Former Armed Forces Chief Başbuğ in Custody

Photo from Radikal

Today, on January 5th, retired former chief of General Staff General Ilker Başbuğ was called to testify as a suspect in a probe into propaganda websites that were allegedly set up by the military to undermine the AKP government. He faces preliminary charges of “gang leadership” and seeking to unseat the government by force. He has been taken into custody at a military jail overnight pending trial. He is the highest ranking military officer to be investigated and the first chief of general staff to be jailed. (click here and here, here in Turkish)

Turkey’s Glow Dims

Some take-away quotes from a hard-hitting New York Times article about the AKP’s intensifying crackdown on free speech. For the full article, click here.

After Mr. Erdogan swept to power in 2002, human rights activists initially lauded him for expanding free speech. But after an unsuccessful attempt by the secular opposition to ban Mr. Erdogan’s party in 2008, critics say, Mr. Erdogan embarked on a systematic campaign to silence his opponents.

–There are now 97 members of the news media in jail in Turkey, including journalists, publishers and distributors, according to the Turkish Journalists’ Union, a figure that rights groups say exceeds the number detained in China.

–The European Human Rights Court received nearly 9,000 complaints against Turkey for breaches of press freedom and freedom of expression in 2011, compared with 6,500 in 2009.

–In late December, Turkey drew fresh criticism after the police detained at least 38 people, many of them journalists, saying they had possible links to a Kurdish separatist group. But critics say dozens have been arrested whose only offense was to have expressed general support for the rights of Kurds, a long-oppressed minority here.

–Dozens of current and former military personnel, intellectuals and politicians have also been detained who have been linked to what officials say was a plot to overthrow the government by an organization called Ergenekon.

–Four years into the Ergenekon investigation, no one among the more than 300 suspects charged in the case has been convicted, even though courts have heard more than 8,000 pages worth of indictments, many of them based on transcripts of surreptitiously recorded private telephone conversations.

–Advocates for press freedom say that the government has also moved to mute opposition by using punitive fines and by intimidating the ownership of leading media companies.

–While the Internet has become the main weapon against censorship, more than 15,000 Web sites have been blocked by the state, according to engelliweb.com, which tracks restricted pages. For more than two years until last fall, YouTube was banned on the grounds that some videos on the site were insulting to Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, the founder of modern Turkey.

The monitoring agency last summer called on Web sites to ban 138 words, including “animal,” “erotic” and “zoo” in English and “fat,” “blonde” and “skirt” in Turkish. It is a tribute to Turkey’s still vibrant media culture that the prohibition inspired an online competition to create the best short story out of the banned words.

1980 Redux


The two surviving members of the five-man junta that carried out the 1980 military coup, Kenan Evren (94), then Chief of General Staff and later president until 1989, and Tahsin Şahinkaya (86), then air forces commander, have been indicted for crimes against the state: “intentionally attempting to force Turkish Parliament to annul itself or stop it from fulfilling its duties.” The prosecutor has asked for life imprisonment. A separate investigation is ongoing with regard to torture allegations in the coup period between 1980 and 1983 when elections were held. (click here)

During the 1980 coup period, 650,000 people were taken into custody and 230,000 were put on trial. Military prosecutors demanded capital punishment for 7,000 people; 517 of them received the death penalty and 50 were hanged. Military rulers revoked the citizenship of more than 14,000 Turks while another 30,000 left the country to seek refuge abroad.  Some 299 prison inmates also died of “undetermined” reasons while another 14 died in hunger strikes. Torture by security forces reportedly claimed another 171 lives.

The indictments were made possible by an amendment to the Constitution in 2010 that allowed military officers to be tried in civilian courts. (click here) Evren has previously threatened to commit suicide if he is put on trial. click here

The Egyptian generals who believe themselves to be following the “Turkish model” (protecting Egypt’s new democracy against the encroachment of Islam) might be a bit taken aback.

A Happy, Peaceful New Year To All

Comet Lovejoy 2011, seen from the International Space Station, NASA

Returning to the Era of Prisons

An international group of scholars has begun a collaborative effort to address growing violations of academic freedom in Turkey since 2009. Under the pretext of counter-terrorism operations, countless academics, students, translators, lawyers, and journalists have been arbitrarily arrested, posing an extreme threat to freedom of expression and association. It is a shame that after decades of economic and political successes, just as Turkey is on the cusp of being a recognized world leader, the word Turkey once again is associated with “prison” just as in the days of “Midnight Express” and “Yol”.

