The disaster we have yet to face
Jacques Attali finds disturbing similarities between the financial tsunami and the climate crisis we
By Jacques Attali Published 09 October 2008A good chess player plays several moves in advance. Today, it is important to anticipate the path of the current financial crisis and ensure that what has begun does not become even more brutal in 20 years' time.
But it is even more important to ask ourselves what the economic crisis reveals about our ability to control all our tsunamis, financial and otherwise. Foremost is the worst imaginable tsunami: an uncontrollable disruption of climate leading to panic and instability of the kind we are currently experiencing.
For the stakes of such a climate crisis are high. The current financial tsunami will, at worst, provoke a major recession, whereas a climatic tsunami will, at worst, destroy humanity. Am I exaggerating? No. First, the data: the cost of the ecological impact of CO2 emissions from countries in the Northern Hemisphere from these "toxic products" - to employ a phrase that has been used to describe financial derivatives - has been put at $3trn, perhaps more than the losses that will arise from the financial crisis. This ecological impact will only grow, and with it the effect on temperatures, on oceans, on glaciers, on storms.
If climate instability accelerates as quickly as the financial crisis has unfurled, if we discover, as in the case of the economy, that not only is there no pilot in the aeroplane, but there is not even a pilot's cabin, then at a certain point the trends could become irreversible. We could even find ourselves in a situation where the global increases in temperature are final and where no human action can prevent the poles from melting, the deserts from growing, the sea level from rising, or hurricanes from becoming more numerous and more powerful.
Then, species of animals would disappear, life under the sea would become almost impossible, hundreds of millions of people would be forced to move, to flee deserts and coastlines, without knowing where to go. The temperature could rise so high, beyond the 4, 6, 8 degrees of which the most pessimistic hypotheses currently speak, that vast areas of the planet would become uninhabitable. Natural phenomena could disturb underwater deposits, leading to a huge release of methane into the atmosphere, asphyxiating humanity. Even the best-informed and richest would be unable to act or find refuge.
It would then be too late to lament that we hadn't listened to those who warned us, or to regret not having acted when there was still time. It would be too late to regret not having taken modest, sustainable measures that would have been enough to reverse the trends and to inaugurate a formidable period of growth based on simple available technologies that would have helped us to reduce greenhouse-gas emissions.
It may be an extreme hypothesis. But it is no more extreme than the hypothesis made by many economic experts in recent years, that a sub-prime crisis would lead to a general loss of control over financial derivatives - toxic or not - and to the total breakdown of interbank lending; to the weakening of hedge funds, of businesses, of nations and to the huge, lasting and uncontrollable global depression that now threatens.
In both cases, we find ourselves confronted by collective intelligence. Market economics is a sort of golem, or clay creature, without intent, capable of benefiting humanity, but also of destroying everything in its path because it has no concept of ethics. As with every golem, now may be the time to engage our brains, and our sense of good and evil in order to master it, before it escapes us.
Jacques Attali is a former president of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development
Translated by Daniel Trilling
Tags: Economy 2008
Comments
Latest tweets
![NewStatesman](http://library.vu.edu.pk/cgi-bin/nph-proxy.cgi/000100A/http/web.archive.org/web/20130112203944im_/http:/=2fa0.twimg.com/profile_images/569409742/ns_online_144_normal.jpg)
![c_crampton](http://library.vu.edu.pk/cgi-bin/nph-proxy.cgi/000100A/http/web.archive.org/web/20130112203944im_/http:/=2fa0.twimg.com/profile_images/2974139974/62d53e635918007fc1488e7be53902a8_normal.jpeg)
![rafaelbehr](http://library.vu.edu.pk/cgi-bin/nph-proxy.cgi/000100A/http/web.archive.org/web/20130112203944im_/http:/=2fa0.twimg.com/profile_images/2240792690/Rafael_Behr_normal.jpg)
![georgeeaton](http://library.vu.edu.pk/cgi-bin/nph-proxy.cgi/000100A/http/web.archive.org/web/20130112203944im_/http:/=2fa0.twimg.com/profile_images/1151721372/70596_61301825_7925641_n_normal.jpg)
![helenlewis](http://library.vu.edu.pk/cgi-bin/nph-proxy.cgi/000100A/http/web.archive.org/web/20130112203944im_/http:/=2fa0.twimg.com/profile_images/3029636869/2554be813c5d0124656c7cf42777d42a_normal.jpeg)
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- John Stoehr
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists
7 comments
Please refer to strangedaystrangeskies website and uaff.us and click on chemtrails. We are being poisoned by the illuminati or global elite if you prefer that term THE DOCUMENT TITLED OWNING THE WEATHER BY 2025 will bring you up to speed. The weather is God's domain and we have no business messing with it. 1229 days mol to go. We are in the Tribulation folks so prepare. Best, the remnant
There is a pattern here. It's not as if the financial crisis has just appeared out of the blue. Like climate change, general environmental degredation, the exstinction of species after species, the fossil fuel crisis, population growth and the fundamental problem of an economic system based on the ideology/dogma of limitless growth on a finite planet; the warnings have systematically been ignored and marginalized by the rich and powerful.
