Neil for the free songs. I'll buy the cd anyway. One good turn deserves another.
COMMENT #5 [Permalink]
...
Grizzly Bear Dancer
said on 4/28/2006 @ 5:11 pm PT...
Thank you Neal. Kick ace! Your lyrics speak volumes on this one. Gonna pick up the new one tonight. GBD
COMMENT #6 [Permalink]
...
GrannyBgood
said on 4/28/2006 @ 5:14 pm PT...
Thankyou Niel Young! We can always count on you!
.... About time more of our Classic Greats came out with Protest Music
As for this National Anthem Debate,
I still like Jimmi Hendrix's version from the Sixties the BEST!!
That SCREAMING Finale about says it ALL!!
..Then and Now..in ANY language!
COMMENT #7 [Permalink]
...
GrannyBgood
said on 4/28/2006 @ 5:22 pm PT...
Thankyou Niel Young! We can always count on you!
.... About time more of our Classic Greats came out with Protest Music
As for this National Anthem Debate,
I still like Jimmi Hendrix's version from the Sixties the BEST!!
That SCREAMING Finale about says it ALL!!
..Then and Now..in ANY language!
COMMENT #8 [Permalink]
...
GrannyBgood
said on 4/28/2006 @ 5:28 pm PT...
... Sorry about the repeat... your server said I was "timed out!"
COMMENT #9 [Permalink]
...
kevkev
said on 4/28/2006 @ 5:36 pm PT...
I LOOK FORWARD THE THE CSN AND SOMTIMES Y
TOUR.
IT IS GOING TO BE A LONG HOT SUMMER FOR
THE WHITE HOUSE, BUSH, ETC.
LETS PRAY FOR PEACE.
BUT LETS
86W!!!
COMMENT #10 [Permalink]
...
Joan
said on 4/28/2006 @ 6:57 pm PT...
Thank you, Neil! Thank you, Brad! Thank you, whoever arrested rush limbaugh...made my night!!
COMMENT #11 [Permalink]
...
GWN
said on 4/28/2006 @ 7:24 pm PT...
Thank you Brad . Thank you Neil. The songs are great but leave me with a heavy heart. It's a reminder of the Vietnam days and meeting guys who came here to avoid the draft. I never EVER dreamed that I would see this happen again in my life time.
The drumming is great ...
ITMFA
COMMENT #12 [Permalink]
...
KestrelBrighteyes
said on 4/28/2006 @ 8:15 pm PT...
I'm gonna buy it too, maybe give it to my kid on his 14th birthday, because even at his age, he gets it!
COMMENT #13 [Permalink]
...
Bill
said on 4/28/2006 @ 9:43 pm PT...
I thought the entire CD was beyond exceptional. The Restless Consumer brought tears to my eyes. Good to hear somoene singing some truth for a change. Maybe now I can see a little further. Thanks Neil for the spontaneity. It is genuine and full of heart...I could hear it in the drumming as well. You're a true patriot of the people.
COMMENT #14 [Permalink]
...
cyn
said on 4/28/2006 @ 10:11 pm PT...
The RIGHTs been saying:
"Young did it for the MONEY" (cd)
Sure...that's why it's on the Web EVERYWHERE for FREE...
Ya gotta give it to the guy...He says everything WE'VE ALL BEEN FEELING for so long...
Thank you Neil - You speak from our hearts too!
Keep on Rockin' in the Free (USA) world!
cyn
COMMENT #15 [Permalink]
...
K. Ron Silkwood
said on 4/29/2006 @ 3:43 am PT...
Excellent!! Now I can play some new protest music. I'll buy the cd, and with the coming summer and my open windows, I should be able to shatter the brains of all the fascists in my neighborhood.
COMMENT #16 [Permalink]
...
Peg C
said on 4/29/2006 @ 6:44 am PT...
I can't listen to the stream - dialup - so I can't wait for the CD. Those '60's protest songs have stayed with me, achingly, and it certainly is time for some new ones! Thank you, Neil Young...and thanks, Brad, for keeping abreast of this and keeping us informed.
COMMENT #17 [Permalink]
...
debbie
said on 4/29/2006 @ 11:25 am PT...
To better understand the spontaneity of Neil Young's writing, you can watch Neil himself explain his songwriting process in an excerpt from his SXSW keynote conversation at SXSW site.
Interestingly enough, I watched the keynote in its entirety yesterday, which included an introduction from SXSW's Roland Swenson. Roland spoke about the environment and impact of Neil's song "Ohio" about the Kent State massacre. How it galvanized so many in the nation, and people said, "Enough!". Years after Neil said "It's still hard to believe I had to write this song".
Roland ended the intro by saying, "Mr. Young, if you can hear me...we need a new song!" Sounds like a call to action to me, and if it influenced Neil in the least, I am grateful.
COMMENT #18 [Permalink]
...
STOP George
said on 4/29/2006 @ 12:07 pm PT...
.
.
.
I have a dream.
It is a dream where thousands upon thousands of Americans surround the White House and sing this song as loud as they can.
Broadcast live --- primetime.
Upons seeing this spontaneous protest, millions upon millions take action.
It's kind of like that moment where everyone gets out of their cars in that R.E.M. video.
.
.
.
COMMENT #19 [Permalink]
...
Charlene
said on 4/29/2006 @ 12:36 pm PT...
I had a dream where Al Qaeda gets Bush & Cheney & chops off THEIR heads.
I'm asking myself, was it a nightmare--or not?
COMMENT #20 [Permalink]
...
Arry
said on 4/29/2006 @ 10:42 pm PT...
Just want to add to my #3 - I thought it was good, but it's even better than I thought. Now that I'm taking a second listening (without buffering:-) it really clicked. They really are terrific songs - music and lyrics equally and complenting each other.