Inspired by the call of our colleagues in France who have constituted /Groupe International de Travail/, GIT, we have decided to form the North American node of a transnational working group that aims to raise awareness and offer documentation on “Academic Liberty and Freedom of Research in Turkey.”

Hence, our invitation: please consider joining our efforts in GIT-North America, which is currently in the process of articulating its goals and scope. If interested, you could reach us at gitamerica@yahoo.com and join our growing network. If you prefer to just follow our work, please visit GIT-North America’s blog <http://gitamerica.blogspot.com/> and “like” GIT Initiative’s Facebook page <http://www.facebook.com/pages/GIT-Initiative/288505904533560?ref=ts>.

We would also like to remind you that GIT Initiative in France will make public on January 1, 2012 a new list of colleagues worldwide who have added their signatures to the inaugural declaration for Academic Liberty and Freedom of Expression in Turkey. If you wish to sign the declaration, GIT website <http://www.gitinitiative.com/> includes practical information and addresses for your reference. An expanded list of signatures will be published on January 15, 2012.

Jadaliyya has posted translations of a letter and statement from an activist in prison, one of dozens of writers, scholars and civic activists supporting Kurdish rights arrested in the past few months and accused of supporting terrorism. This statement is interesting in part because of the description of how the legal system is handling evidence, the right of the accused to know the charges against her, and treatment of lawyers of the accused. This is not new, of course. Similar accounts by other detainees have been circulated in the press, but it is worth looking carefully at the details of the judicial process, not just the arrests.

In October 2011, Ayşe Berktay (Hacimirzaoglu)—a renowned translator, researcher, and global peace and justice activist—was taken by the police from her home in Istanbul at five o’clock in the morning and subsequently arrested. She still remains imprisoned for the foreseeable future. Below is a letter and statement by Ayşe Berktay, addressed to Lieven De Cauter—a philosopher and founding member of the Brussels Tribunal—who has been organizing an international campaign to release Ayşe Berktay from prison. Click here to sign a petition to stop arbitrary detentions in Turkey….

Photo from jadaliyya

[Below is an excerpt of her statement. For the letter and full statement, click here to go to the jadaliyya site]

Ayşe Berktay’s Summary of Her Situation and Proposals

December 2011 [Istanbul Bakirköy Women’s Prison] Translated from Turkish into English by Amy Marie Spangler

I was taken into custody at 5am on 3 October 2011, when my house was raided by the police. All of us were taken into custody in the same way, at approximately the same hour. My door was not broken down, but the doors of some were. Some of our friends, not at home when the police showed up, went to party headquarters (BDP-Peace and Democracy Party) to find out what was going on and what could be done, and were then taken into custody themselves from there. In fact, one person, upon hearing that the person who generally opens up the BDP’s Istanbul Province Headquarters had been taken into custody, showed up to open the building so that the headquarters wouldn’t remain closed that day. This person too was taken into custody there.

So, I mean, no one attempted escape of any kind. And none of us were summoned for questioning or testimony prior to being taken into custody. The method of raiding houses and forcibly taking people into custody, which should be used only under exceptional circumstances, has now become standard procedure. Being awoken from sleep at five o’clock in the morning to find your house full of armed police is simply unacceptable. Our whereabouts, our jobs, our addresses, our lives are not secret; we can easily be found. If there is an investigation happening, they could easily call us in for questioning. There was absolutely no justification for raiding my house. A thorough search was conducted in my house, which certainly pushed the limits and at least verged upon an invasion of privacy. During the search, books and my computer were confiscated as evidence. The practice of the police and courts thus far indicates that the websites I have visited, articles I have downloaded and read, drafts of articles I have written, and thoughts that I have noted down can all be admitted as elements of crime. Freedom of thought and expression and the freedom to organize have all been completely trampled upon, completely disregarded.

They listened in on our telephone calls. While listening in on private communication is generally something used as a last resort, in our case it happens automatically. Yet I have made no attempt to conceal my actions. Everything I do is completely out in the open.

