ThinkProgress
ThinkProgress Logo

Economy

Dick Armey’s FreedomWorks Super PAC Blasts Orrin Hatch For Debt Limit Increases Armey Voted For

FreedomWorks for America's anti-Hatch publication

FreedomWorks for America's anti-Hatch publication

FreedomWorks for America, the super PAC for former Rep. Dick Armey’s (R-TX) FreedomWorks USA, just released new radio and TV ads urging the defeat of longtime Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT). The spots are the latest in a series of attacks by the group against the six-term senator, who is facing a challenge from the right in this year’s renomination process.

The new commercials note that Hatch “voted 16 times” to raise the debt limit, allowing for $7.5 trillion of the national debt. Both ads say that it’s “time to retire” the man who “wracked up half of our nation’s debt.” Watch the spots:

The group helpfully documents these 16 votes in a report available on its website. The list includes 16 votes from between February 1981 and September 2007.

Prior to joining FreedomWorks in 2003, chairman Dick Armey served nine terms in Congress. Six of those debt-limit votes took place between the time Armey was elected to the House in 1984 and his retirement at the beginning of 2003. Armey voted for at least five of those six:

  • $179.9 billion in December 1985 (House roll call #454, 99th Congress)
  • $448 billion in September 1987 (House roll call #330, 100th Congress)
  • $600 billion in March 1996 (House roll call #102, 104th Congress)
  • $450 billion in July 1997 (House roll call #241, 105th Congress)
  • $450 billion in June 2002 (House roll call #279, 107th Congress)
  • Before the 2002 debt limit increase (which passed by a 215 to 214 margin — making Armey the deciding vote, arguably), Armey gave an impassioned floor speech urging colleagues to “do what is good for America” and back the bill.

    And like Hatch, Armey helped run up the debt that necessitated those increases. In 2001, Armey helped push through a $1.35-trillion tax cut and in 2010, he urged Congress to renew this and other Bush-era tax cuts. He even argued that the 2001 tax cut wasn’t big enough. Hatch also voted for both the original tax cuts and the 2010 extension.

    Put another way, FreedomWorks for America has invested about $500,000 into attacking Hatch for having a record that is not very different from Armey’s own.

    Politics

    Rush Limbaugh Show Includes Over 5 Minutes Of Dead Air As Advertiser Exodus Continues

    Rush Limbaugh’s advertising exodus is deep into its second week, and despite the radio host’s claim that the impact of 50 companies pulling their business has been negligible, listeners in the nation’s largest media market were treated to over five minutes of radio silence where Limbaugh’s advertisers once stood today.

    There were four separate instances during this afternoon’s broadcast on WABC 770 AM in New York City where the network fell silent. During the lead in to the show, two and a half minutes of silence was broken up by a single, solitary ad before Limbaugh hit the air. Then, towards the end of the first hour of Limbaugh’s three hour program, a public service announcement was followed by an additional minute of silence before Limbaugh returned. Another minute of dead air came in hour two, and a fifth minute in hour three followed that. A spokesperson for WABC wouldn’t say whether the silence was caused due to a technical glitch or Limbaugh’s fleeing sponsors.

    As Media Matters reports, of the 86 ads that made it on the air today, 77 of them were free public service announcements donated by the Ad Council. An additional seven ads were from companies that are in the process of pulling their spots from the show, leaving just two ads during the entire three hour broadcast that were purposefully paid to appear during the program.

    NEWS FLASH

    Hate Groups Are On The Rise, Southern Poverty Law Center Finds | The number of hate groups and antigovernment organizations “in the nation has continued to grow, according to a report released Wednesday by the Southern Poverty Law Center.” At least 1,018 hate groups were operating last year, SPLC found, while the “number of groups whose ideology is organized against specific racial, religious, sexual or other characteristics has risen steadily since 2000, when 602 were identified, the center said. Antigay groups, for example, have risen to 27 from 17 in 2010″:

    Economy

    Women’s Impact On The Economy, By the Numbers

    Today is International Women’s Day, which this year is coinciding with a lot of debate on the subject of women’s rights, specifically regarding abortion, contraception and reproductive health. But it’s worth pausing for a moment to also consider the enormous contributions women are making vis-a-vis the global economy.

