*dun dun
After 10 years of evading the justice system, my time finally came. I was summoned to Jury Duty.
Most people told me what to expect when I showed up to the courthouse, “Oh, honey, bring a good magazine. You’ll be waiting around aaalllllll day.” “You should bring your laptop, they have wi-fi at the court.” “You call ahead the night before and you might not have to go.”
Thanks for the advice random people.
Thanks for NOTHING!
I called the night before and the automated voice with the Brooklyn accent said “you WILL need to attend tomorrow”.
Okay fine.
The first part was spot on… waiting around in a huge room with a ton of potential jurors. They explained to us how to properly complete the forms we were given, as if we were 2nd graders who didn’t understand English. (My forms were already filled out per instruction).
They told us that the courts were busy that day and that we all would get put on a case. (I honestly don’t really know what that means/entails at this point)
My name was called with about 45 others and we were told to meet in this hallway “near the drinking fountain”. They called role and then moved us to another courthouse across the street.
More rooms, more waiting around and then BOOM, all of a sudden we are in a courtroom. Just like that. There is a judge, and attorneys and a defendant.
This is jury selection.
They explain the case to us. My mouth dropped open and my heart stopped when they told me it was a Murder Trial.
WHAT?!?!? No divorce court? No property dispute? No car accident? This is Brooklyn. This is murder.
After questioning groups of us in the jury box, I was feeling pretty good about not getting called. I didn’t say that much and they were choosing 15 people (including alternates)out of about 50.
Boy was I wrong. I was selected as Juror #11.
I spent the next five days in court. It was kind of surreal. My courtroom experience consisted of episodes of Law & Order, movies like Legally Blonde, My Cousin Vinny and Chicago.
It definitely felt more like Law & Order (no Razzle Dazzle here).
Most of the day was spent waiting in the jury room. But I didn't mind so much because we had an awesome view of the city
Exhibit A:
The attorneys presented their evidence and pleaded their case to us. About day 3 I was really curious what the District Attorney actually had on this guy, because the evidence presented thus far did not even suggest that the defendant was at the crime scene, let alone commit the crime!
I don’t want to talk too much about the case, but in the end, the DA’s office did not do enough to prove that the defendant was guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. I firmly believe, based on the evidence presented to me, that he was not guilty.
We went into deliberations on day 5 and up until this point we had not been able to discuss the case with one another. I was interested in what other people were thinking. We discussed the case and it was unanimous right away. We did discuss elements of the case over lunch, then voted on it.
We went back into court, where the foreman read the verdict. I was really nervous for some reason. I knew we made the right decision, but still for some reason I felt the weight of the situation and it made me very anxious.
After he read the verdict, we were carted off back to our jury room, got our stuff and left. That was it.
It was so weird just leaving after spending days of getting to know these characters. I think I wanted more closure. I wanted to see what was happening inside the courtroom. I want to know who actually committed the murders. I want to know all the things that they couldn’t tell us in court.
Regardless, I felt proud to do my civic duty. And I do feel like justice was served… at least for this innocent man wrongly accused of murder.