Messages: No more lies; we can be something a lot different and a lot better; impeach the damn "president"
It's easy to get caught up in the excitement of a new protest album by a veteran like Neil Young, but this may really be a classic.
(Agree with Bill at #13 about "The Restless Consumer" - what a great, angry, necessary truthtelling - one terrific song.)
COMMENT #21 [Permalink]
...
big johnny
said on 4/29/2006 @ 11:42 pm PT...
Yes, i've listened to it continuously since it first came up on the 'nets. This is a very good album, there is no doubt about it. Solid rock and roll a la Ragged Glory and Mirror Ball. Thoughtful lyricism a la Broken Arrow and Harvest Moon. The only thing I was somewhat disappointed by was the fact that there was no extended guitar meltdown solo as with "Southern Man", "Down By the River", etc. Otherwise his guitar is exceptional as always.
"Roger and out" (#9) is playing now is also very good.
Thanks Neil... this restless consumer will be very happy to go out and buy your new record!
COMMENT #22 [Permalink]
...
GrannyBgood
said on 4/30/2006 @ 8:42 am PT...
"Roland spoke about the environment and impact of Neil's song "Ohio" about the Kent State massacre. How it galvanized so many in the nation, and people said, "Enough!". Years after Neil said "It's still hard to believe I had to write this "
Our "Burnin'Band" in Maine has been rockin' out doing protest songs for over 20 years now, and even written a couple ~all BEFORE it was "In" again.
One of our "classics" has always been a seguey where we do, a capela, "Find the Cost of Freedom"
followed by a STOMPIN' version of "OHIO".
I'll never forget how, a couple of years ago, a bunch of our Redneck Townies stomped out of the hall over that... even though we were playing a BENEFIT for one of their RELATIVE's medical expenses!
Yup, that's the types who voted Bush... TWICE!
COMMENT #23 [Permalink]
...
GrannyBgood
said on 4/30/2006 @ 8:46 am PT...
Oh yes, and talk about guitar meltdowns!
How about forgetting the language barrier and officially adopting the Jimmi Hendrix version of our StarSpangledBanner!
That Screaming Finale STILL says it all.. in ANY language!
COMMENT #24 [Permalink]
...
Jeffrey Hunter
said on 4/30/2006 @ 9:22 am PT...
Living With War is incendiary Rock & Roll at it's very finest! I rate it 5 Stars! Every American needs to listen to this album - regardless of political stripe!
Rock on Neil!
COMMENT #25 [Permalink]
...
Anthony Corso
said on 4/30/2006 @ 10:17 am PT...
I will buy the CD as soon as I can find it. In the meantime, everyone..please read John Kerry's speech, Apr. 22 dilivered at Faneuil Hall in Boston.
COMMENT #26 [Permalink]
...
Bill
said on 4/30/2006 @ 10:35 am PT...
What Neil said in his interview with CNN--"Red and blue or not black and white. We're all together. It's a record about unification."-- shows me that he's not trying to be the very thing we are all protesting. His gift for us all is a voice. The grunge has a way of transforming that illusion of hopelessness. It can't just be about us versus them. That's been going on since the beginning of time.
COMMENT #27 [Permalink]
...
Bill
said on 4/30/2006 @ 7:35 pm PT...
Debbie--
I didn't yet see the keynote at SXSW but I found an interview by them with Neil regarding his creative process. Neil says, among other things, "When you're terrifed, you know you're on the right track." This was probably just slightly before Living With War. But, compare this to the "creativity" of Bush the deluded aggressor. At first we were in Afghanistan, now we are dumping billions into Iraq in a war without a noble cause. The difference here is that I don't think Bush's own fear sprung from his love of humanity. Being the opportunist he is, he used our fear to advance his vision of a cookie-cutter democracy. But even though things appear dark and dire it's not at all a hopeless situation. I feel that's part of what Neil's message is. Where there is no heart, there is lying, and calculated destruction based on trying to get what isn't ours. But the heart can change that nightmare into something that we can all live with, even those who are out deluding themselves with visions of war.
Good to hear Neil singing, "I take a holy vow to never kill again."
COMMENT #28 [Permalink]
...
Bill
said on 5/3/2006 @ 9:12 pm PT...
It's also good to hear Neil's LWW songs on a local radio station. I heard three of them so far. What a treat!
BTW, I'm actually new at posting on blogs. Seriously. As for #27, I'm thinking that maybe it's a lot of blah, blah for the small point I was trying to make. At any rate, I am interested in other comments. But, if it must end here, then so be it.
The End
COMMENT #29 [Permalink]
...
Cam
said on 5/4/2006 @ 3:11 pm PT...
holy crap Neil Young is my idol and i love him so much ... if i dont buy it i'll die!! :crazy:
COMMENT #30 [Permalink]
...
Bruce
said on 5/9/2006 @ 6:13 pm PT...
COMMENT #31 [Permalink]
...
Bruce
said on 5/9/2006 @ 6:15 pm PT...
COMMENT #32 [Permalink]
...
Bruce
said on 5/11/2006 @ 2:28 pm PT...
BTW, the above songs have been censored and banned in a grand Bush-esque style at More Cowbell. You won't find that kind of censorhsip here.
COMMENT #33 [Permalink]
...
Bruce
said on 5/11/2006 @ 2:32 pm PT...
BTW, the above songs were banned and censored at More Cowbell in a grand, Bush-esque manner. You won't find that kind of censorhip here.
COMMENT #34 [Permalink]
...
Bruce
said on 5/17/2006 @ 11:13 pm PT...
I'm no longer a one-man "banned." More Cowbell has now officially lifted the ban on my music.