    The World Bank predicts that the earning power of women will hover around $18 trillion by 2014, which is $5 trillion increase in current income, and more than double the estimated GDP for growing economic forces like India and China combined. So, in celebration of International Women’s Day, let’s take a look at the contribution that women are making, while bearing in mind all of the work there’s still left to do:

    66 million: Number of American women currently in the workforce.

    64: The percentage of mothers with children under the age of 6 that are in the labor force. 78 percent of mothers with children ages 6-17 were in the labor force.

    60: The percentage of American women who are now the primary or co-breadwinner for their families.

    87: Percentage of women who possess at least four years of high school or more education, as compared to 86 percent of men.

    58: The percentage of all undergraduate degrees in the U.S. that were awarded to women in 2010.

    50: The percentage of the total college educated population women accounted for in the U.S.

    12: Number of Fortune 500 companies that have female CEOs.

    1.9 million: Number of firms that are majority-owned (51% or more) by women of color in the U.S.

    26: The percentage of vice presidents and senior executives that are female.

    7: The percentage of directors on the world’s coporate boards who are female.

    15.6: Percentage of elected parliamentary seats globally that are held by women.

    18: Average percentage by which women worldwide are paid less than their male counterparts at work.

    0.77: The female-to-male earnings ratio in the U.S., meaning female workers earned 77 cents on every dollar earned by a male worker. Progress on the pay gap in the last 10 years remains statiscally unchanged.

    Although women have been making significant strides towards gender equality in the workforce, a survey carried out by Yale Law Women highlights a major discrepancy in the growing numbers of female attorneys (25-35 percent) in comparison to the small number of who are actually partners in firms (5-15 percent).

    Fatima Najiy

    NEWS FLASH

    Poll Finds Americans Reject Republican Assault On Unions | A new Bloomberg News national poll finds that Americans believe, by a wide margin, that public sector workers should have the right to collectively bargain. 64 percent of respondents, including a plurality of Republicans, believe public workers should be able to bargain collectively for their wages, while 63 percent believe that states should not be able to break pension agreements they’ve already made. This, of course, comes after a number of Republican governors used budget woes to justify removing collective bargaining rights from public employees.

    Green

    Senate Rejects Keystone XL By Narrow Vote

    An amendment by Sen. John Hoeven (R-ND) to force immediate approval of the Keystone XL tar sands pipeline failed to get the 60 votes it needed, on a 56-42 vote. Democrats Max Baucus (MT), Begich (AK), Casey (PA), Conrad (ND), Hagan (NC), Landrieu (LA), Manchin (WV), McCaskill (MO), Pryor (AR), Tester (MT), and Webb (VA) voted with Senate Republicans to strip authority for the pipeline’s approval from the president of the United States. Despite the intensity of climate activism in the region, New England Republicans Ayotte (NH), Brown (MA), Collins (ME), and Snowe (ME) stayed with the Republican bloc in favor of the Keystone XL pipeline. The amendment was attached to the unrelated highway funding bill.

    Moments earlier, Republicans killed an amendment that would have approved the pipeline if it used American steel and kept the oil for American use.

    Update

    350.org‘s Bill McKibben responds:

    Today’s vote was a temporary victory and there’s no guarantee that it holds for the long run. But given that this thing was a ‘no brainer’ a year ago, it’s pretty remarkable that people power was able to keep working, even in the oil-soaked Senate. We’re grateful to the Administration for denying the permit and for Senate leadership for holding the line.

    The reason this fight has been so hard is because of the financial power of the fossil fuel industry, so that’s what we’re going after now. We’ve been playing defense for months, now we’ve got to quickly go on offense. Going forward, we’ll be working with the huge majorities of Americans who want to end subsidies to the fossil fuel industry. We’ve learned a lot, not all of it savory, about how the political process works and we’re going to put that to use.

    Security

    FBI Official: News Of NYPD Muslim Surveillance Program Is ‘Starting To Have A Negative Impact’

    Newark FBI Special Agent in Charge Michael Ward at a press conference.

    The recent news that the NYPD has been monitoring the communications and activities of Muslim groups in and around the tri-state area has been roundly condemned by all sides of the political spectrum, but CBS New York is reporting that criticism is also being leveled by an unexpected group: the FBI.

