We’ve written about the alternate universe we could be living in many times before – if only the 2000 election had turned out differently. There’s a blogger or two who may have touched on it, and maybe a columnist or two.
But it is interesting to see a smart New York magazine finally coming around to a point of view we’ve had since writing at Southerner.Net from New Orleans nearly four years ago.
According to David Remnick’s column in the current New Yorker, it is useful to reflect on “how much better off the United States and the world would be today if the outcome of the 2000 election had been permitted to correspond with the wishes of the electorate.”
While the attacks of September 11, 2001, may not have been avoided, he concludes, “there is ample evidence, in the 9/11 Commission report and elsewhere, that Gore and his circle were far more alert to the threat of Islamist terrorism than Bush and his.”
Can anyone seriously doubt that a Gore Administration would have meant, well, an alternate universe, in which, say:
1. American troops were sent on a necessary mission in Afghanistan but not on a mistaken and misbegotten one in Iraq?
2. The fate of the earth, not the fate of oil-company executives, was the priority of the Environmental Protection Agency.
3. Civil liberties and diplomacy were subjects of attention rather than of derision.
4. Torture found no place or rationale?
In increasing numbers, poll results imply, Americans are disheartened by the real and existing Presidency, and no small number also feel regret that Gore – the winner in 2000 of the popular vote by more than half a million ballots, the almost certain winner of any reasonable or consistent count in the state of Florida – ended up the target of what it is not an exaggeration to call a judicial coup d’état.
The New Yorker on Al Gore
According to the Associated Press and other news organizations and oddsmakers, Gore’s film on global warming, “An Inconvenient Truth,” is the odds-on favorite to win the Oscar tonight for best documentary.
If the oddsmakers are right, it might also give a boost to the recruit Al Gore for President campaign.
We will be watching – and wish him well.