Old Fashion Peanut Butter Cookies Recipes
336 recipes to browse.-
Old School Peanut Butter Cookies
cookiessnackclassic..- 2 comments
- 13 bookmarks
-
Old Fashioned Hermit Cookies
spicychewyclovesallspicecinnamonmutmegraisins- 11 comments
- 11 bookmarks
-
by
Old Fashioned Apple Butter
smellslikegrandmashousesweetapplecinnamon- 8 comments
- 16 bookmarks
-
Old Fashioned Sugar Cookies
adropsugarcookielightfluffysweet- 6 comments
- 10 bookmarks
-
by
Old Fashion Butter Cookies
cookieeasybutteryvanilla- 6 comments
- 10 bookmarks
-
Old Fashioned Sugar Cookies
cookiesoldfashionedsugarvanillabutterysugary- 3 comments
- 9 bookmarks
-
by
Old Fashioned Suger Cookies
funcheapalmondsugar- 4 comments
- 7 bookmarks
-
Old Fashion Peanut Butter Fudge
fudgepeanutbuttersugardessertsweet- 3 comments
- 13 bookmarks
-
by
Old Fashioned Sugar Cookie
cookiessugarwithpineapplewalnutslemoncookie- 3 comments
- 4 bookmarks
-
by
Old Fashioned Sugar Cookies
easysidedessertscookiessugarlemonsweetsugarylemony- 1 comments
- 3 bookmarks
-
by
Old Fashioned Tea Cookies
sugareggsmarbuttery- 1 comments
- 8 bookmarks
-
by
Old Fashioned Sugar Cookies
comfortsimpleholidaytreatssweetbutteryvanilla- 1 comments
- 3 bookmarks
-
by
Old Fashioned Sugar Cookies
lowcarbdiabeticnosugaroldfashionedcookiesaddictivenutt- 0 comments
- 6 bookmarks
-
by
Old-fashioned Peanut Cookies
double peanut goodness- 0 comments
- 0 bookmarks
Narrow your search
Cuisine Filters
Ingredient Filters
fruits
dairy
- peanut butter 232
- butter 135
- margarine 41
- creamy peanut butter 40
- milk 35
- unsalted butter 29
- chunky peanut butter 18
- crunchy peanut butter 17
- peanut butter cups 15
- peanut butter chips 12
- smooth peanut butter 11
- butter flavoring 6
- miniature peanut butter cups 5
- evaporated milk 4
- butter flavor shortening 3
- heavy cream 3
- salted butter 3
- sour cream 3
- whipping cream 3
- sweetened condensed milk 2
- whipped cream 2
- almond butter 1
- butter flavor crisco 1
- butter flavor extract 1
- canned milk 1
- dry milk 1
- low-fat margarine 1
- natural-style peanut butter 1
- nonfat dry milk powder 1
- powdered milk 1
- reduced-fat peanut butter 1
- smart balance butter spread 1
- soy yogurt 1
- vegan margarine 1
- whole milk 1
- View More ↓
- flour 111
- all-purpose flour 53
- whole wheat flour 10
- unbleached all purpose flour 5
- self rising flour 3
- unbleached flour 3
- wheat flour 3
- almond flour 1
- bread flour 1
- pastry flour 1
- rice flour 1
- tapioca flour 1
- white flour 1
- View More ↓
- chocolate chips 24
- chocolate 22
- semisweet chocolate 13
- cocoa 9
- milk chocolate chips 9
- semi-sweet chocolate chips 9
- sweet chocolate 8
- milk chocolate 7
- unsweetened cocoa powder 6
- baking chocolate 4
- chocolate chip cookies 3
- cocoa powder 3
- bittersweet chocolate chips 2
- chocolate cake mix 2
- chocolate wafer cookies 2
- dark chocolate 2
- unsweetened baking chocolate 2
- unsweetened cocoa 2
- white chocolate chips 2
- baking cocoa 1
- bittersweet chocolate 1
- chocolate candy bars 1
- chocolate frosting 1
- chocolate pudding mix 1
- chocolate sprinkles 1
- dark chocolate chips 1
- hershey's chocolate kisses 1
- mini chocolate chips 1
- miniature chocolate chips 1
- semisweet baking chocolate 1
- semisweet chocolate chunks 1
- white chocolate 1
- View More ↓
- eggs 222
- sugar 212
- baking soda 149
- brown sugar 104
- baking powder 65
- cookies 45
- light brown sugar 28
- shortening 18
- chips 18
- powdered sugar 17
- vegetables 15
- dark brown sugar 14
- honey 13
- rolls 13
- oats 12
- nuts 10
- rolled oats 10
- oatmeal 9
- vegetable shortening 6
- egg whites 6
- cream cheese 6
- quick oats 5
- light corn syrup 5
- confectioners' sugar 5
- View More ↓