    According to FBI Newark Special Agent in Charge Michael Ward, the fallout from the NYPD’s surveillance program has made the FBI’s job harder than ever:

    Ward said the NYPD’s spying on mosques and Muslim businesses in the Garden State has caused sources to dry up and made the job of gathering counter terrorism intelligence much more difficult, reports CBS 2′s Marcia Kramer.

    It’s starting to have a negative impact. When people pull back cooperation it creates additional risks. It creates blind spots. It hinders our ability to have our finger on the pulse of what’s going on around the state,” Ward said.

    FBI Newark has made efforts to mend its ties with the Muslim community in New Jersey by apologizing on behalf of the NYPD’s activities, but it appears that some may not be so quick to forgive. The AP is reporting today that at least one mosque in Paterson, New Jersey has postponed a planned appearance by Ward that meant to repair trust, though would not comment on the specific reason why.

    The Newark office has also seemingly diverged from the agency’s official position on the controversy. FBI Director Robert Mueller offered praise to embattled NYPD Commissioner Raymond Kelly and said “the New York Police Department have done a remarkable job in protecting New York.”

    The FBI could not be immediately reached for a comment on Ward’s statements.

    Politics

    GOP Primary Turnout Down From 2008 And 2000 As Polls Point To Growing Enthusiasm Gap

    Romney addresses a crowd in Detroit last month

    As ThinkProgress has previously noted, Republican voter turnout was down in the early GOP primaries, suggesting a lack of enthusiasm among Republicans for their presidential candidates, and for presumed nominee Mitt Romney in particular.

    A new report out today from the Bipartisan Policy Center shows this trend continued in this week’s Super Tuesday votes, with turnout down from both 2008 and 2000(the previous year with a contested GOP primary):

    Based on final and official results from the six states whose primaries preceded Super Tuesday and near final and unofficial results from the seven Super Tuesday primaries, 7,846,172 voted out of 68,125,000 eligible citizens or 11.5 percent. Turnout in 2008 was 13.2 percent of eligibles and it was 12.2 in 2000.

    This table provides the complete date:

    A new Rassmussen poll released this week “shows that a plurality of voters have less confidence in the Republican hopefuls today than they did a month ago,” the conservative blog Town Hall notes, suggesting the situation is not improving. An astonishing 43 percent of Republicans say they still want a new candidate to enter the race; just 36 percent are satisfied with the current field.

    Meanwhile, as Gallup reported Tuesday, “Republicans are not highly satisfied with their field of candidates, and the intensity with which they view their candidates pales in comparison to the intensity Democrats have for their candidate.” Among Republican voters, Mitt Romney has a “positive intensity score” of +13 percent and Rick Santorum has a +15 percent, while Obama has a whopping +36 percent among Democratic voters. (The score measures the percentage who have a strongly favorable view of each candidate minus the percentage with a strongly unfavorable view.)

    That greater-than-double ratio is even higher than the positive favorability rating in 2008 of the Democratic candidates compared to Republican candidates at around the same time in the process, according to a Pew poll from February of that year.

    But 2012 was supposed to be a banner year for Republicans to rally against Obama. And liberals were supposed to be unenthusiastic, given the still ailing economy and unique liberal motivators in 2008 — a chance to elect the first black of female president and a hugely unpopular Republican in the White House — making the date all the more troubling for Republicans.

    At least one group of voters is turning out for Romney: the wealthy. But that may not be enough, as the candidate’s fundraising is now suffering because of its over-reliance on wealthy donors and difficulty attracting small contributors.

    Politics

    Republican Lawmaker Now Supports Obama, Says GOP Presidential Candidates ‘Would Take Women Back Decades’

    New York Assemb. Teresa Sayward (R)

    Questions about women and womens’ health have dominated the political debate over the past weeks, and at least one female Republican lawmaker is unhappy with her party’s record. New York Assemblyman Teresa Sayward (R), who is retiring after serving a decade in Albany, told the New York political program Capital Tonight that she does not support any of her party’s presidential candidates, because of their stances on women.

    She also took an apparent shot at Republicans’ opposition to President Obama’s birth control mandate, saying, “It’s disheartening for me to see our party move away from what it was always about and that is to stay out of people’s lives, let them live their lives, don’t impose their religion on anybody else.”