The file regarding our case has been declared confidential. Therefore, we are unable to learn what we are being accused of or the hard evidence upon which the case is based. Other than general, roundabout expressions like “strong suspicion” and “the nature of the evidence and accusations stated in the file,” we know nothing about the evidence against us, based upon which we have been arrested. Hence it is impossible for us to defend ourselves. Our right to defense has been obstructed, destroyed. We were told that our lawyers would not be given a copy of the deposition we were to give at the police station, accompanied by our lawyers. Legally it is utterly unacceptable to not give a copy of this document, which both I and my lawyer were to sign, to my lawyer. And so no statements were given at the police station. We were transferred to the prosecution office without having first given a deposition. In the document written by the judge responsible for the decision not to give our lawyers copies of our signed depositions, all of the lawyers who had taken on our legal defense were described as potential criminals. The exact words were: A copy of the depositions is not to be given to the lawyers because they may share it with the terror organization…

Turkey to Train Libya’s New Army

Libya’s National Transitional Council Chairman Mustafa Abduljalil has announced that they have reached an agreement for their new army to be trained in Turkey. On his visit to Istanbul last week, Abduljalil commented, “We had the opportunity to discuss a number of issues with Prime Minister Erdoğan. We reached an agreement for Libya’s new army to receive training in Turkey. Meanwhile, our efforts for a transition to an organized military continue. Next week, we will announce the work we have done led by Minister of Defense Osama al-Juwali.” During his trip, Abduljalil also paid a visit to the ‘freedom fighters’ that were wounded in the uprising against Muammer Gaddafi and were in Turkey to receive treatment. /Sabah English/

More Scientific Publications

Salman Hameed writes on his blog Irtiqa that some Muslim countries are showing an increase in scientific publications. (Hameed blogs about the interrelation of science and religion, particularly in the Muslim world.)

This week’s Nature has a nice map of top 40 countries in terms of the number of scientific publications. Turkey, Iran, Egypt and Malaysia are on the list. Iran also shows a 20% increase compared to its 2010 publication record – the largest increase amongst the top 40 countries. These numbers are just for 2011, but Iran, Turkey and Egypt have been showing a consistent increase in their science papers over the past 10 years or so.

Here’s the map:

Image from Nature

One of the commenters on Irtiqa suggested the map would be more useful if the numbers of publications were contextualized with information about numbers of academics/researchers in each country. I’d like to see which research topics are most popular in each country. What subjects have shot up in Iran and Turkey, for instance? It would be interesting to know if change in government support is responsible for a rise or decline in certain research topics. (This is as true in the US as anywhere else.)

Joy To The World

Deniz Hughes took this cheerful photo in New York (see her blog for more great photos).

Photo by Deniz Hughes at Denizblog

And here are “New Year’s” decorations in Ankara. What on earth is Santa doing?

AA Photo from Hurriyet

Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays!

May there be harmony between men and women, between nations and tribes, and respectful communion with all creatures that share this planet. May 2012 bring peace and joy to all.

38 Journalists Rounded Up

This post has been updated.

Dozens of journalists were arrested today in Istanbul, Ankara, Izmir, Van, Adana and Diyarbakır, accused of supporting the PKK by being active in the larger umbrella organization, Union of Kurdish Communities. Their homes and offices were searched. Those arrested include employees of the Dicle News Agency (DİHA), the Etkin News Agency (ETHA), the Fırat News Agency (ANF) and the Özgür Gündem newspaper, as well as a photo reporter for Agence France-Presse and a reporter for Vatan newspaper. The toll today is 38, according to the Freedom for Journalists Platform. Hundreds protested against the arrests in Istanbul. (click here)

These were the journalists in police custody as of yesterday (click here):

Employees of DİHA and Özgür Gündem; DİHA editor-in-chief Fatma Koçak; DİHA concessionaire Zuhal Tekiner; DİHA Diyarbakır reporter Mazlum Özdemir; DİHA Van reporter Evrim Kepenek; DİHA Istanbul reporters Ömer Çelik and Çağdaş Kaplan; DİHA Urfa reporter Sadık Topaloğlu; DİHA Ankara reporters Kenan Kırıkkaya, İsmail Yıldız, Sevinç Tunceli, Güneş Ünsal, Nuri Fırat, Ziya Çiçek, Çiğdem Aslan, Ramazan Teköz, Semiha Alankuş, Ertuş Bozkurt, Diler Demirel and Hüseyin Deniz; ETHA editor Arzu Demir; Birgün newspaper reporter Zeynep Kuray; AFP photo reporter Mustafa Özer; Vatan newspaper reporter Çağdaş Ulus; Demokratik Modernite magazine editorial board member Nahide ErmişCihan Albay and Etik Agency manager Davut Uçar.