This is understandable as all the solutions to these problems require us to step forward and control and regulate the 'free market' and those who benefit from it. This is about power. Using the power of our economies for other purposes than simply maintaining the fabulous lifestyles of the global economic aristocracy.
For decades they have fought a 'class war' against the rest of us and they didn't care what price had to be paid, by the environment or by the poor. The only thing that mattered was the creation of more and more wealth which they had power over.
The global aristocracy live in virtual Versailles and the rest of us are really peasants oustide in the real world. These aristocrats also own and control the mass media and their values and views are massively and totally disproportionally represented considering how few of them there really are.
A powerful minority own and control the world and they've made it in their image. Ideas and problems that conflict with their interests are filtered out of the debate and only really exist on the margins. We are sold a myth, no matter what reality shows is really happening around us.
This, culture of pushing reality aside, can, of course, have absolutely terrible consequences, in the end, though ignored, reality has a habit of biting back hard.
The challenges we face as a civilization require us to definitively confront and break the power of the 'aristocracy' once and for all, and direct our energies towards solving the problems we face, rather than ignoring them.
What do you really know of about biodiversity? The challenges we face have been excerbated by the "day of the locusts" people like you!
Jacques Attali is right -- climate change and other pressing issues are far more urgent than the immediate crisis in the economy. Sure we need to get ourselves out of this financial mess, and global cooperation is needed, since the market is global and so volatile. The actions taken in the past few weeks have been unprecented and we need to see such urgent and concerted efforts to fix issues like climate change. But again it is a global problem, which needs a global solution with complete cooperation across the developed nations. We should do this, it seems we must do this, NOW.
and no doubt if GAIA does turn against us (the planet will get rid of such a destructive species itself, as illustrated above, if we do not stop our current trends), then our 'Leaders' will also be claiming "But no-one expected it to happen", just as they have claimed about the current economic chaos.
are we truly a sentient species? The NS commentators (well, many of them) give hope in that direction, but...
well, we shall see.
So Monsieur Attali how many moves ahead are you playing? And what is your game? I count 2 if’s & 4 could’s in your science fiction, fairy tale, horror story of global climate catastrophe.
All this to be cured by “modest, sustainable measures” “based on simple available technologies”? Too modest and available to be named apparently.
“an extreme hypothesis” yes, it definitely is. But no, you are wrong! It is still far more extreme than the economic expert’s hypothesis, although perhaps not more extreme than your hyperbole about “the huge, lasting and uncontrollable global depression that now threatens”.
And all this from the “former president of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development”. But if you think that contrary to the views of the most brilliant economists of the last five hundred years that we can master the golem of market economics, then perhaps we should be glad of the “former”. I am sea-sick on the tsunami’s of your rhetoric!
I am sea-sick on the tsunami’s of your rhetoric!
This guy should be writing for the New Statesamn not the usual litany of suspects. I wish I had his verbosity.
We really need real politics and we need to ask our politicians real questions next election!