    Asked which Republican candidate she supports, Sayward replied:

    SAYWARD: I do not have a favorite in the presidential race, if I had to vote today, I’d vote for Obama.

    INTERVIEW: Really?

    SAYWARD: Absolutely… Because I really, truly think that the candidates that are out there today for the Republican side would take women back decades.

    Watch it:

    Sayward said she was retiring for personal reasons, as well as because of her belief in term limits.

    Sayward said she got her start in politics when she attended a local farmers’ meeting and was told women were to gather in the kitchen while men discussed business. “I didn’t come here to sit in the kitchen,” Sayward remembers saying, recounting how she soon integrated the meetings.

    Health

    Texans Rally Against Defunding Of Planned Parenthood, Which Would Leave 130,000 Without Health Care

    Conservative lawmakers in Texas worked to chip away at Planned Parenthood’s funding, creating a “tiered priority system” that ensured Planned Parenthood clinics would be the last to receive any Title X funding. But when faced with renewing the Women’s Health Program, which funds preventive care for low-income women using federal and state money, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services officials warned Texas that their plan to zero out Planned Parenthood violated the Social Security Act. And if Texas blacklisted Planned Parenthood, then HHS would cut off almost $40 million in Medicaid funds for Texas.

    But Texas Health Commissioner Tom Suehs did just that, finalizing the push to defund Planned Parenthood. Last month, he signed a rule that “formally bans Planned Parenthood clinics and other ‘affiliates of abortion providers’” from receiving funds from the joint state-federal Women’s Health Program (WHP) — losing $9 from the federal government for every $1 Texas put into the program.

    Now, about 130,000 Texas women will lose their access to preventive health care, and women in the state rallied against the rule, which goes into effect on March 14, to voice their anger:

    I just got fed up,” [Marcia] Ball said. “I suspected there were many people like me, including Christians and people of all ages, who think it’s a mistake to defund low-income women’s basic health care. All this defunding for political gain is hurting hundreds of thousands of low-income women.”

    The rally drew progressive political activists, local musicians, state representatives and women’s health clinic employees. Passing cars honked in support as protesters held up signs with slogans such as “Don’t Mess with Texas Women” and “I’m a Christian and I Believe in Science, Birth Control, and Tolerance.”

    “I’ve been protesting [for women’s rights] since the ’60s and ’70s, when I was at UT,” said Anita Quintanilla. “I thought by the ‘80s, we wouldn’t have to be protesting for women’s rights. I have a 21-year-old daughter, and I hoped she wouldn’t have to worry about women’s rights. I’m fighting for her.” [...]

    State Rep. Elliott Naishtat, D-Austin, was among those who helped Ball with the rally.

    “This will definitely send a signal to members of the Legislature and Congress that it’s going to be hard to pass these cuts and policy changes in the future without facing opposition from women and their friends,” Naishtat said.

    A spokeswoman for Texas Gov. Rick Perry (R) laid the blame at the feet of the Obama administration. “Although federal law allows the states to set the criteria for qualified providers in Medicaid programs, now the Obama Administration is holding the WHP hostage because Texas state law does not fit its pro-abortion agenda,” the spokeswoman said. Other conservatives have suggested that if Planned Parenthood really cared about women’s health, then it would leave WHP so the program could continue providing health care through other providers.

    But it’s the poor women of Texas, at risk of losing their access to affordable health care, who really will suffer without this program. “Texas Republicans never miss an opportunity to throw the most vulnerable Texans under the bus so that they can pick a fight with the federal government,” said Rebecca Acuña, a spokeswoman for the Texas Democratic Party.

    Media

    Limbaugh’s Latest Female Target: ‘B-i-itchy’ Washington Post Writer

    After targeting Georgetown Law student Sandra Fluke last week and journalist Tracie McMillan this week, Limbaugh turned his sights on Washington Post comedy writer Alexandra Petri today. Petri wrote a column for the Post’s comedy section yesterday, but Limbaugh apparently had a bit of an Onion problem and assumed Petri was a reporter, not a satirist.

