Acne Scarring

The patient is a 26 year old man who presents to the office for evaluation of acne. He has struggled with acne on the face, back and chest since for over 6 years. He was previously prescribed a few different antibiotics over the past few years, however none of them have provided significant improvement in his acne. He had reactions to minocycline and doxycycline and therefore, his dermatologist recommended he stay away from these medications. Otherwise, he is a healthy man without any other concerns.

On exam, the patient has severe hypertrophic scarring on the chest and back. He has a couple active erythematous cysts on the back, chest and neck.

Assessment and plan: Hypertrophic and keloidsl acne scarring is difficult to treat. We  wonder if isotretinoin will trigger more scarring or whether it may actually help him.

Questions:

Is there a value to starting him on isotretinoin? With Prednisone?

His previous dermatologist used intralesional triamcinalone without benefit.

The patient may need to pay for procedures out of pocket; but his insurance will cover isotretinoin.

Imiquimod and Keloids

The patient is a 42 yo man who had a cyst I&D's on his mid-back four years ago. Postoperatively,  a keloidal scar developed.  It is very painful and pruritic.  He has had intralesional triamcinalone acetonide 40 mg/cc without much effect.

The lesion measures almost 4 cm in diameter, but, being sessile, the base is only ~ 2 cm wide.

Plan and Question:  We propose to shave this off and use imiquimod post-operatively as has been done with earlobe keloids.  Does anyone have any experience with this for keloids at sites other than earlobes?  Any other suggestions?  The literature on imiquimod use after keloid removal is all over the map.  One wonders whether employing imiquimod followed by judicial use of intralesional triamcinaloine might be appropriate.

5 Weeks p Shave excision: C&E, followed by imiquimod 5 days per week.  At this point we will stop the imiquimod and follow.  Patient does not live near to my office and can be seen only once a month or less frequently.

8 weeks p shave excision:  The patient stopped imiquimod 2 - 3 weeks ago and just applied Vaseline.  The wound is looking better.  There's a slightly raised area in the middle of the erythema.

6 months after surgery.  These is a subtle scar in the mid-portion of the excision.  The area is still quite pruritic.  Will try clobetasol ointment to area, Monday, Wednesday and Friday.  Scars are rich in mast cells and this likely explains the itching;

1 year follow-up shows small hypertrophic scar which is a considerable improvement over baseline.

 References:
1.  Treatment of keloid scars post-shave excision with imiquimod 5% cream: A prospective, double-blind, placebo-controlled pilot study. J Drugs Dermatol. 2009 May;8(5):455-8.  URL

2.  Successful treatment of earlobe keloids with imiquimod after tangential shave excision. Dermatol Surg. 2006 Mar;32(3):380-6.  URL

3.  Failure of imiquimod 5% cream to prevent recurrence of surgically excised trunk keloids.  Dermatol Surg. 2009 Apr;35(4):629-33.  URL

Ear Keloids and Imiquimod

We presented this patient around a year ago (she is patient # 2). The woman, now 19 years old, presented in March of 2008 for a keloidal scar in the left triangular fossa. On 12/18/08 based on suggestions and a report in MEDLINE, the lesion was shave excised and a week after surgery, imiquimod was applied nightly for six weeks. She is now one month out after stopping imiquimod. At this point, she looks very good. We will have to see if this is a long term solution.

Reference:
1. Berman B, Kaufman J. Pilot study of the effect of postoperative imiquimod 5% cream on the recurrence rate of excised keloids. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2002 Oct;47(4 Suppl):S209-11.
New adjunctive treatments are needed to reduce the high recurrence rates (50%) of excised keloids. Interferon alfa injections have been shown to decrease the size of stable keloids. This study examined the effects of postoperative imiquimod 5% cream on the recurrence of 13 keloids excised surgically from 12 patients.Starting on the night of surgery, imiquimod 5% cream was applied for 8 weeks. Patients were examined at weeks 4, 8, 16, and 24 for local erythema, edema,
erosions, pigment alteration, and/or recurrence of keloids. Of the 11 keloids evaluated at 24 weeks, none (0%) recurred. Incidences of hyperpigmentation were 63.6%. Two cases of mild irritation and superficial erosion cleared withtemporary discontinuation of imiquimod. Both patients completed the 8 weeks of topical therapy and the final 24-week assessment. At 24 weeks, the recurrence rate of excised keloids treated with postoperative imiquimod 5% cream was lower than recurrence rates previously reported in the literature.

Double Helix

We often see problems for which there may be no simple solution. Ear lobe keloids are encountered with regularity; but keloids of the helix and triangular fossae are unusual. Some of you may have a simple trick for patients like these:

Patient # 1.
Abstract: 25 yo woman with ear keloid.

HPI: This 25 yo Asian woman pierced the triangular fossa of her right ear 2 years ago and developed a keloid which is pruritic and whose appearance bothers her.

O/E:


Patient # 2
As I was getting case # 1 ready to publish on this site, a second patient presented for evaluation and treatment.
This is a 16 yo girl with a one year history of a keloid of the left triangular fossa. She had a professional piercing done two years ago. This lesion is painful.




This patient had an "Industrial Piercing" with a 14 guage stainless steel rod.

Comment: Earlobe keloids are commonly seen and reported. But I could find no helpful articles about helix and triangular fossa keloids. I suspect that these lesions are not rare, since I have seen two in a few weeks in a small New England town. Perhaps, these are harbingers of an epidemic! One of these young women pierced her own ear, and the other was a professional job.

Questions:
These can not be simply excised and then injected with TAC like the more common ear lobe keloid. Wound closure would be problematic.
How would you approach these women?
Any role for shave excision followed by imiquimod?
Do you think TAC alone will work? 20 mg per cc, 40 mg per cc?
Does anyone have experience with similar lesions?