Category Archives: Remedies

“The Supreme Court’s Accidental Revolution? The Test for Permanent Injunctions”

By: Mark P. Gergen, John M. Golden & Henry E. Smith have written this article for the Columbia Law Review.  The article discusses how the Court, perhaps inadvertently, changed the test for permanent injunctions in the eBay case.  It is an issue I address in my forthcoming Emory Law Journal article, Anticipatory Overrulings, Invitations, Time Bombs, and Inadvertence: How Supreme Court Justices Move the Law, Emory Law Journal (forthcoming 2012) (draft available).

Share
Posted in Remedies | Comments Off

Pam Karlan on SCOTUS and “Remedial Abridgement”

Boston Review: “Remedial abridgment is a pervasive tool of the contemporary Supreme Court.”

Share
Posted in Remedies, Supreme Court | Comments Off

Laches and election-law: “Piling on” edition

In this post, Rick pointed out one substantial downside of last-minute election claims.  I made a similar point in this Article, in the context of litigation challenging election-day burdens like lines at the polls (and citing the discussion Rick blogged about).  Where (and only where) the conditions likely to cause the problem are known well in advance, early resolution based on a probabilistic assessment of likely harm benefits the system as a whole.  (But see Crawford…)

And while Rick’s discussion here focuses on pre-election v. post-election relief, the Article above builds on Rick’s point in a different piece: even pre-election, logistical difficulties increase the later it gets in the election cycle.   (In a way, this is the second state where Perry’s involved in a pragmatic election administration mess caused by unresolved last-minute litigation, though technically, laches aren’t — and shouldn’t be — at issue in the Texas case).  The Virginia election isn’t until March 6, but absentee ballots should already have been printed, and have to be mailed in less than a week.   Even if the choice at hand doesn’t threaten to overturn the results of an election, it’s already making it more difficult to actually run the election in question.

Share
Posted in absentee ballots, ballot access, election administration, military voting, primaries, Remedies | Comments Off

Ninth Circuit, Citing Wikipedia, Proclaims Elvis “the King” and Explains the Meaning of “Elvis Has Left the Building”

More substantively, in Flexible Lifeline Systems v. Precision Lift, the Ninth Circuit reverses a longstanding circuit rule presuming irreparable harm in copyright infringement cases in which plaintiff seeking a preliminary injunction has proven likelihood of success on the merits.

Share
Posted in Remedies | Comments Off

Making Remedies Interesting

In less than two weeks, I will have another crop of Remedies students. I love teaching the course, because students come in with such low expectations as to how interesting the course will be (compared to, say, election law). Some subjects are tough to make interesting, such as how to execute on a valid judgment. This Daily Show story about a couple executing on a bank does a pretty good job. I’ll be showing it to my students.

Share
Posted in Remedies | Comments Off