    Limbaugh attacks the “so-called reporter” (she’s not actually called that) for inserting her “b-i-itchy opinion” into her “reporting” (which was not actually reporting). Again, Limbaugh apparently can’t help but use gendered slurs to attack his female critics. Listen to the audio via Media Matters:

    Update

    Petri responded to Limbaugh in a characteristically funny blog post, acknowledging that she had her facts wrong on a potential Limbaugh advertiser, and offering to buy him a sandwich as a peace offering. “As ways to start the day, I prefer coffee. In fact, I prefer root canals,” she wrote of the attack. “Having my work called ‘b-i-itchy’ and ‘an out-and-out lie’ was not how I expected to spend International Women’s Day. Usually, I spend International Women’s Day completely ignoring the fact that it is International Women’s Day,” she added.

    • Comment Icon

    Justice

    Breitbart’s ‘Bombshell’: The President Still Fights For Racial Equality

    Harvard Professor Derrick Bell (1930 – 2011)

    Breitbart.com and Fox News believe that President Obama’s affiliation with the late Harvard professor Derrick Bell, as evidenced from a hug they share in a video from 1990, is some kind of “smoking gun” for his perspectives on “racial division and class warfare.” Bell was the first tenured African-American law professor at Harvard University and helped establish the study of Critical Race Theory (CRT). This morning, Breitbart.com editor Joel Pollak appeared on CNN to repeat this claim, but Soledad O’Brien was quick to point out that he had absolutely no understanding of CRT and that the clip presented no “bombshell” for the President:

    O’BRIEN: What part of that was the bombshell? Because I missed it, I don’t get it. What was the bombshell?

    POLLACK: Well, the bombshell is the revelation of the relationship between Obama and Derrick Bell—

    O’BRIEN: Okay, so he’s a Harvard law student and a Harvard law professor. Yeah?

    POLLACK: That’s correct. And Derrick Bell is “the Jeremiah Wright of academia.” He passed away last year, but during his lifetime he developed a theory called Critical Race Theory, which holds that the Civil Rights Movement was a sham and that White Supremacy is the order and it must be overthrown. Barack Obama was—

    O’BRIEN: I’ll stop you there for a second and then I’m going to let you continue, but that is a complete misreading of Critical Race Theory. As you know, that’s an actual theory and you could Google it and someone would give you an good definition, so that’s not correct.

    Watch it:

    Critical race theory does not have an absolute set of principles, but later in the interview O’Brien accurately describes it as a theory that “looks into the intersection of race and politics and the law.” CRT emerged from a broader movement known as critical legal studies, which examines how factors such as race, gender and social class can often skew legal decisions in favor of privileged groups. Critical legal theory is, by definition, critical of how our law has developed and often calls for significant departures from existing law—but its central premise that judges are prone to decide cases in ways that advantage their own social group has certainly been vindicated by cases such as Citizens United.

    CRT looks specifically at how race and racial privilege shapes the law. The purpose of CRT isn’t to wage war against white people, as Pollak and others of his anti-liberal ilk would have us believe. Indeed, its entire goal is to ensure that race not be forgotten as a significant factor in the operation of society. The value of this perspective is certainly demonstrated through voter ID laws, immigration policies, and drug enforcement penalties that disproportionately impact non-white populations. Policies that target racial majorities, by contrast, would never become law in the first place because the majority possesses the power to veto them.

    The President should be applauded for standing with great minds who do not accept that the Civil Rights Act of 1964 marked an endpoint in the fight for racial equality. It is those who seek to disregard the experiences of all people of color — lest they confront the persisting effects of racial injustice — who should be ashamed.

    • Comment Icon

    Justice

    After Wisconsin Voters Revolt Against GOP Lawmakers, GOP Lawmakers Approve Amendment Preventing Recall Elections

    The Wisconsin GOP has not worn well with that state’s voters. Two GOP senators were removed from office last year in a recall election, and as many as four more could lose their jobs this year — along with the state’s anti-union Gov. Scott Walker (R).

    Rather than accept that these mass recalls are a sign that they should abandon their current policies and pursue effort that won’t incur such ire from the electorate, however, the Wisconsin GOP has decided to pursue a very different tactic — changing the rules of the game:

    In the face of an expected recall election targeting Gov. Scott Walker and four Republican state senators, the Wisconsin state Assembly voted Tuesday to amend the state constitution to make it more difficult to toss an official from office.

    The measure, which still faces major hurdles before taking effect, would allow officeholders to be recalled only if they have been charged with a serious crime or if there is a finding of probable cause that they violated the state code of ethics. [...]

    Republican supporters, including the amendment’s sponsor Rep. Robin Vos, R-Caledonia, argued changes are needed to limit recalls given the flurry of such efforts over the past year. Republicans have said Walker and the others are being unfairly targeted simply for doing their job.

    For the record, Scott Walker’s job is to serve the very people who have decided that he is doing such a terrible job of it that he needs to be fired immediately.

    • Comment Icon

    Media

    RushLimbaugh.com Removes Offensive Attacks On Sandra Fluke From Transcript Archives

    For days, conservative radio host Rush Limbaugh personally attacked Georgetown Law student and women’s health advocate Sandra Fluke, smearing her at least 70 times. Now, he’d like to pretend that some of the things he said never actually happened.

    The Atlantic Wire points out that his website has scrubbed a few offensive comments. While the “slut” comments still show up in other rants by Limbaugh, his site has removed his sex tapes comment from March 1. “The pages were clearly working a few days ago — several sites linked to them,” Elspeth Reeve reports. “The pages don’t show up on the February 29 and March 1 archives, either, though links to them still exist on other transcripts related to the controversy.” Here’s the blank archives page for February 29:

    Limbaugh may want to scrub some of his insulting remarks from the historical record, but they will not be forgotten. ThinkProgress has preserved Limbaugh’s sex tape comments on video here.

    Limbaugh issued an apology to Fluke on March 3, and apologized on air on March 5. But in between, he has continued to attack Fluke and even turned his wrath on female journalist Tracie McMillan as well. Meanwhile, advertisers continue to abandon Rush Limbaugh’s show, with more than 40 dropping their ads since his attacks against women began.

    • Comment Icon

    NEWS FLASH

    Anti-Gay Group Abandons Failed Boycott Of JCPenney And Ellen DeGeneres | One Million Moms was outraged that JCPenney would affiliate itself with a “high-profile homosexual entertainer” like Ellen DeGeneres, but its attempt to boycott the store has fizzled. Director Monica Cooley believes “only time will tell,” because the group is now moving on to other issues that require its attention. The group’s boycott of Toys ‘R’ Us has also failed miserably — the Archie Comics issue they objected to because of its same-sex wedding sold out.

    Health

    Georgia Female Legislators Stage Walk Out To Protest Anti-Abortion And Contraception Bills

    Accusing the GOP of waging a war against women, the Democratic women of the Georgia senate staged a walk out yesterday to protest two measures that would significantly limit access to abortion services and contraception. The bills, passed yesterday, prohibit state employees from using their state health benefits to pay for abortions and stipulate that “employees of private religious institutions have no right to demand that their insurance policies pay for contraceptives, as the Obama Administration wants to require.”

    “What we’re seeing here,” Sen. Nan Orrock said, “is an ideological battle that’s being waged to make women a target, to take our access to our Constitutional right of privacy and also our ability to make our health decisions with our doctor and our own best judgment. And it’s government intruding into that decision. The origins of this bill are ideological, it’s coming from an extreme, right, fundamental point of view. And that doesn’t bode well for women in Georgia.” Watch a local news story:

    Republican Sen. Josh McKoon insisted that “the war that’s being waged is on a religious minority in this country that has strong beliefs” and predicted that both measures would pass the House, where the GOP has control.

    The Guttmacher Institute estimates that “about 430 abortion restrictions that have been introduced into state legislatures this year, which is pretty much in the same ballpark as 2011.” Follow the key bills moving through the states, here.

    • Comment Icon

    NEWS FLASH

    Senate Armed Forces Chairman: Drop Limbaugh From Military Network | Sen. Carl Levin (D-MI), the chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, said yesterday that he would like to see the American Forces Network, which broadcasts TV and radio to American servicemen, stop carrying Rush Limbaugh’s radio program. “I would hope the people that run it see just how offensive this is and drop it on their own volition,” he told CNN. “I’d love to see them drop it, but I don’t think I’d legislate it.” “I think that is probably an issue that should be left to the folks that run that network,” Levin explained. A group of female veterans, organized by VoteVets, called on the Armed Forces Network to drop Limbaugh Monday.

    Older

    Switch to Mobile